Capt.Fantastic
Topic Author
Posts: 811
Joined: Thu Aug 12, 1999 4:01 am

Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 6:37 am

I just wanted to see what ya'll thought about some of the new color schemes. The best, and the worst.

I'll start off with what I consider the worst livery. I shall bestow this honor on Middle East Airlines (no offense CedarJet). Although I like MEA, I find their new livery incredibly ugly! The all white fuselage with the type-writter-font "MEA" on the side wasn't exactly a leap of creativity. Adding insult to injiry is the lonely cedar tree on the tall; actually, it dosent even look like a cedar tree ... more like bushy green shrub. The two baby cedar trees on the engine pods look rediculous and out of place. All in all, just a bad design.

I think the best liveries are that of Air Canada and United Airlines. Air Canada's tail is awesome! United uses good color combinations, along with the classic orange, red, blue thin stripe along the side. The over all effect is sleek, and classy.

Also, I hate these new "modern" schemes that seem to emphasize snazzy writting and wild paint stokes, e.g., Varig and Britsh Airways (World Schemes). I feel the more sleek, elegant look is best for an airliner. An obnocsious livery cheapens the integrity of the aircraft. Anyone agree? What do you guys think?

Jim
 
flyaa757
Posts: 850
Joined: Mon Jun 14, 1999 7:12 am

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 6:47 am

I agree with your comments about MEA. I think that UA's livery is gaudy, and too complicated. Air Canada has a wonderful tail. It would be nice to see that type of creativity applied to the fuselage. I love TWA's new colors. They really look great, especially on the 757.
 
AC183
Posts: 1496
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 1999 10:52 am

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 10:03 am

I think Air Canada has a good scheme, and I think the fuselage, although fairly plain, looks pretty good. I think their tail is also very good, but I wish that green colour on the tail looked a little more like the deep forest green colour its supposed to be, not so black.

Also, Canadi>n's new livery is good. I just despised their old one, but their new one is pretty nice. I'm not sure I like it more than AC's, but I really find it quite appealing. The only problem is looking at it from certain angles the goose looks a little wrong, but at a good angle its quite nice. I also really like the return to the goose logo, which dates back to the days it was Canadian Pacific, and earlier to its forerunners.

Also, Cathay Pacific is quite attractive.

Probably one of the worst liveries I have ever seen would be Southwest's.
 
tygue
Posts: 220
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 1999 4:42 pm

From A Canadian Point Of View

Sun Aug 15, 1999 10:21 am

Hello all,

Worst: Canada 3000.
I love the airline, but their scheme is just way too dull. Not even original! Cam from Air2000/Air3000 in 1988.

Best: Canadian Airlines
Beautiful. Very well designed.

IMHO
Tygue
 
Guest

RE: From An Australian Point Of View

Sun Aug 15, 1999 11:07 am

The majority of aircraft seen here are plain white fuselages, thanks to Ansett, Qantas and Air New Zealand... they're getting a bit boring now!!

Here, it's great to see Singapore Airlines' colours, the old BA, United (the grey IS a bad idea, but it still looks good), I like Canadian's older colours, China Airlines' new colours, JAL's Resort Express 747s.

Other great ones: America West, TWA,

Ones that "take a while to like": new Virgin colours, new Canadian, new SAS.

Dull/boring ones: National, MEA (you're right!), Air France, Alitalia, Delta, Northwest, ANA, Sabena
 
Cody
Posts: 2172
Joined: Tue May 18, 1999 12:16 pm

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 11:52 am

I don't care too much for USAirways new color scheme. The dark blue makes it very hard to see. The best current livery is either TWA or Continental. My all time favorite color scheme is the blue and green of Air Florida or the pink and blue cloud scheme of Northeastern International.
 
Guest

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 12:28 pm

My favourite is Cathay Pacific's colours! It is very modern Asian livery. It is just stunning and inspiring.
 
