Jakeflyer From United States of America, joined Sep 2006, 46 posts, RR: 0 Posted (7 years 5 months 3 weeks ago) and read 26547 times:
Here it goes... my first trip report...
This is a summary of my (quick) trip to Porto and Lisbon, Portugal departing on 7/15/06 and returning on 7/18/06.
I find that part of the enjoyment of flying is planning how to get there. For my trip to Portugal, I did a lot of research on the internet to explore the various options and prices. I have "Chairman" status on US Airways so I wanted to fly on them---or at least a Star Alliance carrier so I could earn miles towards keeping my US Airways status. This was a business trip and my company will pay for business class on European flights. US Airways offers a seasonal flight from Philadelphia to Lisbon on a 757-200 that has two rows of "first class" seats. This aircraft is typically flown on domestic and Caribbean routes and the seats don't recline like typical first class or business class seats that you would find on transatlantic flights. I researched the internet and found that TAP Portugal was offering a special $1,880 round trip ticket in their "Top Executive" business class. Their website includes a multimedia presentation that details the experience of flying on TAP in business class, including check-in, the lounge, food, cabin, the seats, etc. I found that they go into much more detail than most other airlines do about their business class experience. I was particularly interested in the description of their "Italian designed" seats that seem to recline to a semi flat position and included individual video screens. Since they are part of the Star Alliance, I decided to book my travel with them.
I arrived in Newark Airport about two hours ahead of my flight to Portugal. There were only a few passengers at the counter and check-in went very quickly and smoothly. TAP does not have a club at Newark Airport, but I was given an invitation to the Virgin Atlantic Club instead. During the day, the Virgin Atlantic Club is contracted out by other airlines including Alitalia and El Al so it was very busy. The Virgin Atlantic flights don't leave until later in the evening so the service was not the typical Virgin Atlantic club service that I have heard about (meals, snacks, etc.). Basically all that was offered were drinks and chips.
After spending an hour in the club reading emails, I headed down to the departure gate. The club is in front of the security area so I allowed extra time to make sure I made it through security with plenty of time to board. The gate area was extremely crowded with passengers waiting for flights on other carriers that blended together. For my flight, all classes boarded through the same jet way. The TAP gate agent offered preboarding for families and others who needed assistance. It was as if someone yelled "GO!" because everyone rushed to board. It was a free-for-all at that point with very little order in the boarding process---every man for himself!
The aircraft was a fairly new Airbus A330 with the new award-winning TAP livery that is modern and very pleasing to look at.
To my disappointment, once I boarded I found that my aircraft did not have the special "Italian designed" seats as featured on their website. Rather, they had the traditional business class seats that don't fully recline. (After returning home, I checked the website and the seats are available only on A310s and A340s. They don't make it clear that these seats are not available in Top Executive class on all aircraft.)
The Top Executive class cabin was full as several charter flight attendants that were headed to the Azores to start a flight were upgraded to Top Executive. Passengers were offered a preflight drink of water or orange juice. Soon, we were taxing to the runway and took off to the South over the Atlantic Ocean.
Almost as soon as we got off the ground, the flight crew began preparations for dinner. A dinner menu and separate wine list were handed out.
While I don't drink, I was impressed with the wine list featuring over 11 varieties of Portuguese wine including two sparkling wines, a rosé, three white wines, and five red wines. They also served Portuguese brandy and port wines. The drinks were served from a large cart where the wine was featured. Very impressive
The dinner menu consisted of the following:
Appetizer (choice of)
Roasted Red Pepper Soup
Seared Shrimps with Jicama Salad
And Seasonal Salad
Grilled Beef Filet with Portobello Demi Roast Potatoes and Vegetables
Sesame Crusted Mahi with Grilled Pineapple
Thai Grilled Chicken Breast with Fried Rice and Vegetables
Cheese Manicotti with Marinara Sauce
Selection of Portuguese Cheeses
I couldn't make up my mind on the appetizer, so I asked if I could have both the soup and the shrimp. The flight attendant gave me a curious look and then gave me both. The shrimp and soup were excellent! The presentation could have been better as the cold plates were served with plastic wrap still attached to the dishes. For the main course I ordered the Filet of Beef. I was disappointed that the dinners were served from a cart that was wheeled down the aisle. It sort of cheapened the experience. Next they brought dessert. I asked for both the cheese and the chocolate mousse. Again the flight attendant gave me a curious look and gave me both! Hey, I want to experience it all!
