Sponsor Message:
Aviation Technical / Operations Forum
My Starred Topics | Profile | New Topic | Forum Index | Help | Search 
I Can Hear ATC, But Not The Pilots, Why?  
User currently offlinec5load From United States of America, joined Sep 2008, 917 posts, RR: 0
Posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 7 hours ago) and read 5340 times:

Listening to MSP approach, I can hear my father's flight number when ATC issues instructions, but can't hear him respond. Why does this happen sometimes?


"But this airplane has 4 engines, it's an entirely different kind of flying! Altogether"
14 replies: All unread, jump to last
 
User currently offlineMir From United States of America, joined Jan 2004, 21552 posts, RR: 55
Reply 1, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 6 hours ago) and read 5319 times:

Sometimes one controller will work multiple frequencies. He'll talk on all of them, and listen to all of them, but the pilots will only be listening and talking on one of them. If you're not tuned to the same one as the pilots, you won't hear them, but you will hear the controller.

Are you hearing some other flights on the feed, or is it just the controller talking?

-Mir



7 billion, one nation, imagination...it's a beautiful day
User currently offlinec5load From United States of America, joined Sep 2008, 917 posts, RR: 0
Reply 2, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 6 hours ago) and read 5313 times:

Quoting Mir (Reply 1):
Are you hearing some other flights on the feed, or is it just the controller talking?

Yes as I listened more I could hear some pilots calling in, but not all of them.



"But this airplane has 4 engines, it's an entirely different kind of flying! Altogether"
User currently offline411A From United States of America, joined Nov 2001, 1826 posts, RR: 8
Reply 3, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 4 hours ago) and read 5192 times:

The answer often is...a limited remote communications outlet (LRCO), on some frequencies.
Most noticed over France, during the nightime.


User currently offlineEMBQA From United States of America, joined Oct 2003, 9364 posts, RR: 11
Reply 4, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 3 hours ago) and read 5145 times:

It has to do with line of sight on the transmitting radio.


"It's not the size of the dog in the fight, but the size of the fight in the dog"
User currently offlineShamrock137 From United States of America, joined Jul 2005, 141 posts, RR: 0
Reply 5, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 3 hours ago) and read 5135 times:

Are you listening to this online with a site such as Live ATC or a scanner?


Time to spare? Go by air!
User currently offlinec5load From United States of America, joined Sep 2008, 917 posts, RR: 0
Reply 6, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 2 hours ago) and read 5088 times:

Quoting Shamrock137 (Reply 5):
Are you listening to this online with a site such as Live ATC or a scanner?

Listening to LiveATC.net



"But this airplane has 4 engines, it's an entirely different kind of flying! Altogether"
User currently offlineShamrock137 From United States of America, joined Jul 2005, 141 posts, RR: 0
Reply 7, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 1 hour ago) and read 5072 times:

If the aircraft are on the ground you may not be able to hear them due to the aircraft radio transmitters not being as powerful as those used by ATC. It also depends where the scanner receiving the signals is in relation to the airport. You will be able to hear aircraft that are in the air because VHF radios operate by what is known as line of sight. This means that the antennas need to be able to "see" each other for the signals to be received. The higher an aircraft is, the further the signal will be able to be received depending on how powerful the transmitter is. Hope this clears it up a bit.


Time to spare? Go by air!
User currently offlineMir From United States of America, joined Jan 2004, 21552 posts, RR: 55
Reply 8, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 6 days 1 hour ago) and read 5068 times:

Quoting EMBQA (Reply 4):
It has to do with line of sight on the transmitting radio.

That was my first thought as well, but that would normally mean you hear the pilots but not ATC, instead of the other way around.

Quoting 411A (Reply 3):
The answer often is...a limited remote communications outlet (LRCO), on some frequencies.
Most noticed over France, during the nightime.

I'll take your word for it with respect to France, but these situations are common in the US as well. At least as recently as 2006, the approach/departure controllers at JFK would talk on two frequencies - one for VFR aircraft and one for IFR aircraft. If you were on the VFR frequency, you'd hear the instructions being given to the IFR aircraft, but you wouldn't hear the pilots responding.

-Mir



7 billion, one nation, imagination...it's a beautiful day
User currently offlineFly2HMO From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 9, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 5 days 20 hours ago) and read 4935 times:

Quoting Mir (Reply 1):
He'll talk on all of them, and listen to all of them, but the pilots will only be listening and talking on one of them.

In other words, ATC can transmit/receive on multiple frequencies simultaneously, while aircraft can't (technically).

Quoting Mir (Reply 8):

That was my first thought as well, but that would normally mean you hear the pilots but not ATC, instead of the other way around.

Yep. Most likely the frequency is split.

Quoting Mir (Reply 8):
If you were on the VFR frequency, you'd hear the instructions being given to the IFR aircraft, but you wouldn't hear the pilots responding.

