A340Spotter From United States of America, joined Jul 2003, 1989 posts, RR: 21
Reply 1, posted (9 years 7 months 2 days 14 hours ago) and read 2202 times:
Was about to start another thread myself, but see you've done so already, good on ya...
Tonight, the singers got to sing 2 songs, current songs or ones of the Billboard Top 100 of any variety. Saw some interesting choices, but maybe not the best of singing...
To me, Taylor picked the right songs, singing Play that Funky Music White Boy and Something by the Beatles. Sang them well and got deserved praise. Chris and Katharine both did well on at least one of their songs, Chris singing Styx's Wanted Man well but faded on a Shinedown song due to his voice getting tired (too much shrieking). Katharine sang Phil Collins' Against All Odds okay but did very well with KT Tunstall's Black Horse and a Cherry Tree...woo hoo.
Paris sang Prince's Kiss and then took a good turn with a Mary J Blige song while Eliot sang On Broadway and a Michael Buble song about going home, risky and likely foreshadowing tomorrow night's results show.
Think the bottom 2 are Paris and Eliot with Eliot's ride finally coming to an end.
I'm off to LA tomorrow before the trip to Australia so this is likely my last post about the show. Will have to catch the web logs I suppose.
oh, and as for Paula, she was much more calm tonight compared to the last couple of weeks.
"Irregardless, it's a Cat III airplane, we don't need an alternate!"
9VSPO From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 2, posted (9 years 6 months 4 weeks 1 day 2 hours ago) and read 2184 times:
It was an odd show this week. Elliot was no Michael Buble! Hopefully he will go next week. Katherine's second song was better. I agreed with everything Simon said really and Paula actually looked sober too!
Vaporlock From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 3, posted (9 years 6 months 4 weeks 14 hours ago) and read 2168 times:
I hope Elliot doesn't go as he really does have an amazing voice and can sing pretty much any style.... which is amazing for someone who is deaf in one ear. He sings in tune and can hold a note without having to strain his voice.
Sean377 From United Kingdom, joined Mar 2001, 1225 posts, RR: 37
Reply 10, posted (9 years 6 months 3 weeks 4 days 3 hours ago) and read 2082 times:
Is American Idol supposed to be similar to the X-Factor (just an assumption coz Simon Cowell is in both)? I don't know if we get a highly edited version here in the UK, but there is no comparison. AI is pants. One of the best parts of The X-Factor was the judges banter. The panel on AI are absolutely lifeless. Apart from Simon, the other 2 NEVER critisize ANY of the contestants. It's always "Yo Man, that rocked. You did it for me" waving fingers in the air like some Vulcan salute gone wrong!
Flying is the second greatest thrill known to man... Landing is the first!
After the next person who gets voted off tonight, there will be 3 left, remember?!
I predict Katharine will be voted off, although shes really cute!!
Quoting IFEMaster (Reply 7): Paula Abdul has absolutely no credential to be on the show.
I agree. She goes through too much and is absolutely SICK of Simon. She gives every participant very good marks, I rarely see any negativity from her. She used to be very good at judging in the first two seasons, but now she seems so worn out.... She recently signed on for two more seasons, I think.
A Safe Flight Begins With Quality Maintenance On The Ground.
Tranceport From Canada, joined Jul 2003, 282 posts, RR: 1
Reply 19, posted (9 years 6 months 3 weeks 3 days 13 hours ago) and read 2032 times:
Actually, as much of a fan as I am, in retrospect this doesn't surprise me. You have to consider the driving force behind the fan base of an American pop idol. When you look back through the season and evaluate each person's performance on that fan base and not on the individual's music style, it's a fairly logical choice.
Zarniwoop From United Kingdom, joined Apr 2005, 265 posts, RR: 0
Reply 21, posted (9 years 6 months 3 weeks 3 days 12 hours ago) and read 2024 times:
Actually, not that suprising.... i thought *he/she* was weak last night. Felt like *he/she* just came on and sung the songs without any passion or feeling. The others seemed to put a lot more effort and "soul" into it, if you see what I mean. Having a good voice isnt just what its about i guess, connecting with the viewers on an emotional level is gonna get you far more votes.....
IFEMaster From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 24, posted (9 years 6 months 3 weeks 3 days 4 hours ago) and read 1996 times:
Quoting Tranceport (Reply 19): Actually, as much of a fan as I am, in retrospect this doesn't surprise me. You have to consider the driving force behind the fan base of an American pop idol. When you look back through the season and evaluate each person's performance on that fan base and not on the individual's music style, it's a fairly logical choice.
