Print from Airliners.net discussion forum
http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/general_aviation/read.main/5749323/

Topic: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: deaphen
Posted 2013-04-27 09:36:32 and read 32952 times.

The last two years have been very sad for Indian Aviation due to a certain airline going bust, but not only did it loose money, it completely dismembered alot of its fleet (which btw, did not belong to them).

This is a 6 year old aircraft, but looks like it is ready for the scrapyard.

All photographs are mine and taken by me, sorry for the small size.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: pennphila
Posted 2013-04-27 09:47:18 and read 32899 times.

Very sad. Owner must be upset to say the least. Hope things turn around for you guys over in India. Wish you all the best!

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: na
Posted 2013-04-27 10:06:12 and read 32730 times.

Sad, a six year old A320?
I think what Kingfisher did to those planes that dont belong to them is a criminal act or close to it. A few years back I flew on a Kingfisher A320, in good shape, and it was the most comfortable domestic plane I was on in India, ahead of Indigo, Go Air, Jetconnect, AI and Spicejet...
Well, Vijay Mallya seems to be fine off still, he arrived in his red Bentley and was proudly sitting next table when I was at a restaurant opening in Goa last weekend.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: n471wn
Posted 2013-04-27 10:15:33 and read 32657 times.

Even aircraft that can fly away from India head to the scrappers---for example Jet Connect sent two 737-700's to the scrap yard yesterday----I simply cannot understand why any lessor would do business in India

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: irish251
Posted 2013-04-27 10:56:19 and read 32449 times.

Ex-Kingfisher A320 msn 2531 (formerly VT-KFF) arrived at Dublin today from Istanbul. It is now registered EI-EYA.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: SXDFC
Posted 2013-04-27 11:06:48 and read 32349 times.

It looks like the A/C in the pictures is an A321 and not an A320..

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: irish251
Posted 2013-04-27 12:21:10 and read 31911 times.

Quoting irish251 (Reply 4):
Ex-Kingfisher A320 msn 2531 (formerly VT-KFF) arrived at Dublin today from Istanbul. It is now registered EI-EYA.

Actually this turns out to be an A319 msn 2621. It is ex-VT-KFH.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: virginblue4
Posted 2013-04-27 12:31:32 and read 31829 times.

Quoting irish251 (Reply 4):

Any idea who it's going to? Or is it being scrapped?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: irish251
Posted 2013-04-27 14:08:44 and read 31430 times.

Quoting virginblue4 (Reply 7):
Any idea who it's going to? Or is it being scrapped?

Further storage for now but I doubt there are any plans to scrap it.

EI-EYA A319-131


Dublin airliner storage, April 2013

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: heavy747
Posted 2013-04-27 18:22:42 and read 29542 times.

Quoting SXDFC (Reply 5):

It looks like the A/C in the pictures is an A321 and not an A320..

I agree. In the pic of the empty fuselage, there is a door there in between windows. A319's and A320's have window exits. The A321 is the only one equipped with 4 actual doors.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: jagflyer
Posted 2013-04-27 19:11:28 and read 28870 times.

Quoting n471wn (Reply 3):

Is the aircraft not the property of the leasing company? How can an aircraft be cannibalized like the one above without any repercussions from the leasing company? When you lease a car, you are required to bring it back with no damage or you must pay the cost to fix said damages. In this case, the plane cannot be repaired and it's original value must be reclaimed by the leasing company.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: ltbewr
Posted 2013-04-27 19:19:52 and read 28750 times.

Don't leasing companies have better monitoring of their leased aircraft ? It can't be that difficult to do so and it would be in their best interest to do so, to prevent a major devaluation of their property.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: DIJKKIJK
Posted 2013-04-27 23:51:50 and read 25756 times.

Quoting jagflyer (Reply 10):
In this case, the plane cannot be repaired and it's original value must be reclaimed by the leasing company.

Reclaimed from whom? The company operating the aircraft is no longer in business. The original promoters of the company either have no money to or do not want to pay up. The authorities of the airport where the plane is parked won't release it unless they reclaim their landing and parking charges, which, as mentioned above, won't materialize from the former operators. The leasing company which wants to repossess the airplane will have to pay up not only to make the aircraft airworthy again, but also has to clear all the dues that the former operator has run up. In most cases, it is cheaper to buy a new airplane.