Had this happen a lot in PHX APP in a slow day. I want to say this also happened to me on ZABQ once or twice, been a while though...


User currently offlineajd1992 From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 10, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 5 days 13 hours ago) and read 4733 times:

Quoting EMBQA (Reply 4):
It has to do with line of sight on the transmitting radio.

That's true, but usually you won't hear the ATC, not the pilot. The pilot being in the plane would be the one person you'd expect to hear them more than anybody.


User currently offlinec5load From United States of America, joined Sep 2008, 917 posts, RR: 0
Reply 11, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 5 days 12 hours ago) and read 4699 times:

Quoting Shamrock137 (Reply 7):
Hope this clears it up a bit.

It does, thank you sir. It's really cool though being able to hear one of your family members talking with ATC while I ma sitting at work and he is flying somewhere.  



"But this airplane has 4 engines, it's an entirely different kind of flying! Altogether"
User currently offline71Zulu From United States of America, joined Aug 2006, 3072 posts, RR: 0
Reply 12, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 5 days 8 hours ago) and read 4601 times:

Quoting c5load (Reply 6):
Listening to LiveATC.net

It sounds to me like an antenna issue with the feed. If the person providing the feed doesn't or can't have an external antenna and is close to the airport, the controllers will come in loud and clear but the pilots on approach will be weak or not heard at all. Listened to the feed last night and that sounds like what is happening. You really don't hear the pilots until they are closer in but the controllers are loud and clear. On the tower and ground feeds, you hear the pilots fine.

It could also be the fact that one scanner has to monitor the 4 different approach frequencies. The scanner will scan the appropriate frequencies and will lock onto the first one that it hears something on. You can hear the approach controller transmit to your Dad's plane but if another pilot or controller is also talking on one of the other approach frequencies, as soon as the controller talking to your Dad stops transmitting, the scanner will start to scan again and will lock onto the other transmission before your Dad can respond. With 4 different frequencies and just one scanner trying to catch the transmissions from all 4, it's just not going to happen when it is busy and many will be missed or cut off.

It's still nice having a feed though! We had one at MSY and was one just one scanner covering everything but it still did a pretty good job since we are not as busy and wish we still had it running.



The good old days: Delta L-1011s at MSY
User currently offlineHAWK21M From India, joined Jan 2001, 31667 posts, RR: 56
Reply 13, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 4 days 10 hours ago) and read 4299 times:

Sounds like a range issue....on the feed thats providing data to the website.
regds
MEL.



Think of the brighter side!
User currently offlinen901wa From United States of America, joined Oct 2009, 457 posts, RR: 0
Reply 14, posted (4 years 4 months 2 weeks 4 days 7 hours ago) and read 4182 times:

My 2 cents, I agree with Fly2HMO. Sounds like a freq split. We have that here at LAX late at night arround 2300. Both 121.65 and 121.75 on the same controller. I always double check to make sure I don't step on anyone before we push back to taxi, from the north side to the south side. Before 2300 (I think its 2300) I usally call on 121.65 and at the mid point switch to 121.75. HTH  

Top Of Page
Forum Index

Reply To This Topic I Can Hear ATC, But Not The Pilots, Why?
Username:
No username? Sign up now!
Password: 


Forgot Password? Be reminded.
Remember me on this computer (uses cookies)
  • Tech/Ops related posts only!
  • Not Tech/Ops related? Use the other forums
  • No adverts of any kind. This includes web pages.
  • No hostile language or criticizing of others.
  • Do not post copyright protected material.
  • Use relevant and describing topics.
  • Check if your post already been discussed.
  • Check your spelling!
  • DETAILED RULES
Add Images Add SmiliesPosting Help

Please check your spelling (press "Check Spelling" above)


Similar topics:More similar topics...
LH: Why Does MIA Work Ex DUS, But Not Ex MUC? posted Fri Oct 16 2009 14:35:33 by Dairy
Adam Air Accident-why Didnt The Pilots... posted Sun May 10 2009 05:34:18 by Ajaaron
Boeing Greys?why One, Not The Other? posted Thu Oct 23 2008 11:09:20 by Soon7x7
Why Not The Fuel Dump Option In The B6 A320? posted Thu Sep 22 2005 17:37:21 by Bongo
Paint In The Wings...why Not? posted Mon Feb 14 2005 17:36:41 by Bongo
For The Pilots: Airports You'd Rather Not Fly To posted Thu Aug 28 2003 21:58:01 by John
For The Pilots, An ATC Question posted Wed Aug 13 2003 05:37:42 by Cancidas
Can Airlines Save $$$ By Not Painting Airplanes? posted Fri Mar 26 2010 20:40:25 by c5load
Strobes On While At The Gate... Why? posted Wed Feb 18 2009 21:59:24 by Vio
Can I Fly G Reg Planes In The UK With An FAA PPL? posted Mon Jul 14 2008 04:48:45 by Gulfstream650

Sponsor Message:
Printer friendly format