The food and service were both good although I did feel like the flight attendants were rushed to get dinner served and things cleaned up. After dinner, I reclined my chair (not as far as the "Italian designed" chair I am sure) and dozed off.
It was just before dawn as we approached Lisbon. I woke up too late for breakfast and wasn't offered anything as the flight attendants were rushing to secure the cabin. We flew low over the center of Lisbon as we approached the airport. The mix of early dawn and city lights was absolutely stunning. Lisbon is truly a beautiful city. Within a few minutes we were on the ground.
After landing we taxied to a large loading and unloading area with about 20 or 30 other jets. Most of the TAP flights are accessed through an airport bus system called "Ground Force" that provides transportation to the main terminal. We walked down the steps and into the bus for a five minute ride to the terminal. Customs was a bit confusing, but got through without problems. As I was connecting to a flight to Porto, I had to go through security again. I have flown a lot and I have to say, this was the most pleasant experience I have EVER had going through security. It was very civilized and unrushed with a friendly security guard to assist me with putting my bags on the conveyer, taking out my lap top, and to check my passport and boarding pass. There was another guard on the other side who helped me take my bags off and repack my laptop computer and made sure I had everything and directed me to my connecting gate. Everyone in security was friendly, smiling, and extremely helpful... and this was at 7:00 on a Sunday morning! TSA could take some notes.
I found my connecting gate and within a half hour boarded another bus to take me out to my flight to Porto. This time, the aircraft was a fairly used A319. Business class on an A319 has the same 3-3 configuration as coach with just a bit more leg room. All the seats on this aircraft were leather. There wasn't any food offered on the flight, only orange juice. The flight was a short half hour and we arrived in Porto at about 8:30 AM. The Porto Airport was new, efficient, and had jet ways--a big contrast from Lisbon.
The night before my return flight I stayed at the Raddison Hotel close to the Lisbon Airport. It is also close to the subway station so I was able to get out and see a bit of the city during my rushed trip. The Raddison also has a shuttle to the airport which makes it very convenient. I got up early and enjoyed one of the better continental breakfasts I have had. I took the shuttle to the airport (about a 15 minute ride) and arrived two hours before my flight. I checked in and was given an invitation to the Top Executive lounge. The entrance to the lounge was hard to find. I had to ask several people where it was located. The entrance is located after you pass through security, then you go up an escalator, you pass the McDonalds and it tucked between some duty free shops, down a small corridor. It was smaller than it looks on their website. The food selection in the club was fairly limited, but it was still a quite place to sit away from the duty free crowds and wait for the flight (I did end up going to McDonalds and got a McFlurry to tide me over until my flight!).
Even though my bags had been screened and my passport was checked at security, as I entered the gate area both were checked again and I was selected to have my bags searched. As I mentioned before, most TAP flights are accessed via a bus. Again, families and passengers needing extra assistance were boarded first. And again there was a mad dash to board the bus to the plane. It was announced that Top Executive class would board the buses last. A few Top Executive Class passengers attempted board early, but were told they couldn't board yet and were turned away. I guess this is so we could "relax" in the boarding area and not have to wait on a bus, but it was somewhat confusing. I finally boarded the bus and took the five minute ride to the plane. Again, it was an A330 so I still was not able to experience those "Italian designed" seats featured on the website. This time there were two sets of stairs---one to coach, the other to business class. There was some light rain so I hurried to get on board. The Top Executive class cabin was almost empty with less than ten passengers (coach was full). Once the flight was boarded, we taxied and took off for the trip to Newark. Within minutes we were over water and the flight attendants began the preparations for lunch.