Well said my friend. Given the different vocal styles of the remaining contestants, I would say that it's not surprising at all that he/she got kicked off on Wednesday. Despite some killer performances during the Barry Manilow and Rod Stewart weeks, and the Love Song week, he/she isn't what America vote for in a pop star. Frankly, I think two out of the final three are incredibly lucky to be there as there is really only one 'pop' singer left.
America made the right decision this week. My prediction is that the top two from this week will be the final two.
Quoting Jaysit (Reply 22): And who on earth is going to buy a Taylor Hicks album pray tell?
Me. Out of all the contestants, Taylor is the only one who has raised the proverbial middle finger to what everyone else thinks, and done his own thing. He loves the music above everything else, always has a good time, and doesn't take it to heart when Cowell unfairly critisizes him. Taylor is awesome. SOUL PATROL!
: OK. One album for Taylor. Sold. Now that still leaves those other 999,999 lying unsold in the bargain bins at Costco.
: Clearly you don't like him, but there are enough Americans who do to CONSISTENTLY vote to keep him on. He's never been in the bottom three as far as
: Uh, yeah. I guess that explains that Justin Guarini vote too, doesn't it?
: My view is Taylor and Elliott both seem like nice guys but at the end of the day this show is called 'Idol'. It's about what 13 year old teenage girl
: I just watched the outcome on Fox and I am shocked!!
: No! We were all prepared to taunt you endlessly until Friday night. Now what shall we do for entertainment?
: Alot of people were shocked....I, for one, am happy that........
: This year's American Idol series has officially jumped the shark. I'm done with it.. the best is gone.
: I agree, I would have put money on Chris winning. Maybe people thought it was a dead cert so they didn't bother voting. If Taylor wins that will be a
: You got that right. But it seems that Paula and the good people of Alabama like the sound of him farting on stage.
: It's on here right now! I thought Chris's version of Suspicious Minds was good and Katherine looks great.
: Watch Chris' face while he does A Little Less Conversation. He's got this stupid, blank why-am-I-here look about him. If only I'd predicted the outco
: Just went to see Elliott live in downtown Richmond as the Idols are back home this week for a few days. Have to say live he sounds much better than he
: Damn, did Kat ever NAIL "Over the Rainbow." That's a bugger of a song to sing, too. Best moment this season by far for me. All in all, however, Elliot
: Paula was still drunk, Randy was still high on sugar, and Simon's man boobs moved to the right. All in all, same ol', same ol' on Idol, except that la
: Not a singer myself but I found the arrangement of all of Katharine's songs and in particular 'Over the Rainbow' to be god awful! She sang them we
: Looks like I'll be dialing 866-IDOLS03 tonight.
: Is Randy Jackson a total idiot or what? Its about time that someone (the mcphee girl) called him on his stupidity when she said that she didn't choose
: It's such a sorry show--I'm not sure what Randy does other than the dog salute. If they'd just assign someone to installing more phone lines, that'd
: You know that Simon's thinking "Shut up Paula, you dumb sl*t."
: Well, I found the rarely-sung lead-in done a capella to be a gutsy move, and she was spot-on in terms of pitch. Then the classical guitar-only verse,
: I believe Randy Jackson helped produce most of Mariah Carey's albums. I'm gettin' sick of Randy's 'Yo yo yo' or 'sup, dawg...' Getting a bit old now!
: GAH! I've just realized that the results show will be broadcast during the second hour of the season finale of The Amazing Race tonight. Time to fire
: I actually got goosebumps, and was almost moved to tears when they showed her father. You could just see the pride beaming from his face. Her renditi
: I suggest you research some history on the guy. He has been in the music industry for a VERY long time and is a well respected musician, song writer,
: Very close on the vote tonite...less than 1% diff tween the three...and the loser is....as predicted...[Edited 2006-05-18 04:20:24]
: Your limey bastard friend 9VSPO is gonna pour acid on your crank for that.
: Boo Hoo....I was hoping Elliot would last till the end. Considering where he came from he has done amazing! Phyllis
: Phyllis, you whacky nut, you're supposed to keep it secret so our lime-sucking pomey bastard friends like 9VSPO can wait to see it in their 3rd-world
: Wow, just fast-forwarded through my tape. Glad I had speed-dial going last night. Close one!
: As I'm in Greece I will miss it this week so I don't mind knowing the result. Did Elliot go then? That's good!