This is not the first time such an incident is happening in India. There are many such abandoned aircraft in a number of Indian airports. People doing business with operators who do not have a good background in the sector, need to be extra careful. The scumbag who owned Kingfisher is known to be a shady and flamboyant character who has not only run his company into the ground, but also defrauded his lessors, kept his own employees his near-slave like condition for months and used his political clout to extract untold millions from Indian state owned banks (and he isn't paying them back too). And he is still a free man.

The Kingfisher saga is the worst example of crony capitalism that one can ever encounter.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: 817Dreamliiner
Posted 2013-04-28 00:38:20 and read 25089 times.

Even though im not a big fan of airbus planes, its really sad to see these images, especially that of a 6 year old aircraft. I actually cant believe they would do something like this (not only the aircraft, but they way the airline was run into the ground), but I guess that's what happens when greedy people run the show...

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: Ronaldo747
Posted 2013-04-28 02:12:21 and read 23659 times.

I don't want to be rude but who want that aircraft? I mean look at the photos ... the interiors, especially the cockpit looks very dirty (lot of dust or sand) and worn, and thats not only by the process of parting-out I guess. The age of an aircraft is irrrelevant if it's in bad condition.

The 777s which Air India want to get rid off comes in my mind. If the aircraft are in similar condition, no wonder that nobody wants them.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: francoflier
Posted 2013-04-28 03:10:31 and read 22780 times.

I'm pretty sure the lessor will have an insurance covering that kind of scenario, especially if they're doing business in India or such places.

Still, there will be a long legal battle and it's anybody's guess how that goes...

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-28 03:28:30 and read 22494 times.

Quoting na (Reply 2):
Well, Vijay Mallya seems to be fine off still, he arrived in his red Bentley and was proudly sitting next table when I was at a restaurant opening in Goa last weekend.

Shameless character, and an example of how political connections and corruption protect the rich and the criminal much more in India than in other countries.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: DTWPurserBoy
Posted 2013-04-28 05:10:02 and read 21067 times.

It is obvious that someone is living in the cargo bay. Where was airport security?

Actually, the airplane is not in that bad of shape. The leasors can come in, replace the missing instruments and parts, clean it up and fly it out for a complete D check and overhaul. Just depends on if they want to spend the money or take the insurance money and write it off.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: 777ER
Posted 2013-04-28 06:22:47 and read 19841 times.

Whats the condition of the outside like on those grounded Kingfisher aircraft?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: 777fan
Posted 2013-04-28 06:23:24 and read 19842 times.

Quoting francoflier (Reply 15):

I'm pretty sure the lessor will have an insurance covering that kind of scenario, especially if they're doing business in India or such places.

True, but things may get to the point where an insurer may not want to underwrite an aircraft leased to an Indian lessor.

Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 17):

It is obvious that someone is living in the cargo bay. Where was airport security?

I was wondering about that myself. At least the frames in Dublin will be subjected to cleaner air and fewer vagrants.

777fan

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-28 06:30:38 and read 19689 times.

It was most like security assigned to guard the aircraft who set up a bunk arrangement inside, likely to handle their duty in rotating shifts.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: CairnterriAIR
Posted 2013-04-28 07:17:10 and read 18879 times.

Never mind the stripping of parts....that aircraft looks like it never saw a moment of basic cleaning or any form of mechanical upkeep. Shameful, and perhaps if that is how companies in a given area operate, then perhaps the leasing companies should take their business to someplace less risky. Let the airlines there shell out some bucks for a plane sitting unused in the desert...then they can destroy it on their own dime.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bobloblaw
Posted 2013-04-28 07:29:09 and read 18666 times.

Quoting na (Reply 2):
ahead of Indigo, Go Air, Jetconnect, AI and Spicejet...

Therein lies the problem. India has massive excess capacity in its airlines. I read a story about a near miss between a KingFisher A320 and JetAirways 738. Both planes were carry a TOTAL of 87 passengers.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: 2008matt
Posted 2013-04-28 07:30:57 and read 18635 times.

Such a shame that Kingfisher had a criminal at the helm, a few years ago i flew LHR - Mumbai - Bangkok on A330 and A319. There were very comfy, with exceptional cabin crew in my opinion.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: tommyy
Posted 2013-04-28 07:40:48 and read 18438 times.

Does anybody know what is the story of he A330's sitting in Zurich for the past few months ?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: deaphen
Posted 2013-04-28 07:49:27 and read 19052 times.

