Sponsor Message:
Aviation Technical / Operations Forum
My Starred Topics | Profile | New Topic | Forum Index | Help | Search 
Do I Need An Alternate?  
User currently offlineTXdispatcher From United States of America, joined Jul 2013, 1 posts, RR: 0
Posted (1 year 2 weeks 1 day 21 hours ago) and read 3146 times:

I have decided I'm going to pursue a career in the awesome industry! I've signed up to go to dispatch class next month to get my license. I'm trying to get a head start and learn some of this on my own. I have a question about an alternate situation.

Here is the TAF:

KDAL 142103Z 1421/1518 07007KT 6SM -RA SCT080 BKN010 OVC120
FM150200 04008KT 5SM -SHRA BR BKN070 OVC100
FM150500 09007KT 5SM -SHRA BR VCTS BKN040CB OVC070
TEMPO 1509/1513 2SM TSRA BR SCT020 BKN030CB OVC050
FM151300 09008KT 5SM -SHRA BR VCTS BKN020CB OVC040
TEMPO 1513/1517 3SM TSRA BR BKN015CB OVC025

Question #1
If my flight is scheduled to land at 0230 do I have to file an alternate? Even though the main body is forecasting ceilings below 2,000 feet can I just go based on the FM or are both the main body and FM controlling.

Question #2
If my flight is scheduled to land at 0930 would I need to file an alternate? From what I read you do have to file based on TEMPO forecasts.

Thanks for your help!!!!

2 replies: All unread, jump to last
 
User currently offlineMSJYOP28Apilot From United States of America, joined Jul 2009, 219 posts, RR: 1
Reply 1, posted (1 year 2 weeks 1 day 20 hours ago) and read 3091 times:

1-2-3 rule is +/- 1 hour of ETA if weather reports and forecasts ceiling and visibility is less than 2,000 ft or 3 sm visibility, you require an alternate. METAR trend and TAF are both controlling. Both indicate the possibility of the ceiling and visibility being less than 2,000 ft/3sm. Airlines encourage you to dispatch solely based off the TAF since it tends to be more generous and saves fuel money. METARs are weather reports and by regulation this means the METAR trend is controlling as well though this is mainly important to consider for shorter flights more than longer ones where METAR trend may change considerably.

As a dispatcher, you aren't required to file an alternate on the flight plan. When required or thought needed by the dispatcher or pilot, an alternate is designated or selected on the dispatch release and the computer dispatch system calculates the fuel needed to legally get to that alternate.

In your question 1, one hour before your scheduled arrival the main body before 02z shows BKN010 which would require the alternate.

In question 2, the TEMPO is also controlling. If you were to arrive +/- 1 hour from the start to the end of the TEMPO, it would require an alternate be designated on the release. All phrases are controlling on a TAF.

The difference comes when determining whether an alternate is required versus when a flight is legal to launch for the destination. Landing minimums and alternate minimums are based on ETA whereas requiring one is based on +/- 1 hour. Many airline pilots confuse this and every dispatcher gets phone calls about this from time to time.

For landing minimums, visibility is almost always controlling unless the approach plate calls for a ceiling requirement.

For a takeoff alternate, if the departure station is below landing minimums you need a takeoff alternate that needs to be within 1 hour in still air with one engine inoperative of the departure station. A dispatcher has a high workload. Average of 60 releases or flights to be released and flight followed. Because of this, airlines use mileage for how long that time is that way it makes it easier for the dispatcher. Since takeoff alternate is based on an emergency situation, you can consider your 45 min FAR reserve as usable and thus for almost all probable circumstances you wont need extra fuel to get to your takeoff alternate. RVR is controlling for takeoff alternate so legally this can be changed straight up until the takeoff roll.

Remember also, the first line of the TAF is not the main body for the whole TAF. This is a common misconception. The main body in the first line is valid as the main body until the next FM phrase begins at which point that FM is the new main body. There is no common prevailing conditions as many incorrectly believe.

Conditional phrases are all considered controlling for the purposes of weather decision making. The only caveat to this is if the flight is less than 1 hour flight time, you can launch a flight where the forecast is below minimums based on the METAR. Thus you can have a situation where the TAF requires an alternate and is not legal to launch and the METAR can be above landing and 1-2-3 minimums and you are launching the flight but of course with the required alternate.

If the flight is in the air and the weather drops below 1-2-3 limits, you still need to find an alternate inside the fuel range of the aircraft. If you cannot find a legal alternate within fuel range, you can legally continue if you and the captain agree it would be safe to do so and you have a method of escape should things deteriorate and make landing not legal. If you are in flight and your alternate drops below alternate minimums, you need to find another alternate with fuel range. If this is not possible, you either need to divert for more fuel or the captain can continue based on his emergency authority. If a flight has a TAF the drops below landing minimums in the TAF, the flight can continue to the destination and land if it turns out to be above minimums when he arrives. This is known as having the ability to have a "look and see" before diverting. The FAA does not like to see flights diverting once they are in the air and tries its best to limit times when a flight must divert.

