Print from Airliners.net discussion forum
http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/general_aviation/read.main/5611420/

Topic: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: miaintl
Posted 2012-11-14 17:33:29 and read 1425 times.

What is the status of AZ as an airline right now? I think it was a mistake to dehub MXP and focus on FCO. MXP is better located geographically to be a hub and spoke airport. FCO just involves backtracking for most people in Italy and Europe. Plus all the premium traffic is in Northern Italy. With everything being said what do you think the chances are for AF/KL to allow the MXP hub to be reestablished? I think MXP will compliment skyteam and CDG/AMS much better than FCO. I still dont know what purpose FCO plays in the skyteam system.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: flyyul
Posted 2012-11-14 18:44:54 and read 1431 times.

Linate would need to close to FCO-LIN flights only

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: FSDan
Posted 2012-11-14 18:50:02 and read 1439 times.

Quoting miaintl (Thread starter):
What is the status of AZ as an airline right now?

They are still an airline.  

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: QFVHOQA
Posted 2012-11-14 19:03:41 and read 1439 times.

MXP may be better located than FCO for an intra-EU hub, but FCO has higher O&D than MXP. MXP was doomed to fail when airlines were permitted to fly to LIN from within the EU. Now that the LCCs have taken over MXP, it may be too late to re-establish MXP as an AZ hub.

FCO is useful for EU-Africa flights (though I don't know how many it supports) in the same way that MAD is a better hub for EU-Africa flights than LHR is for oneworld.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: miaintl
Posted 2012-11-14 19:31:20 and read 1439 times.

Quoting QFVHOQA (Reply 3):

I dont think its too late to establish an MXP hub. The LCCs can have LIN completely to themselves and MXP can handle all the AZ and scheduled airlines operations. Plus skyteam has no need for AZ's africa flights, AF and KL both operate to all those destinations and even more. Keep in mind that the idea to close MXP came from AF, who wanted to steal AZ's northern Italian and continental Europe clientele.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: MaverickM11
Posted 2012-11-14 19:45:32 and read 1439 times.

Europe has too many hubs as it is, so adding another one, particularly one that wasn't viable before, is a challenge.

Quoting QFVHOQA (Reply 3):
MXP was doomed to fail when airlines were permitted to fly to LIN from within the EU.

  

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: miaintl
Posted 2012-11-14 20:13:57 and read 1439 times.

Quoting MaverickM11 (Reply 5):

MXP was very viable when it was a hub, it failed because AZ tried to keep FCO open and focus on a joint-hub system which was inappropriate for AZ at the time. But now that AZ has its finances in check it certainly make a MXP hub work.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: QFVHOQA
Posted 2012-11-14 21:44:42 and read 1439 times.

Quoting miaintl (Reply 6):
MXP was very viable when it was a hub, it failed because AZ tried to keep FCO open and focus on a joint-hub system which was inappropriate for AZ at the time. But now that AZ has its finances in check it certainly make a MXP hub work.

I'm not so sure AZ could make a MXP hub work. According to the old AZ, more than 50% of pax in Milan / Northern Italy did not use MXP as their gateway for flights. They instead used LIN to connect to other hubs like FRA or CDG.

Alitalia's Milan decision could destabilise sale process

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: Avianca
Posted 2012-11-14 21:53:35 and read 1439 times.

Quoting miaintl (Reply 4):
I dont think its too late to establish an MXP hub. The LCCs can have LIN completely to themselves and MXP can handle all the AZ and scheduled airlines operations. Plus skyteam has no need for AZ's africa flights, AF and KL both operate to all those destinations and even more. Keep in mind that the idea to close MXP came from AF, who wanted to steal AZ's northern Italian and continental Europe clientele.

well - what sence would make to change LIN from a high yield airport - near of the city to a LCC (who are normally not willing to pay fees etc the same way the legancy carriers are doing? btw LCC have as well scheduled operations.

Well if not for Africa (its the only real region were most European origins would need to to backtrack) - what other need would have skyteam from AZ flights?

I think NorthItaly is in general an complicate market - LH has tons of feederflights to MUC, FRA, and to all other "LH Group memmber" hubs. AF / KL to their hubs, BA to LHR/LGW, IB to MAD for SouthAmerica etc

LH was always successfull with feeding their traditional hubs with passengers from north Italy, but they failed establishing an own hub as LH Italy in MXP

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: JU068
Posted 2012-11-14 21:56:32 and read 1439 times.