Quoting n471wn (Reply 3):

Even aircraft that can fly away from India head to the scrappers---for example Jet Connect sent two 737-700's to the scrap yard yesterday----I simply cannot understand why any lessor would do business in India

These birds are young and still have a high residual value, they will not be scrapped.

Quoting jagflyer (Reply 10):
Is the aircraft not the property of the leasing company? How can an aircraft be cannibalized like the one above without any repercussions from the leasing company?

Put simply, yes it is and an aircraft cannot be legally cannibalized.

Quoting ltbewr (Reply 11):
Don't leasing companies have better monitoring of their leased aircraft ? It can't be that difficult to do so and it would be in their best interest to do so, to prevent a major devaluation of their property.

Monitoring an aircraft which is flying thousands of miles from the lessor is difficult, at best, it can be examined every few months, it takes just days to cannibalize an aircraft.

Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 17):
It is obvious that someone is living in the cargo bay. Where was airport security?
Quoting sankaps (Reply 20):
It was most like security assigned to guard the aircraft who set up a bunk arrangement inside, likely to handle their duty in rotating shifts.

No, those are sand bags, as the aircraft had no engines, they were placed to keep the centre of gravity towards the centre of the aircraft.

Quoting 2008matt (Reply 23):
Such a shame that Kingfisher had a criminal at the helm, a few years ago i flew LHR - Mumbai - Bangkok on A330 and A319. There were very comfy, with exceptional cabin crew in my opinion.

Yes, their product was very good, shame this happened.

Quoting tommyy (Reply 24):
Does anybody know what is the story of he A330's sitting in Zurich for the past few months ?

Either of the following, being repaired, is pending a legal battle in London or just waiting to be leased again. The 330's were quite badly cannibalized too.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: jfk777
Posted 2013-04-28 07:49:36 and read 18963 times.

Quoting tommyy (Reply 24):
Does anybody know what is the story of he A330's sitting in Zurich for the past few months ?

Seems the A330 escaped intact from India since Kingfisher stopped LHR flying first.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: gr8circle
Posted 2013-04-28 08:20:46 and read 18725 times.

deaphen, if this is about IT aircraft, why have you put the title as

Quoting deaphen (Thread starter):
Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking

Isn't that misleading?

It leads to these sort of comments.....

Quoting Ronaldo747 (Reply 14):
The 777s which Air India want to get rid off comes in my mind. If the aircraft are in similar condition, no wonder that nobody wants them.


I thin the thread title should be changed to point at IT specifically.....

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: GCT64
Posted 2013-04-28 08:35:25 and read 18585 times.

Quoting deaphen (Reply 25):
for example Jet Connect sent two 737-700's to the scrap yard yesterday----I simply cannot understand why any lessor would do business in India

These birds are young and still have a high residual value, they will not be scrapped.

The two 737-700s from Jet Konnect are both early examples (#138 and #152 from 1998). Given that they have gone to eCube at St Athan where A320s, A318s and B736s have all been scrapped, I don't think we can be certain that they are going to survive. But we are getting off topic .....  

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bennett123
Posted 2013-04-28 08:38:23 and read 18401 times.

Especially given that 3 U2 B737-700's and 2 Austrian B737-700's have ended their days at Kemble in the last couple of years.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: deaphen
Posted 2013-04-28 09:47:07 and read 17151 times.

Quoting GCT64 (Reply 28):
The two 737-700s from Jet Konnect are both early examples (#138 and #152 from 1998)

Quite right, but this example is a bird with her first flight in 2006. Much younger.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-28 10:42:05 and read 16985 times.

Quoting deaphen (Reply 25):

No, those are sand bags, as the aircraft had no engines, they were placed to keep the centre of gravity towards the centre of the aircraft.

You may be right. Was thrown off by the bottle of mineral water in the phot, made it look like someone's living quarters!

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: n471wn
Posted 2013-04-28 12:28:39 and read 16654 times.

Quoting deaphen (Reply 25):
These birds are young and still have a high residual value, they will not be scrapped.

Sorry but you are wrong---they are being scrapped

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-28 12:40:09 and read 16552 times.

Quoting deaphen (Reply 30):
Quite right, but this example is a bird with her first flight in 2006. Much younger.

