I love the guy's show, joined the Premium site for a while.
IMO, It's not really worth the price at all.
I mean, I can tune my radio to listen to O'Reilly if listening at home, and if I'm online elsewhere... then there's a good chance that listening to a talk show (even with headphones) wouldnt be an option. I really don't care about archived articles and there are already public polls on the site, so why bother with private members-only ones?
On the other hand; you may want to try Sean Hannity's website
, which has all the same features as O'Reilly's Premium site (including live & 24hr streaming of Hannity's radio show
), but everything's free