Print from Airliners.net discussion forum
http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/aviation_photography/read.main/195174/

Topic: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: Jderden777
Posted 2005-08-03 03:48:08 and read 4145 times.

First of all let me say that I am extremely glad that there were no fatalities in today's accident at YYZ. It is amazing that all those people got out alive, and without any serious injuries (or so they say). In the wake of today's accident at YYZ, I don't want to sound insensitive at all but I am a bit curious about something.

I was at the flight school today when I got a phone call from my father telling me to turn on the news if I could, that an AF jet ran off the runway at YYZ and was on fire. I turned on the TV there at the school and it was already on CNN news and they were showing the image from the traffic camera across the 401 from the airport of the burning airplane. They also proceeded to show a picture of an AF A340 from the spot near the // taxiways at CDG. I almost instantly recognized it as being familiar to me, and I thought it may have been either mine or Chris Liao's photo here on a.net. I only saw it for a second or two before they removed the picture, so I didn't get a real good look at it and the photo wasn't my main concern at the time. However, if anyone else saw it on CNN today and if you thought it looked like one of these....please let me or Chris know. I thought it looked more like the K64 slide but I am not sure.

View Large View Medium
Click here for bigger photo!

Photo © Christopher Liao - Spot This!
View Large View Medium
Click here for bigger photo!

Photo © Jonathan Derden - Spot This!


Again I don't want to sound insensitive to the matter, but after all if CNN did post one of these photos, it is still a copyright violation, regardless of the accident that occurred.

Thanks
JD

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: AGD
Posted 2005-08-03 04:11:09 and read 4133 times.

Not sure but I think I saw this picture as well...


View Large View Medium
Click here for bigger photo!

Photo © Hongyin Huo



...serving as a background.

Not sure which channel it was tho, but something's telling me it was on CNN as well. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe Hongyin could confirms, or not.

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: TACAA320
Posted 2005-08-03 04:24:48 and read 4128 times.

If they posted ANY of those pics without copyright's owner permission its indeed a violation of law. But in the previous posts I don't see any "I'm sure, it was my picture...".

I know that the title of this thread is "Possible..." but I think its better to be sure before making any accusation against any serious News Channel like CNN.

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: Jderden777
Posted 2005-08-03 04:37:04 and read 4121 times.

TACAA320:

thank you for your help in the matter. your post has done wonders for me in my search to determine whether or not one of these pictures was used. so what if i'm not 100% sure, that's what i'm trying to figure out....thats why i requested the help of others, because unless someone else saw it i won't know for sure. heaven forbid i ever get another feeling that one of my pics (or one of my friend's pics) may have been used without my permission  Yeah sure

jd

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: TACAA320
Posted 2005-08-03 04:39:08 and read 4119 times.

Quoting Jderden777 (Reply 3):
thank you for your help in the matter.

Your welcome.

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: EZEIZA
Posted 2005-08-03 05:23:41 and read 4106 times.

They definitely showed an a-net picture on CNN Latin America, but it was for a few seconds and the image was way too small to be able to see the copyright bar, but it was for sure from a.net. Don't know if it was your pic, but it's obviously some a.net photog that might want to look into the matter

Quoting Jderden777 (Thread starter):
First of all let me say that I am extremely glad that there were no fatalities in today's accident at YYZ

I am still amazed how no one perished in an accident like this one. Well done to the crew and to the emergency response at the airport!

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: N317AS
Posted 2005-08-03 05:36:38 and read 4098 times.

Start by recording CNN. They could so easily blow the tape away or cut it out. If you have it on tape, there's no chance of that.

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: Sulman
Posted 2005-08-03 10:09:25 and read 4068 times.

If they did use them without permission, you must follow it up, without a doubt. I'm not sure whether a photographer would charge in a situation like this (there is inevitably a morality question regarding the use of an image featuring an accident aircraft) however it demonstrates a pretty poor ethic on the media's part if they are stealing images - copy deadlines are no excuse.