Can you confirm the tail number please, and the fact that it is an A321?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: gatorman96
Posted 2013-04-28 12:44:14 and read 16576 times.

Quoting deaphen (Reply 25):
These birds are young and still have a high residual value, they will not be scrapped.

Based off the interior pics you provided, I can't even imagine what the engines, flight surfaces and landing gear looks like. I am sure they are more or less completely stripped and there is no way these IT aircraft are preserved externally for long term storage. The cost to re-engine these birds and get them up to spec for flight will likely outweigh the cost of scrapping them (there isn't much left of them at this point anyways). Next, stop, my local grocery store as beer cans...

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: KarelXWB
Posted 2013-04-28 14:08:04 and read 16334 times.

The pictures in the first post are gone?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: TheRedBaron
Posted 2013-04-28 14:17:16 and read 16282 times.

Cant see the pics just the first and last... such a shame IT was run by a thief...

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: na
Posted 2013-04-28 14:20:59 and read 16283 times.

Quoting bobloblaw (Reply 22):
Therein lies the problem. India has massive excess capacity in its airlines. I read a story about a near miss between a KingFisher A320 and JetAirways 738. Both planes were carry a TOTAL of 87 passengers.

All domestic flights I had in India over the past 2 years (about 10 flights) were full or almost full.

Quoting Ronaldo747 (Reply 14):
The 777s which Air India want to get rid off comes in my mind. If the aircraft are in similar condition, no wonder that nobody wants them.

The stored 777 I saw at BOM last week didnt look very good.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: aloges
Posted 2013-04-28 14:29:52 and read 16221 times.

Quoting KarelXWB (Reply 35):
The pictures in the first post are gone?
Quoting TheRedBaron (Reply 36):
Cant see the pics just the first and last...

Deaphen's photobucket account is out of bandwidth, hence the "look who's popular" notice.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: Spacepope
Posted 2013-04-28 14:34:27 and read 16201 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 31):
You may be right. Was thrown off by the bottle of mineral water in the phot, made it look like someone's living quarters!

That's not a bottle of water, it's an aerosol spray can.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: ThomasCook
Posted 2013-04-28 23:38:37 and read 15702 times.

Search 'Aircraft Canbalization India' on google images and the pictures will show there.

ThomasCook

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: flywrite
Posted 2013-04-29 04:48:09 and read 15146 times.

It's so sad to see airliners in this kind of state, especially when they usually have life in them. There are some similar images in the new Mumbai Airports Through Time book, such as this one:

http://www.destinworld.co.uk/wp-content/gallery/mumbai-airports-through-time/16-img_4461.jpg

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-29 07:57:50 and read 14599 times.

Wow! Pathetic. Have not seen such a careless, ugly, scrap-littered scene ever at any major commercial airport in the world! Any idea when this photo was taken, and was it as BOM or Juhu?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bennett123
Posted 2013-04-29 08:13:28 and read 14556 times.

http://www.airfleets.net/ficheapp/plane-a320-97.htm

http://www.planespotters.net/Product...320/097,VT-EPT-Indian-Airlines.php

This site indicates Delhi, (post 2009).

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: na
Posted 2013-04-29 08:19:48 and read 14464 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 42):
Wow! Pathetic. Have not seen such a careless, ugly, scrap-littered scene ever at any major commercial airport in the world!

The place in the middle of BOM airport where currently some A310s (among them a colourful one that I couldnt identify) are being cut up (very close to the stored AI 787s/777) doesnt look much better. There are also engineless Jet AW 737s standing around a few hundreds meters away in direct neighbourhood to a large slum (the nearest shacks are less than a 100 m away). Dismantling work is very slow, I´ve been past that place several times in recent years, hardly any movements)

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-29 08:41:47 and read 14324 times.

Quoting bennett123 (Reply 43):

This site indicates Delhi, (post 2009).

Do we know that it is the same aircraft? Airfleets says VT-EPT is stored, the aircraft pictured above does not looked stored, it appears to have been in an advanced state of being scrapped when the photo was taken.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: na
Posted 2013-04-29 08:44:43 and read 14313 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 45):
Do we know that it is the same aircraft? Airfleets says VT-EPT is stored, the aircraft pictured above does not looked stored, it appears to have been in an advanced state of being scrapped when the photo was taken.