The joint responsibility does not end when a flight blocks out. You are not legal from start to finish. Things can change and your responsibility remains the same. You and the captain MUST agree on the release from the weather requirements to the NOTAMs to the MELs and everything else that needs to be considered and any amendments thereafter.

As a dispatcher, your judgment is also to be used. Your releases are due out 1-3 hours before departure and as much as 4-5 hours before arrival time. Depending on the airline, they may want you to send the releases farther out. Pilots and station agents want the releases as early as possible. The funny part is they all get upset when you need to change the release. Its a bit funny because none of them seem to realize the weather is not a constant variable, fuel is not cheap, MELs get added and subtracted and yet they all expect perfection out of a release sent long before the weather may even be forecast or occurring on radar.

It is interesting that people and the FAA focuses so much on pilot workload and stress but ignore dispatcher workload and stress. The FAA at every airline gets upset and starts threatening violations and licenses when dispatchers fail to respond to ACARS messages or send release amendments to flights diverting to airports not listed on the original or amended release as alternate airports but seems to think 60-130 flights are an acceptable amount for one person to handle. When you have 20-30 flights going to a hub at one time and the airline fuel policy and aircraft weight limits dictate only a few alternates can be used and when it comes time to divert and other places are better suited, you are stuck in bad situation of having 20-30 flights legally needing and wanting something from you but you can only calculate the required fuel and do all the documentation for changing the releases in flight for one flight at one time. Makes for an almost impossible situation.

We as dispatchers legally have joint responsibility for the flights we release and flight follow. Just remember that whenever you dispatch that airline management can fire you, write you up and counsel you on fuel usage but they cannot take your license away from you. If flights need to go out late, they go out late. Protect your license.

I am a current Part 121 for American Eagle at their DFW SOC.

[Edited 2013-07-14 17:55:43]

User currently offlineGoldenshield From United States of America, joined Jan 2001, 5970 posts, RR: 14
Reply 2, posted (1 year 2 weeks 1 day 11 hours ago) and read 2963 times:

Great breakdown, but one little nitpick, and I can't blame you for this entirely, as it's the "tribal knowledge" way of remembering it.

Quoting MSJYOP28Apilot (Reply 1):
As a dispatcher, you aren't required to file an alternate on the flight plan.
Quote:

§ 121.619 Alternate airport for destination: IFR or over-the-top: Domestic operations.

(a) No person may dispatch an airplane under IFR or over-the-top unless he lists at least one alternate airport for each destination airport in the dispatch release. When the weather conditions forecast for the destination and first alternate airport are marginal at least one additional alternate must be designated. However, no alternate airport is required if ...

Thus, the way the regulation reads is: You may not dispatch a flight without an alternate, EXCEPT when the weather meets the exemption requirements. Another way to read it is: The Alternate is mandatory; the exemption is not.

Of course, then there's supplemental operations where an alternate is required at all times, but I digress...

[Edited 2013-07-15 02:33:03]


Two all beef patties, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions on a sesame seed bun.
Top Of Page
Forum Index

Reply To This Topic Do I Need An Alternate?
Username:
No username? Sign up now!
Password: 


Forgot Password? Be reminded.
Remember me on this computer (uses cookies)
  • Tech/Ops related posts only!
  • Not Tech/Ops related? Use the other forums
  • No adverts of any kind. This includes web pages.
  • No hostile language or criticizing of others.
  • Do not post copyright protected material.
  • Use relevant and describing topics.
  • Check if your post already been discussed.
  • Check your spelling!
  • DETAILED RULES
Add Images Add SmiliesPosting Help

Please check your spelling (press "Check Spelling" above)


Similar topics:More similar topics...
Can Kabul Be Used As An Alternate? posted Sun Dec 2 2007 11:37:42 by Mozart
What Does This Button Do On An A330? posted Wed May 17 2006 20:08:00 by MM
Cool Things You Can Do With An Aircraft... posted Sun Feb 5 2006 15:29:08 by Kaddyuk
First Flight On Katana Saturday, What Do I Need? posted Thu Apr 21 2005 15:41:31 by Kay
Fun Stuff To Do In An Airplane... posted Fri May 9 2003 21:25:53 by DeltaASA16
Piloting-an Expensive Ticket! Need Hours? I Do.. posted Wed Aug 20 2003 06:10:02 by FSPilot747
How Do You Engage An Autothrottle System? posted Fri Mar 8 2013 13:50:05 by Novice
Why Do Gate Agents Need To Assign Seats? posted Sun May 6 2012 15:49:40 by AlnessW
Need Help ID-ing An Aircraft posted Wed Sep 7 2011 18:12:04 by sleekjet
How Long Do It Take To Fuel An A380? posted Tue Feb 2 2010 17:00:50 by 747400sp

Sponsor Message:
Printer friendly format