A lunch menu and a wine list were given to each passenger. The lunch menu consisted of the following:
Appetizer (choice of)
Cauliflower Soup with Cottage Cheese and Coriander
Mushroom Salad with Asparagus and Mint
And Seasonal Salad
Partridge Pie (that is really what it said)
Salt-Cod with Traditional Portuguese Cornbread
Caramelized Pork Tenderloin with Potato Gratin
Penne with Sautéed Green Asparagus
Selection of Portuguese Cheese
Pumpkin and Lemon Tart accented with Aniseed
Neither of the appetizers sounded appetizing, and I ordered the cauliflower soup. It was actually very good. The main course selection also didn't appeal much to me either. The flight attendant mentioned that they didn't have the partridge pie but had a beef dish instead. I gladly took the beef dish. Again for dessert I asked for, and received both selections. The pumpkin and lemon tart was especially good.
After lunch, the shades were drawn and most people settled back for a rest. I ended up working on my computer for about an hour and sleeping for about three hours as the movie choices weren't very good.
Before landing we were served a snack. At first glance I thought it was a ham and cheese sandwich, but it turned out to be a smoked tuna and boiled egg sandwich. My first bite was my last!
Between lunch and the light snack, there wasn't any other food offered or available (which one would expect---especially in business class)... not even a pretzel!
The return flight was smooth and relaxing. One of the highlights of the flight was our flight path over Sable Island about 130 miles ESE of Halifax, Nova Scotia. It is about 25 mile long by about a mile wide at its widest point. It is basically a huge sandbar in the middle of the ocean and is notorious for causing many shipwrecks over the years. I once lived in Nova Scotia and have heard a lot of tales about this island, and so seeing it from 35,000 feet was a treat.
The rest of the trip was uneventful. As we approached Newark, we took a large circle over Long Island and New York City to the North and landed in Newark.
Portugal is a beautiful country and would love to return when I can spend more time. Would I fly TAP again?... maybe, but I would make sure I booked Top Executive on an A310 or A340. Also, the Star Alliance system needs some work as my miles still have not posted to my US Airways account. I called TAP and they are working on it, but make sure you keep you boarding pass to prove you were on the flight!
Food: 7.5 out of 10 (if you don't count the smoked tuna and boiled egg sandwich)
Wine Selection: 11 out of 10 (even though I don't drink)
Seat: 6 out 10 (it wasn't the "Italian designed" seat)
Service: 8 out 10
In-flight Entertainment: 5 out of 10
Lounge: 7.5 out of 10
767747 From United States of America, joined Jan 2005, 1870 posts, RR: 25
Reply 6, posted (7 years 5 months 2 weeks 6 days 3 hours ago) and read 25757 times:
Amazing report! Great pictures! I haven't heard much about TAP Portugal, but when I was flying out of EWR last, I remember seeing signs for "Top Executive" when I was checking in at Terminal B. The seats and food looks pretty good. The "new" livery for TAP does look very nice.
The miles were credited to my account today. TAP forwarded a letter to me documenting my travel. I forwarded the letter to US Airways Dividend Miles. I even got bonus miles for flying in business class.
Quoting Zrs70 (Reply 5): How was the IFE?
How is the amenity kit?
The IFE was OK. There were a few channels to choose from but it wasn't AVOD. Movies repeated themselves.
The amenity kit was nice (pic follows). Not shown are the socks as I used them. The return amenity kit was more colorful and the contents were orange.
Quoting BA319-131 (Reply 7): Where is the champagne? - I know you don't drink but it should be offered.
No champagne was offered as a preflight drink on either flight as I recall. They did bring around glasses of port after dinner however.
Quoting Nimish (Reply 8): How was the crew? And was there a difference in their standards on different sectors - or were they uniformly good/bad?