"Stored" in India means usually that a plane is in a state of scrapping. Those fleetlists cant always get up-to-date data from there. Several old Indian A320s have been scrapped or a about being cannibalized.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-29 08:49:31 and read 14280 times.

Quoting na (Reply 46):
"Stored" in India means usually that a plane is in a state of scrapping. Those fleetlists cant always get up-to-date data from there. Several old Indian A320s have been scrapped or a about being cannibalized.

Yes, I can believe that. However why then would a photo of an aircraft being scrapped in DEL land up in a book on Mumbai's airports?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bennett123
Posted 2013-04-29 11:41:01 and read 14010 times.

Hello Na,

Are you able to confirm the colour schemes of the A310's, and if they are freighters.

Many thanks.

David

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: DTW2HYD
Posted 2013-04-29 11:50:43 and read 13963 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 45):
Airfleets says VT-EPT is stored

Airfleets says Scrapped
Planespotters says Stored

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bmibaby737
Posted 2013-04-29 12:26:36 and read 13845 times.

Quoting DTW2HYD (Reply 49):
Planespotters says Stored

Planespotters.net shows...

std at DEL 2009
Broken up 2011 at DEL
Preserved at Sai Museum, Sai Baba Temple since March 2012 [fuselage only]

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-29 12:30:27 and read 13791 times.

Quoting bmibaby737 (Reply 50):
Planespotters.net shows...

std at DEL 2009
Broken up 2011 at DEL
Preserved at Sai Museum, Sai Baba Temple since March 2012 [fuselage only]

Thanks. But the question still remains, do we know for sure if the scrapped aircraft pictured VT-EPL? And if it is, what is it doing in a book about Mumbai airports?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: na
Posted 2013-04-29 12:30:32 and read 13794 times.

Quoting bennett123 (Reply 48):

Hello Na,

Are you able to confirm the colour schemes of the A310's, and if they are freighters.

Many thanks.

David

I have seen a freighter in a colourful scheme unknown to me (orange, blue and yellow stripes), and two AI (pax) A310s, one in the old, one in the current livery. The one in new colours is largely dismantled, just a hull with wings.
The AI 777 that I saw stored last week was already stored in december, I have just checked my photos.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bennett123
Posted 2013-04-29 16:14:05 and read 13495 times.

http://www.airfleets.net/ficheapp/plane-a310-544.htm


http://www.planepictures.net/netshow.php?id=945084

I think that this aircraft is the freighter with the Orange, Blue and Yellow bands.

However, the Air India aircraft are proving more tricky.

I suspect that the aircraft in the old colour scheme is VT-AIB, and the other is either VT-EJG, VT-EJJ or VT-EJK.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: gr8circle
Posted 2013-04-29 16:56:56 and read 13341 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 42):
Wow! Pathetic. Have not seen such a careless, ugly, scrap-littered scene ever at any major commercial airport in the world!

A scrap yard, in which a plane is being broken up, will look more or less the same anywhere in the world......don't know what you find "careless" or "ugly" about the site in the pic......

Quoting sankaps (Reply 42):
Any idea when this photo was taken, and was it as BOM or Juhu?

No way an A320 can land at Juhu airport.....

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: DTW2HYD
Posted 2013-04-29 17:51:25 and read 13233 times.

If parts are worth more than the frame itself lessors may prefer just to sell parts and leave metal in India. India is world's dump yard for scrap metal. I am guessing there is no heavy equipment to cut and compress large metal structures in India.

US secures retired planes is to avoid illegal sale of aircraft components to sanctioned countries. They always remove all electronics from military aircraft before they store in open space.

Here is a nice slide show.

http://www.environmentalgraffiti.com...edible-airplane-graveyards?image=0

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: RickNRoll
Posted 2013-04-29 18:23:06 and read 13119 times.

Quoting TheRedBaron (Reply 36):
Cant see the pics just the first and last... such a shame IT was run by a thief...

Is it possible that the cannibalisation is more than just that, but outright theft? The amount of parts missing seems to indicate more than just grabbing a few parts here and there to fix something.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: jagflyer
Posted 2013-04-29 18:56:39 and read 13034 times.

Where are the parts going and who is cannibalizing the aircraft? Kingfisher no longer exists so they obviously are not putting the parts on other planes. Is someone selling the parts off to other carriers (most likely without proper airworthiness certificates/traceability).

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-04-30 01:09:12 and read 12642 times.

