http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/trip_reports/read.main/22086/ |
| Topic: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SR 103 Posted 2002-06-25 19:43:30 and read 8074 times. Due to a request to write this report here it is. It was a FRA-JFK-FRA roundtrip done back in November 2000. I was on my way to Boston for a school trip. Some of you already know what the flight was like. For the others, please be warned it is far less than a flattering Singapore Airlines report. ![]() Photo © Jerome Zbinden Check In: As it was a Sunday the counters were packed with people at 6:15am. The flight looked like it was running full. Staff were helpful and managed to get me a window seat with two of my friends sitting next to me. Bags were checked in all the way through to Boston on TWA though boarding passes were not issued. Boarding: We began boarding at 8:00 and I was assigned 39A so I was one of the last onboard. I was welcomed onboard by the IFS with a smile. The last smile I saw on the flight. Reached the seat and was a bit disappointed but it was alright. PTV's looked nice and certainly bigger than the UA 777 I had flown across the Atlantic with 2 weeks later. We pushed back exactly at 8:30. ![]() Photo © Frank Schaefer The Flight: Hot towels were passed out followed by breakfast. I don't have the menu for this so all I can say is that they ran out of my choice and gave me the omelet which was the only thing left. It was ok, never really found the eggs served on planes to be good. The pocket TV was nice and kept me and my "non-aviation" friends busy. There were no walk around, crew did answer the call button when I asked for a coke. A light snack was served before arrival, no idea what, sorry! Like a mini heated quiche or something. Throughout the flight the crew had no smiles, just did their job, like it was an LH flight! Arrival: We landed in the brand new terminal 1 and it was something really good. We collected our bags in no time and were off to the TWA terminal for our flight to Boston. Singapore Airlines 025 Frankfurt-New York JFK Boeing 747-400 Departure 9:15pm Arrival 10:40am Check In: We landed at 3:30 from Boston on TWA so we had plenty of time to check in. The counter just opened at 4:30 when we got there. We managed to get some good seats and were told that the flight was 100% full tonight. We went into the terminal and my friends started bombarding me with questions regarding planes and I answered willingly! Hey when else are you the "know it all?" ![]() Photo © Vasco Garcia Boarding: Boarding started at roughly 8:45 and we were on first having seat 57A. My friends were seated next to me which was good. A steward welcomed us onboard and pointed to our seats. We backed away from the gate at 9:30, no reason given. Worse came when we sat on the side till 9:55. We eventually took off at 10:30, over an hour late. Not one announcement as to why we were late. ![]() Photo © Jason Milligan The Flight: Hot towels were handed out first and menus were handed out after take off but not to all. As I was about to put my hand out to get mine, she walked away. As she went back down the isle a minute or two later I asked her for a menu and this was the response. "We are only serving menus to people who need them. I'm sure you'll want the vegetarian option anyway!" and walked away. At this point one of my American friends that were sitting next to me with a smirk on his faces said "So this is the Singapore Airlines warmth you talk about!" My other German friend that was between the two of us at this point, said something I had not noticed. "You know who the people who need menus are? They are all the 'Caucasians' on this flight!" I said "what?" As I looked around he was right. Every person that had a menu was American or German. In my group there was another Indian and a Turkish, neither of them had a menu either! Either way my freind gave me his menu and this is what it said. DINNER Hors d'Oeuvre Braised Fillet of Fish in Black Bean Sauce Seasoned Mixed Vegatbles, Steamed Rice OR Sauteed Chicken with Fresh Herb and Mushrooms Vegetable Medley, Roast Sable Potatoes Cheese and Crakers Apple & Pecan Nut Pie Coffee - Tea BREAKFAST Choice of Juices Fresh Fruit Appetiser Assorted Breakfast Rools Butter - Fruit Preserve Coffee - Tea I tried to watch mt PTV but guess what? It was not working. I checked to see if my freinds TV's were working and they were. I waited for another memeber of the cabin crew to come round instead of you know who! When a male steward came round, he said "Wait till we reset the system." I said fine, but nothing ever happened. No audio, no video. Then the meal came with the "wonderful" stewardess. I was about to say chicken. Before anything came out of my mouth a tray with a vegetarian dish was slapped in front of me. "Ma'am I would like the chicken, not this please." "We have to save the non-vegetarian