Print from Airliners.net discussion forum
http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/aviation_photography/read.main/274989/

Topic: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: 797
Posted 2007-04-15 22:16:37 and read 4653 times.

Hello guys,

Well, a good friend of mine (A.net photographer) asked me to help him choose between these two magnificent brands as his father is about to open a business on aviation photography down here in Venezuela. He is a profesional photographer and needs help on choosing between the following combinations:


  • Nikon D200

    AF-S VR DX Zoom Nikkor 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6G ED-IF

    AF-S VR Nikkor 70-300mm f/4.5-5.6G ED-IF


  • Nikon D200

    AF-S VR DX Zoom Nikkor 18-200mm f/3.5-5.6G ED-IF


  • Nikon D80

    AF-S VR DX Zoom Nikkor 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6G ED-IF

    AF-S VR Nikkor 70-300mm f/4.5-5.6G ED-IF

  • Canon EOS 30D

    18-55 kit lens

    Canon EF 70-200mm f/4L USM

  • Canon EOS 30D

    18-55 kit lens

    Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6 IS USM



One other thing he'd like to know is if it's woth to get the pair of lenses Nikkor 18-135 and 70-300 or if it's better to get only the 18-200. Which one's better?

Finally, he also has in mind the Olympus E510 with the Olympus 14-42 kit lens and the Olympus 50-200mm Zuiko Digital f/2.8-3.5 ED. I told him not to go for it, but I ain't no expert.

Well, thanks for your help and thanks in advance!!!

Cheers!

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Sluger020889
Posted 2007-04-15 22:26:36 and read 4646 times.

IMO, a "pro" photographer shouldn't need help with this question, and I hope he doesn't plan to make a living off this because not to many can pull it off.

As for the combos above, it all depends on where he will be shooting from. But I'd say the D200 and the 70-300 VR would be the best Nikon Combo. I don't shoot Canon so I'm sure someone else will jump on that side.

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Boeingfreak
Posted 2007-04-15 22:36:38 and read 4637 times.

Hi,
my equipment is all Canon so I can't comment on the Nikon gear as I don't have any experience with it.
I'd go with this set:

Quoting 797 (Thread starter):
Canon EOS 30D

18-55 kit lens

Canon EF 70-200mm f/4L USM

The 70-200 F4 L is a VERY good lens for its price (you can't beat Canon's L glass so forget the IS on the 70-300 and go for the 70-200), the 18-55 is the standard kit lens which is OK.

Cheers,
Florian  wave 

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: AC773
Posted 2007-04-15 23:14:47 and read 4620 times.

Quoting 797 (Thread starter):
He is a profesional photographer

1. As mentioned above, why does he need help choosing?
2. More importantly, how does he not have an SLR already?

The equipment listed above is pretty good, but anybody hoping to make a living on it is gonna want something better - something along the lines of a 100-400L, 70-200 2.8L, or some of the longer L primes.

This whole thing is very confusing.  Confused

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: StevenL
Posted 2007-04-15 23:33:00 and read 4607 times.

Nikon D200

AF-S VR DX Zoom Nikkor 18-135mm f/3.5-5.6G ED-IF

AF-S VR Nikkor 70-300mm f/4.5-5.6G ED-IF

Is what I would get. I would then upgrade to a 70-200 F/2.8 VR after I made some money though.
 Smile

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: CalgaryBill
Posted 2007-04-16 00:58:28 and read 4583 times.

If he's a pro, I'd guess he already has lenses for one brand or another's 35mm body. Might as well stick with what he's got, especially since very little of the gear listed above is "pro" quality.

I second/third/etc the comments above, if he's a pro then he should know what to look for.

B

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Photopilot
Posted 2007-04-16 02:29:51 and read 4574 times.

A pro wouldn't buy slow amateur lenses. You need fast glass of f:2.8 at least.

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Kereru
Posted 2007-04-16 02:43:04 and read 4569 times.

Quoting 797 (Thread starter):
He is a profesional photographer and needs help on choosing between the following combinations:

Being a professional I would think he should know what he wants? Buy the pro series Nikon cameras / lenses if he prefers them or Canon if he prefers that brand.

Colin  old 

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Jwenting
Posted 2007-04-17 18:47:17 and read 4431 times.

It he's a pro he'll not get much use out of the selected lenses, they're all just slightly better than junk (designed and built for price rather than optical and mechanical quality)...

As a pro he'd not want any kit offered by some camera store, but carefully select his own gear from the best he can afford (and get a bankloan if that's not the best available on the market) and order that.

He's also pretty certain to already have years of experience in photography and a decent selection of equipment, and be able to decide on his own what he needs based on that.

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Viv
Posted 2007-04-18 11:18:57 and read 4329 times.

Quoting 797 (Thread starter):
He is a profesional photographer and needs help

If he is a professional, he would not need help.

If he needs help, he should find another career.

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: StealthZ
Posted 2007-04-18 12:59:21 and read 4322 times.

Quoting Photopilot (Reply 6):
A pro wouldn't buy slow amateur lenses.

Some pros use and get excellent results from "amateur" lenses but the big difference is the pro would know WHY they were using amatuer lenses.

