Airmale From Botswana, joined Sep 2004, 385 posts, RR: 1 Posted (14 years 11 months 4 weeks 20 hours ago) and read 2875 times:
Who was to blame for the 1992 crashes of a Thai Airways A310-300 (July) and Pakistan International A300B4-200 (September) in Kathmandu, Nepal? was it pilot error or the ATC? two fatal crashes, involving two major airlines, just two months apart in the same place makes one wonder.
Tg 747-300 From Norway, joined Nov 1999, 1318 posts, RR: 0
Reply 1, posted (14 years 11 months 4 weeks 19 hours ago) and read 2823 times:
Thai Airways A310-300 HS-TGD was aproaching Khatmandu when a flap problem occured. The had to abort the aproach and start all over again. During a turn the aircraft hit a peak and crashed. From what i see it was mostly the crews fault, but i'm not sure.
PIA A300-300 AP-DCP crached into high terrain during a normal approach. It's not possible for me to find out if it was a pilot error, ATC erroe, or an error from both parts that caused the crach.
Check out http://aviation-safety.net/database/1992/1992.shtml for exact info
Jet Setter From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 2, posted (14 years 11 months 4 weeks 17 hours ago) and read 2812 times:
In the Thai Airways A310 accident, the aircraft had a flap problem which was quickly rectified, however because the Kathmandu approach is so steep due to the mountains aircraft have to be in full landing configuration 13 nm before touchdown (ie full flaps, gear down) The aircraft was too high and abandoned the approach, but they failed to follow the correct procedure. There was confusion over what route the aircraft would follow to re-commence the approach, and entering that route into the FMS. ATC were not properly responding to the crews requests, which lead to more confusion. While the crew were distracted the failed to realise the aircraft had turned towards the north during the confusion and was heading towards mountains rising to 23000ft, the aircraft struck the mountains in level flight at 11500ft.
The PIA accident occured simply because the crew descended too low on the approach, ATC notified them they were too low seconds before the crash, but too late.
The main cause of both accidents was pilot error. The complex approach procedure at Kathmandu were contributory factors to both. Poor ATC also contributed to the Thai crash