Sponsor Message:
Civil Aviation Forum
My Starred Topics | Profile | New Topic | Forum Index | Help | Search 
Comments On The Worst Accident In Aviation History  
User currently offlineBen88 From United States of America, joined Dec 1999, 1093 posts, RR: 3
Posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 10 hours ago) and read 6167 times:

**If you are familiar with this incident, skip the first paragraph**



**"Air Disasters" by Marriot, Stewart, and Sharpe is credited with the quotes and information presented in this post.**

For those who do not know about this accident, it involved two 747's (Pan-Am & KLM) at Tenerife, Canary Islands in 1977. The KLM 747 had just completed a 180 degree turn and was lined up awaiting takeoff clearance. The Clipper jet was on the runway, facing the KLM 747, although they could not see each other. They were instructed to turn off on the charlie 3 taxiway and then report to Approach control. (the approach freq. was being used for both takeoff and approach) In any case, the KLM started its take-off roll and by the time the two jets saw each other, it was too late. The KLM captain pulled back on the yoke, but the main landing gear struck the Clipper jet at the position of the number three engine,(from left) as it was frantically trying to turn off of the runway. The KLM 747 then "skidded for 1,000 feet and as it did so the aircraft slid to the right, rotating clockwise through a 90 degree turn before coming to a halt." The plane was immediately engulfed in flames, and all occupants were killed. The whole upper portion of the Clipper 747 had been ripped off, and the pilots escaped through a hole in the front of the fuselage. "Of the 396 passengers and crew aboard the Pan Am flight, only 70 escaped from the wreckage and nine later died in the hospital."

**And now on to the cause**

I was always under the impression that the KLM captain was at fault for this accident, but further research on the subject may have changed my mind. Picture this scenario for a moment: The KLM 747 is lined up and ready for take-off. The Pan Am 747 is still on the runway facing KLM, and is searching for Charlie 3 through the confusion of dense fog and heavy atc accents. I'm going to pick it up at KLM's request for take-off clearance:

KLM F/O: "KLM4805 is now ready for takeoff and we are waiting for out ATC clearance"

At this time, the Clipper 747 had inadvertently passed the C3 exit and continued towards the KLM 747.

Approach: "KLM4805, you are cleared to the papa beacon, climb to and maintain flight level nine zero. Right turn after take-off, proceed with heading four zero four until intercepting the three three five radial from Las Palmas"

The KLM captain assumed this to be a take-off clearance by approach control. He opened up the throttles and released the brakes.

KLM F/O: "Ah, roger sir, we're cleared to the papa beacon, flight level nine zero. Right turn out, zero four zero, until intercepting the three two five. We are now at take off."

The final sentence was not understood by the Pan-Am 747 or the ATC officer.

Approach: "OK"

The next two transmissions were almost simultaneous, and the KLM 747 heard neither of them. Only a squeal and unintelligible blurbs were heard in their cockpit.

Approach: "stand by for take-off, I will call you."

Pan Am F/O: "No, uh....and we are still taxying down the runway, the clipper 1736"

Approach: " Roger, papa alpha 1736, report the runway clear"

This was the one and only time that the ATC officer referred to the Pan Am 747 as "papa alpha."

Pan Am 747: "Ok we'll report when we're clear"

Approach: "Thank You"

The KLM F/E expressed some concern, but was quickly brushed off by the captain and F/O.

KLM F/E: " Is he not clear that Pan American?"

KLM captain: "oh, yes"

A few seconds later, the two jets collided. There was obviously a lot of confusion during the minutes before this accident. In MY opinion the three critical errors were:

1.) The failure of the KLM 747 captain to obtain absolutely certain clearance in the low visiblilty.

2.) The ATC officers' failure to immediately re-transmit the following message, "stand by for take off, I will call you." The KLM crew never responded to the message, and the officer should have re-transmitted it right away to be sure they understood.

3.) The lack of directional support (namely signage) to help pilots navigate on the ground in low visibility.

What do you guys think?

6 replies: All unread, jump to last
 
User currently offlineHB-IGG From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 1, posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 10 hours ago) and read 6065 times:

From the information that I have either te F/O andthe F/E told the Captain that they were not sure about clearence for takeoff.
Maybe I'm wrong but I think that the main reason for this disaster was "once again" the captain not listening
to his krew  
I hope that those kind of errors won't happen again!!!

Best Regards
HB-IGG


User currently offlineBen88 From United States of America, joined Dec 1999, 1093 posts, RR: 3
Reply 2, posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 10 hours ago) and read 6057 times:

The KLM F/E said, "Is he not clear that Pan American" right before the Pan Am came into view. I doubt that anything could have been done at this junction, although you bring up a good point.

User currently offlineJtb106 From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 3, posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 10 hours ago) and read 6046 times:

Actually, they may not occur again BECAUSE of that incident. The crews are trained to be more of a team than a dictatorship now to prevent this from occurring.

User currently offlineHB-IGG From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 4, posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 10 hours ago) and read 6044 times:

Have you read "THE NAKED PILOT" it may sound funny but I found it wery good!
Well I just cheked and the F/E allerted the Capt. before takeoff PWR ,newer mind at least we agree on the decision mistake!!
""THE NAKED PILOT" DAVID BEATY""
HB-IGG


User currently offlineBen88 From United States of America, joined Dec 1999, 1093 posts, RR: 3
Reply 5, posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 9 hours ago) and read 6035 times:

Yes the KLM F/O said "wait a minute, we don't have atc clearance." That's where I began with my post. He then requested take-off clearance. The KLM F/E said, "Is he clear that Pan American" after they had been rolling for quite a while. So in essence, the captain made two errors. The first could have been just as critical as the second ended up being.

User currently offlineDesertJets From United States of America, joined Feb 2000, 7787 posts, RR: 16
Reply 6, posted (14 years 4 months 2 days 9 hours ago) and read 6029 times:

Some interesting items on the KLM captain. He was the seniormost captain for KLM and had been used extensively in the advertising saying how safe flying was. When the crash occured the head of KLM attempted to call this captain before he realized he was the one at Tenerife. All of this points out several issues, first of all since then cockpit crews have had more ability to double check and question the captain's decision... or rather the captain is no longer a dictator, secondly it brings up the issue of what value experinence has when one gets too set in their ways and does not listen to the other crew members inputs. It was surely tragic what happened that day, but some of the feats of heroism by the Pan Am F/A's are also quite amazing.


Stop drop and roll will not save you in hell. --- seen on a church marque in rural Virginia
Top Of Page
Forum Index

This topic is archived and can not be replied to any more.

Printer friendly format

Similar topics:More similar topics...
Worst Strikes In Aviation History posted Mon Aug 22 2005 18:02:08 by ARGinLON
On This Date In Aviation History posted Fri Dec 8 2000 23:28:26 by TurboTristar
More On The 737/747 In VVI posted Fri Jun 2 2006 20:01:54 by LatinAviation
I Work At The Worst Airport In The World posted Sun May 28 2006 03:10:50 by MSYtristar
Brtain: The World Leader In Aviation posted Fri Feb 11 2005 00:36:11 by Eg777er
Big Day In Aviation History posted Fri Dec 17 2004 13:51:41 by Xpat
The First Attempt In Aviation. posted Wed Nov 10 2004 09:52:54 by HAWK21M
The Latest On The UAL 777s In Storage posted Mon Jun 7 2004 20:37:56 by Thrust
Whats The Reg. On The First UA737 In New Colors? posted Sun Feb 22 2004 00:37:03 by Tony lu
MIA Expansion:Largest In Aviation History(Article) posted Tue Jan 27 2004 21:44:38 by MAH4546