A pro that needed a friend to ask a forum such as this these questions is likely doing himself and all competent pros a disservice..... not in asking the question.. calling himself a pro!

Cheers

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Monteycarlos
Posted 2007-04-18 13:08:05 and read 4316 times.

Quoting StealthZ (Reply 10):
Some pros use and get excellent results from "amateur" lenses but the big difference is the pro would know WHY they were using amatuer lenses.

I'll second that... some of the stuff I have seen come from a 300D with an EF-S 18-55mm kit lens is utterly amazing. Its what people do with their equipment that matters. I am certain that a 'pro' could make any of those combinations work well.

Quoting 797 (Thread starter):
Well, a good friend of mine (A.net photographer) asked me to help him choose between these two magnificent brands as his father is about to open a business on aviation photography down here in Venezuela. He is a profesional photographer and needs help on choosing between the following combinations:

His father is a professional photographer or his son (your friend)? Either way, if he needs help deciding then there is something wrong... either he is an extremely poor decision maker or he has an extremely bad relationship with his father for not being able to ask him. Btw, a pro would probably know if they liked Canon or Nikon by the time they got round to selling photos.  Wink It seems a bit of an absurd situation.

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Jwenting
Posted 2007-04-18 18:12:51 and read 4287 times.

Quoting StealthZ (Reply 10):
Some pros use and get excellent results from "amateur" lenses but the big difference is the pro would know WHY they were using amatuer lenses.

Maybe, but he'd certainly not skimp on optics to buy a more impressive looking body, and especially never buy advertised kits recommended to him by a friend who knows so much about them he needs to ask the opinion of strangers on some internet forum...

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: UnattendedBag
Posted 2007-04-18 19:33:41 and read 4283 times.

Quoting Sluger020889 (Reply 1):
a "pro" photographer shouldn't need help with this question,



Quoting AC773 (Reply 3):
1. As mentioned above, why does he need help choosing?



Quoting CalgaryBill (Reply 5):
I second/third/etc the comments above, if he's a pro then he should know what to look for.



Quoting Kereru (Reply 7):
Being a professional I would think he should know what he wants?



Quoting Viv (Reply 9):
If he is a professional, he would not need help.

797, do you plan to respond to this, or are you going to leave everyone in the dark? Have you made a decision yet?

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: 797
Posted 2007-04-19 02:39:13 and read 4219 times.

Hehe, incredible how this whole conversation went towards the wrong road...

Ok, let's make things clear around here...

The story begun when this guy, a friend of mine who has some pictures uploaded on A.net, asked me, a forum member, if I could post on the Av. Photography forum the things you've all read.

His father is planning to open some sort of a new business where aviation photography is involved. He won't live of it. All he needs is good equipment to make his pictures the best. Thus, I came to the best place on earth where air-geeks like us provide useful info.

He is an architect and has some studies in photography, I may have mistaken on the 'professional' title, but anyways, I think is kind off-topic to get in this kind of discussion.

Quoting UnattendedBag (Reply 13):
797, do you plan to respond to this, or are you going to leave everyone in the dark? Have you made a decision yet?

Sorry bud, I was traveling and had no access to the net. But yes, I've answered above.

Thanks for your help buds!

797

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Sluger020889
Posted 2007-04-19 16:17:48 and read 4175 times.

Quoting 797 (Reply 14):
All he needs is good equipment to make his pictures the best.

That won't do it, I've seen some pretty horrible stuff come from a 30D and a 70-200 f/2.8 L IS, and on the other hand I've seen some great stuff come from a 300D and a consumer 70-300. It all depends on who's behind the gear.

But back to your question, I believe the best combo possible, from what you've listed, would be the D200 and the 70-300 ED AFS VR . BUt I'm sure some Canon users will chime in as well.

-Joey

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Ilikeflight
Posted 2007-04-19 17:28:37 and read 4154 times.

go for the d200 with the 70-300mm lens

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Viv
Posted 2007-04-19 20:20:47 and read 4142 times.

Quoting 797 (Reply 14):
All he needs is good equipment to make his pictures the best.

If only it was that easy ...

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Monteycarlos
Posted 2007-04-20 01:01:08 and read 4115 times.

Quoting Sluger020889 (Reply 15):
BUt I'm sure some Canon users will chime in as well.

As a Canon user, I'd recommend the Nikon combination... I'd be ashamed to see this guy using Canon stuff.  Silly (Just Kidding, 797)

I'm sure he is going to enjoy any of those combinations.

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: JeffM
Posted 2007-04-20 01:18:48 and read 4113 times.

Quoting 797 (Reply 14):
All he needs is good equipment to make his pictures the best

Damn, why didn't I think of that?!?!

Topic: RE: Nikon Vs. Canon. What Should I Get?
Username: Jwenting
Posted 2007-04-20 18:26:59 and read 4047 times.

Quoting JeffM (Reply 19):
Damn, why didn't I think of that?!?!

Like most of us you can't afford good equipment so you have to fool yourself into thinking your failures are your own fault?


The messages in this discussion express the views of the author of the message, not necessarily the views of Airliners.net or any entity associated with Airliners.net.

Copyright © Lundgren Aerospace. All rights reserved.
http://www.airliners.net/