Quoting gr8circle (Reply 54):
A scrap yard, in which a plane is being broken up, will look more or less the same anywhere in the world......don't know what you find "careless" or "ugly" about the site in the pic......

I agree, but is this a scrap yard only? If it is BOM, then it is right next to the main runway in a fully operational commercial airport. Junk and debris like this can create hazardous conditions given how close it is to the runways.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: bennett123
Posted 2013-04-30 01:51:39 and read 12517 times.

My reason for thinking that the A320 in reply 41 was VT-EPT is that it seems to be Indian Airlines.

VT-EPT seems to be the only Indian Airlines A320 that did not go to Air India.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: na
Posted 2013-04-30 02:46:22 and read 12382 times.

Quoting bennett123 (Reply 53):
I think that this aircraft is the freighter with the Orange, Blue and Yellow bands.

Thats it, yes.

Quoting bennett123 (Reply 53):
However, the Air India aircraft are proving more tricky.

I suspect that the aircraft in the old colour scheme is VT-AIB, and the other is either VT-EJG, VT-EJJ or VT-EJK.

The one in the current livery has red tape over titles, registration and even over the IATA logo. Judging from the length of the sticker covering the name and the little individual differences at the tail I am pretty sure its EJK. That plane is basically gone, just a hulk left.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: DTWPurserBoy
Posted 2013-04-30 06:34:46 and read 12126 times.

Theft is indeed a possibility. I noticed that one of the FMC's was still in place. That is a very valuable piece of equipment!

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: KarelXWB
Posted 2013-05-02 00:15:40 and read 11426 times.

http://oi39.tinypic.com/2zstw5d.jpg

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: aloges
Posted 2013-05-02 00:35:10 and read 11307 times.

Quoting KarelXWB (Reply 62):

That just makes you angry, doesn't it?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-05-02 01:31:29 and read 11238 times.

Quoting KarelXWB (Reply 62):

KarelXWB -- the photo of the KF aircraft you posted above was taken by me, incidentally, in DEL. And this was when KF was still in operation! They had no shame or care even then -- just superficial glamour.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: KL5147
Posted 2013-05-02 02:51:32 and read 10994 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 64):
was taken by me

just out of curiosity do you know the regi of this a/c?

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-05-02 02:56:35 and read 10979 times.

Quoting KL5147 (Reply 65):

just out of curiosity do you know the regi of this a/c?

No, did not note that but recall it was a former Air Deccan registration.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: DTWPurserBoy
Posted 2013-05-02 05:56:58 and read 10738 times.

For people that love and respect airplanes, these are outrageous pictures. It is nothing less than vandalism and those responsible should be charged.

Poor insurance companies. They are going to eat these. I would demand mega bucks before I leased an airplane in India since they don't have a great risk record and obviously very little security around the planes.

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: sankaps
Posted 2013-05-02 06:21:56 and read 10666 times.

Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 67):
I would demand mega bucks before I leased an airplane in India since they don't have a great risk record and obviously very little security around the planes.

Don't think security is an issue -- as a matter of fact it is tight in India. These cannibalizations are likely the result of deliberate decisions by KF management (to sell / loan / swap with other aircraft, etc).

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: lightsaber
Posted 2013-05-02 07:03:29 and read 10544 times.

Quoting aloges (Reply 63):
That just makes you angry, doesn't it?

This is money, so no emotions required. It is going to make it tougher for other Indian airlines to lease aircraft. For example, inspections or higher lease rates.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 64):
They had no shame or care even then -- just superficial glamour.

It makes me realize how superficial the 'King of good times' really is.

It also exposes some huge flaws in Indian aviation that I want corrected so that the Indian aviation industry grows as it should and helps the Indian economy grow. The chance of reforms? Sigh...

Lightsaber

Topic: RE: Aircraft Cannibalization In India | Heartbreaking
Username: KarelXWB
Posted 2013-05-02 11:40:30 and read 10208 times.

Quoting sankaps (Reply 64):
the photo of the KF aircraft you posted above was taken by me, incidentally, in DEL

I can only say 1 thing: nice catch! We now have a clear image on what to think about the aircraft cannibalization in India. I never realized it was that bad.


The messages in this discussion express the views of the author of the message, not necessarily the views of Airliners.net or any entity associated with Airliners.net.

Copyright © Lundgren Aerospace. All rights reserved.
http://www.airliners.net/