With all these "counterrecruiters" popping up, what happens if they were successful in every case, so military recruiters could no longer come onto high school/college campuses? Seems to me like the harder they make it for the military branches to meet their quotas, the more the draft almost looks like an option. I had a thread on here a while ago about reinstating the draft, but I don't think this particular topic was addressed. If it was, this thread is still devoted mainly to the title.... Towards the end of the article, whoever the reporter was that wrote it picked a real winner to interview... Painted him as the stereotypical recruit the Marines and Army like... just someone who wants to kill kill kill. Your thoughts?
TheCoz From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 1, posted (10 years 4 months 3 weeks 4 days 9 hours ago) and read 743 times:
I ran into a few anti-recruiter guys in downtown Phoenix one night. They had a display stand set up on the street and were talking about radio-active ammunition etc. They seemed rather idealist in terms of their goals. It's one thing to inform people about the tactics of a military recruiter, but to discourage people from joining the military makes no sense to me.
I find it kind of strange that there are troops out there fighting for these guys' right to spread propaganda against the military. The military is an essential thing in the world we live in, and like you said Greyhound, discouraging recruitment will only encourage a draft.
Greyhound From United States of America, joined Mar 2005, 1026 posts, RR: 2
Reply 2, posted (10 years 4 months 3 weeks 4 days 8 hours ago) and read 733 times:
I never agree with the tactics that have been reportedly used by some recruiters. Threating students, lying about "never going to war" and such things won't get you anywhere. But as adamant as these anti-recruiting people are, they are in a way no better than the recruiters they loathe. It's just fine, IMHO, to inform students about the realities of military life, and to inform them of ALL their options. But it's another thing entirely to do crap like throwing fake blood on a recruiting office doorstep, and tell a recruiter to his/her face that they should understand they aren't wanted there. Why doesn't that lady bitch to her elected representatives? What does she honestly hope to accomplish by telling that recruiter he's not wanted there? Even if she got her wish and he didn't want to be there, the military would just send another to fill the void.
Inform students of their choices, but don't overly pressure them TO join or NOT TO join. When I was in high school, most other kids at the time were smart enough to realize that if you signed up to go into the military, ANY BRANCH, that you would sooner or later be headed off to some sort of conflict. I love how some people hate recruiters because of the job they're doing.
That same PTSA in the article passed a resolution a while back condemning the Iraq war. Sounds like too many parents with too much time on their hands in that district. But sure, go ahead and keep pushing recruiters off your son's campus lady. I hope if there is a draft, that lady's son is the first one to get the call.
Just a side note Coz, I think maybe the parents should spend a little more time with their kids helping them make better, informed decisions. But I'm sure it's all the recruiters' faults.