Well there is also Air One in MXP which I think can do a better job than Alitalia (cost-structure). Air One had recently launched new flights and currently they operate internationally to Prague, Munich, Kiev, Belgrade, Tirana and Warsaw. They also have a total of six domestic routes. That is not that bad.

Also from what I could see you can fly from Belgrade to Milan on Air One and then connect to one of Alitalia's intercontinental flights. I guess that this will be the model used in the future.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: miaintl
Posted 2012-11-14 22:50:41 and read 1439 times.

Are AZ's long-haul flights even profitable out of FCO? I doubt they get any premium traffic plus little to no feed which is the main reason the ORD and EWR routes failed. When MXP was a hub it was a gateway to Eastern Europe and the Balkans, it gave VIE a run for its money for gateway to eastern europe. Keep in mind that Skyteam is relatively weak in Eastern Europe so MXP could be skyteam's answer to VIE. I know that some people will mention PRG and CZ, but PRG does not have any long-haul traffic to feed its Eastern Europe flights, AZ on the other the hand does.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: OOer
Posted 2012-11-15 02:15:19 and read 1440 times.

MXP is just too far outside of Milan. People don't want to drive 1-1.5 hours to get to MXP when LIN is right there. Unless LIN is reduced to intra-Italy flights only MXP will remain the airport of use for international flights (outside of Europe) and for LCC's.

Is there any room to expand LIN?

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: AirGabon
Posted 2012-11-15 02:40:58 and read 1438 times.

Quoting miaintl (Reply 10):
Keep in mind that Skyteam is relatively weak in Eastern Europe so MXP could be skyteam's answer to VIE.

Well, with OK at PRG being the biggest airport for pax number in Eastern Europe, plus RO at OTP and SU at SVO with more than 100 Airbus in fleet, I don't call that, weak...

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: kyrone
Posted 2012-11-15 03:04:07 and read 1438 times.

Quoting JU068 (Reply 9):
Well there is also Air One in MXP which I think can do a better job than Alitalia (cost-structure).

I'm lost... didnt Air One and Alitalia merge like three years ago?

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: JU068
Posted 2012-11-15 05:35:21 and read 1437 times.

Quoting kyrone (Reply 13):

They did but Air One kept its brand and operates as a lowcost airline.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: MaverickM11
Posted 2012-11-15 06:36:30 and read 1437 times.

Quoting miaintl (Reply 6):
MXP was very viable when it was a hub, it failed because AZ tried to keep FCO open and focus on a joint-hub system

Airlines don't close profitable hubs. Particularly ones that are a distant second in terms of preferred local airport.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: Rara
Posted 2012-11-15 08:12:31 and read 1435 times.

Quoting MaverickM11 (Reply 15):
Airlines don't close profitable hubs. Particularly ones that are a distant second in terms of preferred local airport.

Neither FCO nor MXP were profitable for AZ as hubs, because two hubs weren't viable for the airline. Of the two, MXP was in the stronger position to be successful in a one-hub network, but political pressure did not allow AZ to pull its long-range flights from Rome.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: jfk777
Posted 2012-11-15 08:19:39 and read 1437 times.

Linate is teh favorite feeder airport for every long haul airline in Europe. FCO is great for Rome but lousy for Italy.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: Avianca
Posted 2012-11-15 08:27:35 and read 1435 times.

Quoting miaintl (Reply 10):
Are AZ's long-haul flights even profitable out of FCO? I doubt they get any premium traffic plus little to no feed which is the main reason the ORD and EWR routes failed

FCO may have lower yield than NorthItaly but that they dont get any premium traffic? well I highly doubt this...

Anyhow I think AZ made the correct decicion to change their main operations to FCO - as they simply can not compete in a same page with the Big European carriers.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: MaverickM11
Posted 2012-11-15 10:07:15 and read 1434 times.

Quoting Rara (Reply 16):

Neither FCO nor MXP were profitable for AZ as hubs, because two hubs weren't viable for the airline. Of the two, MXP was in the stronger position to be successful in a one-hub network, but political pressure did not allow AZ to pull its long-range flights from Rome.

FCO is much larger, and MXP is riddled with LCC capacity since LIN is preferred by far. If LIN was closed MXP may have had a shot at working, otherwise FCO was and is the best option.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: delta2ual
Posted 2012-11-15 10:30:33 and read 1436 times.

