Phil, my pickiness is way beyond yours... It's quite sad actually. I'll explain in a second.
AA61hvy, you make yourself sound weirder and weirder every day! LOL Are you saying that all of your female friends have perfect eyebrows? I'd like to see what you define as nice eyebrows... So if you have a pic, post it.
I tend to do an overall inspection before I decide that she is attractive.
First of all, she must have a pretty face. This includes pretty eyes, thin, proportional lips, nice ears, clean-stylish hair, few skin imperfections (pimples and such), and a nice nose. Teeth are ideally straight and white. Eyebrows should not be plucked to hell, meaning that there is still something there. If she chooses to wear make-up, she should know how to apply it. Foundation should match her skin color and be applied evenly. Basically, the girl should look very similar with make-up to how she does without it. I can't stand not being able to recognize the girl that I first became attracted to.
A girl's body is also very important. I think her shoulders should not be too wide. This makes them look quite masculine. I also hate a ghetto booty. All that crap "more cushion for pushin" is just that. Crap. I will share a secret with you all, that my mother once shared with me. "It just keeps getting bigger". This is why J Lo butt's are not very desirable. Therefore a nice, not flat, but small ass is what I like. Legs are also very important. Ideally they will be straight and be nice in the knee area. I can not stand when a girl has manly knees. The legs should always be shaved, and contrary to popular belief, they should be shaved from the tip of the toes, all the way up to the bikini line. Not just up to the thigh. A girl should also have small feet. Not only should they be small, but nice feet. Toenails should be SHORT, not long. They should also all be either painted or unpainted. That chipping is very unattractive. She should have long, thin fingers with nice fingernails. They should be long, if they look nice long, and short if the nail is weaker. Finger nails should NEVER be chewed, and must also be either painted or unpainted. They should also never be dirty underneath. Those horrible fake nails that look like shovels attached to the ends of their fingers are also a huge turnoff. I know only 2 girls who always have their finger nails either always painted or always unpainted. This shows that the girls takes care of herself. Breasts do not need to be overly huge, but should be in proportion with the girls body. She should have a nice firm stomach, although it should not be a six pack or any other type of pack. I don't like tattoos either.
Dress is also very important. I tend to prefer a girl who has that preppy style. I also like a girl who dresses very professionally. One who looks good in the Lufthansa German Airlines Uniform, and one that can wear high heels and not look ridiculous.
Go ahead, bash me, do your worst. I can take it.