The crew was very nice and accommodating although sometimes I felt like they had a job to do and were doing it (if that makes sense). Overall standards were uniformly good.
Quoting Nimish (Reply 8): Did you manage to get any pictures of the terminal/lounge at LIS?
CV990 From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 10, posted (7 years 5 months 2 weeks 3 days 19 hours ago) and read 24952 times:
I'm glad that you enjoyed flying our national airline TAP. It is a pitty that you were disapointed with those seats, but let me tell you that the brand new A330-200's that TAP will start to receive from October 2007 on will have those...or even better ones. Has you probably know TAP A330-200 are ex: Swissair, not very old ( around 6/7 years old ). The selection of wines is a very good reflex on how TAP and portuguese in general love and appreciate wine, I'm glad you founded impressive and it's a pitty you didn't taste one or two of those wines, we have excelent wines in Portugal!!! Finnally, and still related with wines, TAP was one of the first ( if not the first..) airlines in the world to give small bottles of red or white wine in economy class since many years ago until things started to change, in all routes except domestic ones!
Glareskin From Netherlands, joined Jun 2005, 1292 posts, RR: 1
Reply 12, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 2 days 13 hours ago) and read 23164 times:
Quoting Jakeflyer (Thread starter): To my disappointment, once I boarded I found that my aircraft did not have the special "Italian designed" seats as featured on their website. Rather, they had the traditional business class seats that don't fully recline. (After returning home, I checked the website and the seats are available only on A310s and A340s.
I flew LIS - EWR on a A310 yesterday. The Italian Designed seats look good but seemed old and mine wasn't functional 100% (though I could go almost flat). Those are certainly not fully flat-bed seats! Love those Airbus widebodies though. The old A310's still present a quiter cabin than the modern 777. Impressive!
Quoting Jakeflyer (Reply 9): The IFE was OK. There were a few channels to choose from but it wasn't AVOD. Movies repeated themselves.
The A310 doesn't have a IFE. That was probably the most dissapointing.
Quoting LipeGIG (Reply 1): Thanks for sharing this report with us. I never travel on A332 Business (only my dad) and their comment is that the A343 is more comfortable (TP uses both planes to GIG)
I'm flying GIG - LIS next week and my itinerary says A330-200. Does this aircraft feature IFE in Top Executive class?
Quoting Jakeflyer (Thread starter): The presentation could have been better as the cold plates were served with plastic wrap still attached to the dishes
Yes I was amazed that they didn't remove it. It looks so much better if they do. And I loved the taste. Do I use TAP again. I probably will but I surely first check if the aircraft has IFE....
There's still a long way to go before all the alliances deserve a star...
CV990 From , joined Dec 1969, posts, RR:
Reply 13, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 2 days 13 hours ago) and read 23131 times:
The only TAP airplanes that have IFE are the 3 ex: SWISS, the 4 ex: Austrian A330-223 and the brand new 5 A330-202's that will replace the A310-300's from November on. The A340-300's also don't have IFE, so before you fly TAP please make sure you'll not fly either the A310-300 or the A340-300.
Semsem From Israel, joined Jul 2005, 1779 posts, RR: 3
Reply 14, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 2 days 10 hours ago) and read 22861 times:
The snack you got in C is the typical meal one gets on Y TAP flights in Europe. I flew on 4 segments and we got exactly the same sandwich. The only difference was that on 3 segments the bread was "bad" while on 1 segment the bread was great.
TAP also operate a EWR to Porto flight on A310. However I don't think it's daily. I agree with you. The Porto airport is a pleasure. New and quiet without too much traffic. Lisbon airport is not very pleasant. Landing in Lisbon is quite an experience flying low next to high buildings. Unfortunately I was sitting on the aisle. If I ever return to Lisbon I will make sure to have a window seat.
Thanks for posting. I always wondered what the C service was like. I wanted to post my trips on TAP but I have no more space for pictures.