Quoting miaintl (Reply 10):
Keep in mind that Skyteam is relatively weak in Eastern Europe
Quoting AirGabon (Reply 12):
Well, with OK at PRG being the biggest airport for pax number in Eastern Europe, plus RO at OTP and SU at SVO with more than 100 Airbus in fleet, I don't call that, weak...

  

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: lisbonbearuk
Posted 2012-11-15 11:41:29 and read 1433 times.

Where do AZ serve intercontinentally from MXP? Do they have a long haul crew vase there still?

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: YULWinterSkies
Posted 2012-11-15 13:56:07 and read 1432 times.

Quoting miaintl (Thread starter):
What is the status of AZ as an airline right now? I think it was a mistake to dehub MXP and focus on FCO. MXP is better located geographically to be a hub and spoke airport. FCO just involves backtracking for most people in Italy and Europe. Plus all the premium traffic is in Northern Italy. With everything being said what do you think the chances are for AF/KL to allow the MXP hub to be reestablished? I think MXP will compliment skyteam and CDG/AMS much better than FCO. I still dont know what purpose FCO plays in the skyteam system.

Backtracking depends where one is coming from. Certainly no backtracking involved for fellows flying from Africa and most of Asia going towards N and Central Europe.

Quoting Rara (Reply 16):
Neither FCO nor MXP were profitable for AZ as hubs, because two hubs weren't viable for the airline. Of the two, MXP was in the stronger position to be successful in a one-hub network, but political pressure did not allow AZ to pull its long-range flights from Rome.

MXP may be "ok" as a hub, but it just sucks in terms of o&d as it is beaten flat by LIN, which however cannot ever become a hub. AZ simply could not rely on this at MXP, while they can for FCO. Proof that a hub in the middle of nowhere (which is what MXP is, due to poor transportation options) does not work well.

Quoting jfk777 (Reply 17):
Linate is teh favorite feeder airport for every long haul airline in Europe. FCO is great for Rome but lousy for Italy.

I do not agree about FCO being lousy for Italy. FCO has a much better location for most Italians and Europeans for:
-Africa
-Middle East
-S and SE Asia
=where the money is being made on long haul flights. I see no reason to think of Europe - NAm as the milk cow and the strategic market anymore. If anything, it is where losses are being generated. Furthermore, AZ already indirectly has two hubs that serve that purpose better than MXP would ever do, for obvious geographical reasons: these are CDG and AMS, thanks to the JV with AF-KL and DL. No point having yet another one, which is a smaller airport, less conveniently located for most Europeans, and awful for o&d.
FCO is a chance for AZ, as long they don't focus on N Am (key routes can certainly work of course but that's it), and I certainly hope they eventually see FCO has a chance for expansion towards the markets mentioned above. They have nothing to win by serving overserved N Am from a mediocre (at best) hub : MXP, or a poorly located one : FCO. I see this a much better strategy than trying to expand out of MXP yet again.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: Viscount724
Posted 2012-11-15 14:06:40 and read 1432 times.

Quoting lisbonbearuk (Reply 21):
Where do AZ serve intercontinentally from MXP?

JFK, MIA, NRT, CAI.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: lisbonbearuk
Posted 2012-11-15 14:15:28 and read 1432 times.

To describe MXP as poorly connected and in the middle of nowhere is just rubbish. It sits on several major motorway corridors and has a fast connection (30 minutes or so) from downtown Milan by train. That's comparable to LHR, LGW, STN, BRU, CDG, ORY, MAD, BCN and many others.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: LINATHJNX
Posted 2012-11-15 14:49:37 and read 1486 times.

Maybe AZ will have better chances in FCO but saying that MXP is in the middle of nowhere it's totally not correct.
It is in the middle of a big industrial area that goes from Milan to Turin, there are railways and motorways that connect it to Milan easily. Of course, it is not as near to the city as LIN is, but the big problem for MXP is LIN still open.

Topic: RE: Will AZ Ever Re-establish Its MXP Hub?
Username: HB-IWC
Posted 2012-11-16 21:14:07 and read 1483 times.

Quoting lisbonbearuk (Reply 21):
Where do AZ serve intercontinentally from MXP? Do they have a long haul crew vase there still?
Quoting Viscount724 (Reply 23):
JFK, MIA, NRT, CAI

And MXP MIA service will apparently end S13.


The messages in this discussion express the views of the author of the message, not necessarily the views of Airliners.net or any entity associated with Airliners.net.

Copyright © Lundgren Aerospace. All rights reserved.
http://www.airliners.net/