Bri2k1 From United States of America, joined Dec 2004, 988 posts, RR: 3 Posted (10 years 1 week 23 hours ago) and read 1802 times:
What is the deal with passengers bringing baggage the size of dump trucks onto completely full flights? The airlines' regulations are clearly posted, and most of them have helpful signage to allow people to make sure a bag will fit in the overhead storage properly. Whose job is it to stop them from bringing much larger bags on board?
Many airlines' seating order appears to favor the front of the plane first, followed by window seats. Anyone with an aisle seat beyond the middle of the plane has a pretty low chance of getting an overhead spot for their bag. I fly very frequently, and have become a preferred member of the frequent traveler programs of the airlines I fly most, so I get to board first in most cases. But, even my business associates who fly often, but not necessarily 3-4 times a month like I do, have a low probability of getting a reasonably-sized bag on board.
I've heard it's supposed to be enforced by airport security, but as I said I fly very often, and I have never seen a security screener reject a passenger's bag due to size in any airport anywhere. Even if security drops the ball, why can't the gate agents do something? And beyond them, the flight attendants? They're just going to have to check bags later and risk a late departure if bags don't fit the way they're designed to.
Just a pet peeve of mine, but I'd be interested to hear the observations of those closer to part 121 ops than me (as a passenger).
Litz From United States of America, joined Dec 2003, 2102 posts, RR: 0
Reply 3, posted (10 years 1 week 10 hours ago) and read 1731 times:
This probably belongs in the regular civil aviation forum, btw ...
However - every airline I've been on has "size-wise" units at the gatehouses. These are, as described above, metal contraptions that correspond to the lengh, width, and height allowed for carry-on baggage.
I have seen these used exactly ONCE, when a guy made a fuss about being forced to gate-check a massive duffel bag. And yes, it didn't fit.
That's in hundreds of airline flights spread across most of the US carriers.
There's got to be some sort of compromise that can be reached between the workloads of the gatehouse agents and the need to restrict these oversize bags.
The thing that scares me the most, is when people stuff those things in the overhead bins and have to push like hell to get the lid to close.
One really good bump of turbulence and that thing's gonna pop open like a jack-in-the-box. One reason I hardly ever, if possible, take aisle seats.
Ditto. I usually only have a small rucksack that fits easily under the seat and a jacket. I don't know how many times I've ended up stuffing the jacket beside my seat because, as you say, so many people bring suitcases on board and use up several people's space. I've never seen the restrictions enforced.
I always thought it would be cool if the security scanner system had some high powered lasers that chopped off the excess.
LH463 From United States of America, joined Apr 2006, 68 posts, RR: 0
Reply 6, posted (10 years 1 week 4 hours ago) and read 1674 times:
I think part of the problem with these people is change. I personally either bring a newspaper on board or a backpack which fits perfectly under the seat. My dad however, for years has been bringing one of those roller bags onto the aircraft which easily fits in any overhead bin, but does not always pass the airlines size check. What's changed is that you used to be able to take on larger bags and not everyone has adjusted to that yet.
Starlionblue From Greenland, joined Feb 2004, 17629 posts, RR: 65
Reply 8, posted (10 years 1 week 2 hours ago) and read 1646 times:
On the one hand:
- I hate seeing the enormous carry-ons being packed into the bins.
On the other hand:
- I used fly an average of 2 segments a week. Checking luggage would have cost me at least an hour a week, not to mention the likelihood of loss. I can understand not checking luggage. It's one thing not having fresh clothes on vacation, but for three days of meetings?
On the gripping hand:
- In my experience, the worst offenders tend to be non-frequent travelers. I'm not saying road warriors don't have large bags, it's just that we tend to have bags that comply with the regs and know how to stow them and sit down before you can blink. My bag looks "large" but it fits lengthwise into deep bins (with about a nanomillimeter to spare) and otherwise complies with the regs, even with the clip-on backpack. I have seen "tourists" cram their three wicker basket bags (open top, no less) into a bin, then put a hat next to them. Half an hour later, the line gets moving again. Another favorite is the petite lady with the enormous bag who asks the F/A to help. Look lady, if you can't lift it into the bin yourself, don't roll it aboard! These are the people holding up boarding and taking all the bins.
So it's not all about the size of the bag. It's also about the person carrying it and if they know how to stow it.
"There are no stupid questions, but there are a lot of inquisitive idiots."
HaveBlue From United States of America, joined Jan 2004, 2168 posts, RR: 1
Reply 10, posted (10 years 6 days 23 hours ago) and read 1620 times:
I'm a PPL but don't fly on airliners often. However last weekend the gf and I went from MCO to PHX on Southwest. Had relatively early boarding for the first 3 legs but at Alburque we were almost the very last of C to board. At the end of the jetway at the door of the 737 starting several people ahead of us the FA's were telling people they would have to check their carry on, as the plane was full and there was no more room for carry on if it wasn't stowable below your seat. Fortunately mine was, but a lady ahead of us was deeming this 'unacceptable' and making a fuss. To make matters worse as we made our way to the back of the already loaded plane there was several spaces in the bins empty, big spaces, so the order seemed a bit contrived. However I do agree with the other posters that I have never seen the size limit enforced yet I only parked my metal camera case in the bins, others however were definitely taking advantage of the lack of oversight.
Miamiair From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 11, posted (10 years 6 days 14 hours ago) and read 1582 times:
Quoting Bri2k1 (Thread starter): I've heard it's supposed to be enforced by airport security, but as I said I fly very often, and I have never seen a security screener reject a passenger's bag due to size in any airport anywhere.
Fly AA out of SFO. The first screener in the line will tell you that cannot be carried on. I have seen it several times, but only AA/SFO.
I travel with with a lap-top case and a small roll-on travel case. It fits even in AA 767 overhead bins, so it is small. For the same reasons Starlionblue posted I do not like checking in bags. Vacations are a different matter, bags go in the hold.
FA's should say something, especially when you see someone shoe-horning a huge bag into the overhead, the old two pound salami in a one pound bag trick. The other thing I notice are people that are seated in the ass-end putting their bags in the first class bins.
DeltaDC9 From United States of America, joined Apr 2006, 2844 posts, RR: 4
Reply 12, posted (10 years 6 days 10 hours ago) and read 1548 times:
What is the motivation for the airlines to enforce this? Apparantly none.
When we travel the only things we don't check are her purse, my camera bag, and one small bag with any needed valuables and everything we need for a one night layover in case of a cancelled flight or lost or delayed bags. This way, if we lose our bags, all we lose are clothes.
We don't check things that are irreplaceable but try not to travel with items like that anyway, who needs the stress? We don't carry on any more than we have to, out of respect for others. I wish more people would just check their damn bags.
It's not like theres anything irreplaceable in those bags! And if there is I think the travelers judgment may be in question. If you have something valuable to transport, use FedEx or UPS and insure the damn thing.
Dont take life too seriously because you will never get out of it alive - Bugs Bunny