Nimish my experiences with the crews in Y were the following. They are reserved but friendly. I was very impressed by how well groomed both the women and men are. They were all young.
LX64A332 From Switzerland, joined Aug 2007, 273 posts, RR: 0
Reply 17, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 1 day 23 hours ago) and read 22260 times:
Very nice TR! Its the same thing with LX and their A332,on their website they only describe and show pictures of the A340, and thus many people, including some of my family, who have visited mem were upset they didn't get the business class discribed with the photos on LX's website, but instead got ancient seats that LX still has on all its A332's, wich serve the MIA run.
OA260 From Ireland, joined Nov 2006, 26375 posts, RR: 58
Reply 18, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 1 day 12 hours ago) and read 21987 times:
Hi there I was looking forward to a TP trip report but like yourself I was a bit dissapointed to see that they dont have the nicer seats on that AC!!! The food on the outward looked better than the return to be honest. Hopefully if you fly them again you willl get a new seat!! I thought TAP would have been a bit better .
Thanks for sharing
AEGEAN-OLYMPIC AIR - ΟΛΥΜΠΙΑΚΗ " μέλος στη Star Alliance
Airlineanorak From United Kingdom, joined Sep 2007, 85 posts, RR: 0
Reply 19, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 1 day 12 hours ago) and read 21959 times:
It is a shame you didn't get the new product, but I have heard that it is at quite an angle and people keep wakening up after sliding to the bottom of the bed. I think some older style cradle seats are more comfortable than some 'angle-flat' beds.
Comeflywithme From Argentina, joined Sep 2006, 265 posts, RR: 2
Reply 20, posted (6 years 5 months 2 weeks 1 day 9 hours ago) and read 21816 times:
Thanks for your report.
Just as well you got a special fare as I am not impressed with the product. The seats look nothing great and the presentation especially of the beef dish with the sauce splattered all over the plate is very poor and the amenity kit is like something one would get in economy +.
Good to get a report about TAP and much appreciated.
Jakeflyer From United States of America, joined Sep 2006, 46 posts, RR: 0
Reply 22, posted (6 years 5 months 1 week 5 days 14 hours ago) and read 21246 times:
To be fair, I submitted this trip report last year and came back to the top after a reply a few days ago... so I'm not sure if my experience with TAP last year is the same as what one would expect today (although my guess is that it is). Overall my impression with TAP is that the new corporate design and livery is very modern and appealing (and won some awards as well)--but it does not reflect the product on the inside. As I recall, the flight attendants were more focused on getting a job done rather than focusing on creating a memorable customer experience and it doesn't take much more effort to do so. It has got to be a complete package. Also, one more bit of advice... if you are offered the smoked tuna and boiled egg sandwich... don't take it!!!!
CF-CPI From Canada, joined Nov 2000, 955 posts, RR: 0
Reply 23, posted (6 years 5 months 1 week 1 day 20 hours ago) and read 20878 times:
Great report on an airline that is not featured too often. I love the new livery and would like to fly TAP sometime, though I wish the L-1011-500 had been around long enough to get repainted in the new design!
One of the offerings was salt cod, which seems to be a Portuguese specialty. I have had it here in a restaurant, and tasted something referrred to as 'green wine', which had a tart but very unique taste.
Loalq From Switzerland, joined Jan 2007, 217 posts, RR: 3
Reply 25, posted (6 years 4 months 2 weeks 11 hours ago) and read 20354 times:
I have flown TAP A330 LIS-GIG and GIG-LIS just recently (a couple of weeks ago), also in Top Executive. I must say their business product is by far the worst in comparison to IB and AF (which I am used to). Terrible food, terrible service, no VOD, only 3 channels on the entertainment system, LIS is a joke of an airport and the business lounge is also mediocre.
Still, I chose to fly this route 4x more this year, because I want to turn to Senator Status
Kudos to the A330, what a nice and silent airplane. felt much better than the A340 or the 744.
"...this is your captain speaking. We have a small problem. All four engines have stopped."