Tupolev160 From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR: Posted (3 years 2 months 1 week 6 days 10 hours ago) and read 5495 times:
For its relatively short time in service and a modest number of deliveries compared to other modern wide-bodies, the MD-11 has been involved in a considerable number of accidents/incidents, most of them strikingly resembling each other. In many of the occasions, the MD-11 lived: a bounced landing that followed by the aircraft loosing control, breaking the wing, flipping onto its back and - burning.
It has been mentioned that:
"In an effort to improve fuel efficiency, McDonnell Douglas designed the MD-11’s center of gravity to be much further aft than other commercial aircraft. This significantly reduces the margin for error during the takeoff and landing phases. A number of operators have introduced special training to assist crews in safely handling the MD-11's critical phases of flight."
as well as:
"The MD-11 has had problems with its flight control systems, problems that have resulted in multiple accidents and incidents since the aircraft's introduction. The initial design of the slat/flap lever in the cockpit was conducive to accidental dislodgement by crew in flight. The defect has been corrected since 1992. In the early 2000s, Boeing improved the flight control software at the urging of the FAA to reduce the possibility of violent unintentional pitch movements."
Have you flown this aircraft and what is your experience/opinion about this?
bueb0g From United Kingdom, joined Jul 2010, 734 posts, RR: 0
Reply 1, posted (3 years 2 months 1 week 6 days 8 hours ago) and read 5447 times:
The accident you refer to (flipping) has happened three times on the MD-11, and one of those came about after the pilots tried to land in conditions that significantly exceeded the MD-11's maximum crosswind component. The other two were FedEx crashes and they both came about after unstabilised approaches that should have been aborted, with the one at Narita in heavy winds and the autopilot only being disconnected at 200 feet, not giving the pilot flying enough time to farmiliarise himself properly with handling the aircraft in the gusty conditions.
In bad conditions, with a badly flown approach, the MD-11 can become unstable in the flare. Like any aircraft. It's true that the problem is more acute on the MD-11 than most aircraft, and seems particularly more so on the MD-11F, but, flown correctly, there's no reason why it should happen.
I'm sure Wilco737 will at some point comment on this thread and say something along the lines of "Never had a problem with more than 350 landings", and his is a pretty typical experience.
Just like any other aircraft, if you don't fly it properly, it won't fly properly.
Quoting bueb0g (Reply 1): I'm sure Wilco737 will at some point comment on this thread and say something along the lines of "Never had a problem with more than 350 landings", and his is a pretty typical experience.
I never had any problems, like you said. She was/ is a little less forgiving than other airliners, but I personally don't see her as dangerous. I am sure many will disagree here.
She has her quirks and issues, but no airplane is perfect.