Thanks to resources like airliners.net, there is - it's quite safe to say - an unprecedented, rich archive of aircraft photographs that everyone has access to. Just ten years ago there is no way the media would have been able to retrieve a comprehensive pictorial record of an aircraft so quickly.


James

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: ChrisH
Posted 2005-08-03 10:22:12 and read 4061 times.

This wouldn't be the first time CNN pulls this stunt. When the Kish F50 crashed they used Olaf Jurgensmeier's photo of it. I got an e-mail once saying my pic of an SAA 744 was used in their "business traveller" program. I had no way of catching that show myself. All e-mails sent to CNN were stonewalled.

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: CV747
Posted 2005-08-03 10:39:54 and read 4056 times.

Quoting TACAA320 (Reply 2):
I know that the title of this thread is "Possible..." but I think its better to be sure before making any accusation against any serious News Channel like CNN.

CNN a serious Channel !!! I don't think so. I had the possebility to compare live journalism yesterday on several news channels. CNN is lousy quality. they just blast anything out and nothing is verified. (OK, its still better then the propaganda from Fox News...)

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: BigPhilNYC
Posted 2005-08-03 10:50:48 and read 4052 times.

It would be tough to get a screenshot of the televised newscast.

I would actually jsut email them and say that you believe they used your photo without permission. See what they say. Couldn't hurt and you can more easily sniff out the bullshit.

-Phil

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: TACAA320
Posted 2005-08-03 15:41:17 and read 4001 times.

Quoting CV747 (Reply 9):
CNN a serious Channel !!! I don't think so. I had the possebility to compare live journalism yesterday on several news channels. CNN is lousy quality.

Everybody is entitle to their own opinion.

And yes, I ever think that CNN is a serious and reliable news channel.

[Edited 2005-08-03 16:01:30]

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: EZEIZA
Posted 2005-08-04 02:03:18 and read 3947 times.

Quoting TACAA320 (Reply 11):
And yes, I ever think that CNN is a serious and reliable news channel.

Maybe not the most reliable, but for sure among the top. CNN is usually the first news channel I check whenever major events happen. For deeper analysis, I then usually go to BBC

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: N317AS
Posted 2005-08-04 06:13:54 and read 3916 times.

Quoting BigPhilNYC (Reply 10):
It would be tough to get a screenshot of the televised newscast

Not a screenshot Phil, but a tape. The way they re-broadcast stories, set your VCR to tape CNN for 8 hours. Almost a sure bet it would come up again.

Bill

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: TACAA320
Posted 2005-08-04 06:18:50 and read 3916 times.

Quoting EZEIZA (Reply 12):
For deeper analysis, I then usually go to BBC

Indeed a quite serious and responsible one is BBC. Do doubt about it.

I just want to point out that CNN is serious business. They don't give 100% accurate aviation news? Maybe yes. But most of the time is a reliable one.

Regards,

Topic: RE: Possible Copyright Violation - Need Your Help
Username: DB777
Posted 2005-08-04 07:04:23 and read 3915 times.

Last February three TV stations in the Noo Yawk area used a pre-crash image from my website of the CL-600 that ran off the end of the runway at Teterboro.

The first station called me for permission and we worked out a price. I spread the word to a couple of buddies of mine in the NY area and one or two of them soon tipped me off that WABC-TV was using my image on their broadcasts.

Fortunately their website had video of the broadcasts with my image used behind their announcer and I got a few screen shots of it. They didn't even remove my name that was printed on the image.

Later that night I went to WCBS-TV's website out of curiousity and I found more video with my shot used behind their announcer, again with my name printed on the photo. I sent both stations invoices with prints of the screen shots, via FedEx so I would have confirmation of delivery time and who signed for the envelopes. I also sent an 8x10 print to the U. S. Copyright Office to register the image with them, which allows added benefits if they didn't pay up and I took them to court.

WCBS-TV paid in May and Disney/WABC-TV News paid last month (5 damn months!) It was well worth pursuing the matter.


The messages in this discussion express the views of the author of the message, not necessarily the views of Airliners.net or any entity associated with Airliners.net.

Copyright © Lundgren Aerospace. All rights reserved.
http://www.airliners.net/