for the people that need it!" At this point I lost it. "Look lady, I did not order a vegetarian meal and I certainly am not vegetarian. I can see that you have enough Beef and chicken in the cart. Why won't you give me my choice?" "Because I need to conserve the dishes for the ones that need it!" At this point both my friends were like "just take my chicken, don't give her the satisfaction!" I said no and started an argument. She just walked away as I started off on her. It looked like some sort of Spinache with green pasta. I found it dry, leathery and tasteless. As she came to collect the try, she snipped at me, "Are you done or not?" "yes" "Then hurry up and give it to me!" After the meal was cleared, my freind said he wanted to go to sleep, and said I could use his entertainment system. I plugged my headphones in his armrest and watched a quick movie and then put the music channel on.Throughout the flight, the other stewardesses were polite if not robotic as usual but the "wonderful" stewardess was so rude to the non-caucasian passengers it was unbelievable. When this paticular stewardess came round to serve drinks she automatically skipped my row every single time. In the end I jumped over my freinds to go to the galley to get a small bottle of water. Thankfully I managed to get another stewardess and she smiled and gave me a bottle and asked if I would like anything else? I told her that my PTV was not working and that I was using my freinds. "I am so sorry about that." She then handed me a pen in a black case. "Please accept this as an apology from me." I said thank you. I looked at the pen and it was what Raffles Class passengers get, having flown RC often I know this. This is the legendary SQ that I have been used to for years! Breakfast was served and it consisted of a crossaint, butter and jam. Bread was offered twice. I ordered tea and the "stewaredess" runs out of teawith a snipe "Just wait for it!"During breakfast an Italian woman asked for tea and at last minute changed her mind to coffee. "Look, I don't have time to play these games, you want tea or coffee, make up your damn mind!" Wow, so she was mean to everyone! I saw quite a few passengers giving her dirty looks now. We began our decent and touched down at 11:15, over 30 minutes late. Arrival: During disembarkation I got halted at the galley and she was there with a frown on her face. As the line moved forward I said the following. "I will never fly Singapore Airlines again after receiving service from you. You are a bi*ch and I hope some day someone will write you up on your 'service skills'! At this point the entire section started applauding! I then walked off and I my freind smaked me on the back and said, "Man you were too lienent on her!" Immigration was a breeze and bags were out when I got there. I have never been so happy to get off an airplane and into freezing Germany. I wrote the letter within 2 days of arrival and sent it to the SQ office in FRA. Not a single word came back. I even talked to a freind that works for SQ in BOM. She had no idea why they would not reply me. She insisted I write another letter and this time to SIN. It was too late. I had thrown everything out as it had been over a year and had moved from Germnay to the US. I had no idea what her name was anymore and so on. It was SQ's decision not to answer me! Singapore Airlines is not an airline I am every going to fly if I can help it. Service has been going down for years and this was the last straw. 1 excellent stewardess compared to the others isn't enough! If SR, CX, KL etc can have great cabin crew in numbers, why can't SQ? I know this is not what most of you SQ people like to hear but I think you have to face reality, SQ is changing and it is not for the better. I have heard countless times of people switching to CX, EK and even UA because of the service on SQ. I'll only fly SQ when every other airline is booked, including NW & DL!!! Congratulations Singapore Airlines, you have managed to lose a loyal customer who has been flying SQ for over 15 years, a customer who has flown over 3 Oceans and 4 Continents with you in First, Raffles and Economy. A customer who once upon a time said he would never fly anything but the airline with the Singapore Girl! SR 103 |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Singapore_Air Posted 2002-06-25 20:01:10 and read 7857 times. SR103: Please choose another airline in the future. I have noted down your flight number. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Sabena332 Posted 2002-06-25 20:53:41 and read 7826 times. I am speechless after I have read your trip report. I never thought that SQ offers their passengers that bad service. Good to know, when I am flying to Asia I choose an other airline. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Jaysit Posted 2002-06-25 21:20:47 and read 7804 times. Did you try complaining to the inflight supervisor? |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: 767er Posted 2002-06-26 01:43:08 and read 7741 times. SR103 That was very good |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ryanair!!! Posted 2002-06-26 03:58:34 and read 7711 times. My my ... I felt offended just reading it. It does not reflect well on Singaporeans at all. I hope that it was just her that was like that on that flight. At least someone was nice enough to pass you a pen from Raffles. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ryanair!!! Posted 2002-06-26 04:52:22 and read 7699 times. Maybe I am taking this way too seriously... but I kept putting myself in your shoes and the I felt way I felt during my similar treatment on my SYD-SIN flight, kept playing again and again in my mind. I would have brought the matter up to the In-flight Supervisor because knowing SQ (face saving and all...) something would have been done about it immediately. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: 767er Posted 2002-06-26 05:19:34 and read 7688 times. SR103: I hope her colleagues overheard your comments. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: 9V-SPK Posted 2002-06-26 05:53:52 and read 7680 times. Bad expereicne you've got SR103, and to bw honest if that F.A really had that altitude i'm gonna kick her ass and I'd swear that I'm gonna make charges on her and on SQ! UNACCEPTABLE altitude. I belive it seems that she's the one that had such a bad altitude, and because of her passengers would think that "What Kind Of Airline and service is that". |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SQ772 Posted 2002-06-26 06:12:26 and read 7667 times. SR103, you know, it is not just passengers who realise that SQ's inflight service has gone down the drain. Whenever I meet my ex-colleagues who are still with the company, they also agree with me that these Singapore Girls nowadays are just interested in flying to some fashion capital to buy their Prada bags so that they can show it off to whoever. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: B737-700 Posted 2002-06-26 09:57:56 and read 7633 times.
|
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Singapore_Air Posted 2002-06-26 10:42:20 and read 7615 times. SR103: Please supply me with the dates of your flights. Thank you. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ryanair!!! Posted 2002-06-26 11:44:45 and read 7597 times. Hey all... let me sum it all up. SQ, at the end of the day, is still not that bad of an airline. It has its bad days, like SR103's, and mine, but it is still far superior compared to major competitors similar routes. Agreed? |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SR 103 Posted 2002-06-26 13:58:11 and read 7579 times. Singapore_Air, |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Chepos Posted 2002-06-26 18:19:37 and read 7537 times. Great trip report. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ilyushin96M Posted 2002-06-26 18:52:25 and read 7525 times. I'm always amazed to read reports about flight attendants who behave this way, and even more surprised that no one hauls off and clocks them into next week. I'm certain if I had been treated the way SR 103 was, I would have raised hell with the lead flight attendant and gotten that nasty bitch fired. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SQ772 Posted 2002-06-27 04:52:41 and read 7471 times. Well, Ilyushin96M, it will take more than raising hell to get that FA fired. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Blink182 Posted 2002-06-27 05:31:54 and read 7466 times. You're right, she was a b*tch! I for one am lucky as I have no plans with flying Singapore Airlines as Cathay Pacific is in Oneworld and I can use/accrue mileage with them. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Singapore 777 Posted 2002-06-27 07:18:20 and read 7453 times. Haha...quite sadly, that's what's happening to some of the local girls here. Even some of those who are not SQ stewardesses seem to have a very bad attitude problem. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ex_SQer Posted 2002-06-27 07:36:17 and read 7441 times. Eh, SQ772, you only heard the f-word. I heard the "CB" word from one of those pretty things once. Too many lians!!! Bet none of them went to your sister schools! Or to mine either, for that matter! haha! |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Singapore 777 Posted 2002-06-27 07:45:52 and read 7435 times. Because now very few locals actually want to go and be a stewardess. The idea is that a stewardess is basically a high-class waitress in the sky so most people are discouraged by this idea. That leaves us with basically "lians". |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SQ772 Posted 2002-06-27 08:23:13 and read 7431 times. Well, looks like the main pillars in SQ are the Lians. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Singapore 777 Posted 2002-06-27 15:09:00 and read 7395 times. I hear that coming from the girls in my school all the time so it's really nothing very fantastic haha! Anyway, not all the lians are bad. Some of them are really quite nice people! |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Sq_ek_freak Posted 2002-06-27 21:01:16 and read 7354 times. when I travelled from LAX to SIN via TPE on SQ 029, I stayed onboard the aircraft though everyone was asked to deboard the plane, namely because I was at the time with a friend of mine who worked for SQ. Actually, the ground staff at Taipei treated me as an SQ staff as well. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SQ772 Posted 2002-06-28 05:08:37 and read 7305 times. Singapore777, there is nothing wrong with cursing and swearing vulgarities (I do that all the time). However, I do feel that there should always be a place and time to for such things. Swearing while a crew is officially still on duty (even though no pax are around) is definitely a no no. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Singapore 777 Posted 2002-06-28 06:19:28 and read 7308 times. I'm now studying for a diploma. Previously I was also in an all-boys school and trust me the amount of swearing coming out is enough to drown you! |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ryanair!!! Posted 2002-06-28 08:43:49 and read 7292 times. At the end of the day, as I have said in my previous post in another thread, it depends on the team. Some teams have IFSs that can motivate the crew to go beyond their call of duty, while some others, its simply do-what-you-want. So you get a myriad of working styles from different teams even though at the end of the day, they have their regimental and robotic SOPs to fall back on. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: SQ772 Posted 2002-06-28 09:01:02 and read 7295 times. Just one comment. QUALITY. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ryanair!!! Posted 2002-06-28 09:03:32 and read 7295 times. Or maybe they simply cannot say "hot towel"? |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Auswnfan Posted 2002-06-28 22:48:33 and read 7224 times. It's nice to see that I not the only one who has received less than stellar service from "the World's most arrogant airline!" |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Continental Posted 2002-06-28 23:09:37 and read 7225 times. Ok, why is everyone always ripping on LH? |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Blink182 Posted 2002-06-29 01:13:29 and read 7208 times. I think if Flight crews want to cuss, feel free to, but only when it is appropriate. Everybody has their right of speech(in the USA at least). However, there are times when cussing is inappropriate, and such times is when you are on paid duty, in uniform, and in front of a whole bunch of passengers. I think it is a fair bet that at least a few passengers heard the crew cussing. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: 747-fan Posted 2002-06-29 08:35:23 and read 7180 times. Actually, I personally feel SQ service has been improving. |
| Topic: Continental Username: SR 103 Posted 2002-07-01 14:01:08 and read 7099 times. Did I complain about LH's service? I have noticed you defend Lufthansa quite a bit. Just remember not everyone has the same opinion as you. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Businessflyer Posted 2002-07-02 04:02:46 and read 7016 times. The quality of SQ's staff does seem to vary wildly. I recently had to spend a day in Delhi and had the same crew going out there as coming back. They were absolutely brilliant and made the flight a very pleasant experience. However, I had so many bad experiences on flights to LHR that I now only fly BA (in addition, BA's business class product is far better than SQ's). Maybe the SQ staff do not like the longer-haul flights! Mmm... my wife knows the daughter of the head of crew training at SQ as well as the son of the chief pilot (Singapore is a very very small place!!), so maybe I should get her to ask them! |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Ex_SQer Posted 2002-07-02 08:27:43 and read 7007 times. Yes, Businessflyer is right - the quality of SQ's staff (not just crew - all staff) varies widely. This problem isn't confined to SQ, though... I have had some very inconsistent service on other carriers, most notably UA and BA. |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: 9V-SVA Posted 2002-07-02 09:54:44 and read 6988 times. Kanninabu cheebai nabei you all! I guess my command of vulgar language is more than them, as I use THEM everyday! |
| Topic: RE: The Long Awaited: FRA-JFK-FRA On SQ Username: Navega Posted 2002-07-02 18:47:05 and read 6932 times. So happy to have this come out in the open. SQ Refuses |
Copyright © Lundgren Aerospace. All rights reserved. |