Guest

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 12:38 pm

Bests:

TWA
BA (World Images)
UAL (I like the colors... very interesting)

Worsts:

BA (with "UJ" on tail)
DELTA oc
TWA oc
 
flyCMH
Posts: 2146
Joined: Fri Jul 09, 1999 12:15 pm

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 12:58 pm

There are a lot of airlines out there with very smart, appealing liveries, here are my favorites:

South African Airways (Great tail!)
Varig Airlines of Brasil (n/c)
Cathay Pacific
Trans World Airlines (my favorite)
USAirways
America West Airlines
Air Canada (also nice tail)
Midway Airlines
 
User avatar
VIflyer
Posts: 452
Joined: Wed May 26, 1999 2:29 pm

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 1:38 pm

Worst: Virgin Atlantics New Scheme
Yuck.....just plain Yuck

Best: BA (I like the tails schemes) and UAL (great over all colors)
I reject your reality and subsitute my own
 
WindowSeat
Posts: 1198
Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2003 3:01 am

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 2:13 pm

Everyone who has responded thus far has failed to mention one of the classiest, and most elegant liveries in the air today: AMERICAN AIRLINES! I believe AA has one of the best color schemes flying today. The silver stainless steal image reflects strengh and power, but also eminates elegance and prestige. I especially appreciate the color scheme on the newer aircraft, in which the tail and engine pods are represented in a soft shade of gray. The shiny silver, coupled with the enlightening gray gives an impressive color contrast that looks great on any aircraft.

The worst scheme must go to Southwest. The next generation 737's deserve more respect than to be dressed in a spoiled mustard yellow paint scheme.
I would like to agree with CaptFantastic, MEA looks like the livery was chosen from an art contest amungst 3rd graders, and the loser won!
I'm all in favour of keeping dangerous weapons out of the hands of fools. Let's start with keyboards.
 
mdsmith11
Posts: 187
Joined: Sat Jul 24, 1999 12:12 pm

My Two Cents Worth

Sun Aug 15, 1999 2:47 pm

I realize that probably no one will agree with me, but then again I was asked for my opinion and here it is:

I do agree that United's color scheme is quite attractive and classy...I only wish that the logo on the tail coulda been a lil larger

American and Southwest; long overdue for new colors although all of the SW special jets are appealing

Delta; Their old colors were not that attractive and the new ones aren't really that much different, however a new coat of paint will make anything look good

America West; I liked their old and their new colors equally. The blue pin stipes with the AW on the tail to me was a very "professional" image.

I liked US Air's old colors much more that US Airways. However for a US Air plane to look good in those old colors, it must be freshly washed...the bare metal gets dirty and seems to show it more easier than a painted surface.

Northwest; To me, it looks like a bowling shoe in bad taste.

Alaska Airlines; Equally tied with America West O/C as my favorite

 
Guest

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 3:32 pm

My favorite new scheme is UA's, i love the scheme. I think it looks especially good on the 722s. I think the worst old scheme is AC's old scheme. I think the best new schemes are UA and DL. I think the best old scheme is DL, i liked that design.
 
User avatar
F-WWKH
Posts: 309
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 1999 8:23 pm

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 3:59 pm

It is a little confusing to see people listing up Megacarrier after Megacarrier, especially the US ones, when there are many wonderful schemes out there that no other Airline applying (european-)white or (us-)grey/silver scheme can ever compete with.

Probably you dont know what I'm talking but have you heard of Air Tanzania? Breathtaking!

Or Ethiopian Airlines. It even originates from the 1950s and looks amazing on just every aircraft type.

And very funny actually to complain about MEA's livery and then come up with Air Canada - excellent joke!
MEA's livery is even more colorful than Air Canada's, well, imagine it has a black (yes i know, greeen) tail as well.

And Canadian is nice, but it'll be interesting how ridiculous that mighty goose will look on the tail of a DC-10...
 
FLY777UAL
Posts: 4830
Joined: Tue May 18, 1999 3:49 am

Here Are Some For Ya, F-WWKH!

Sun Aug 15, 1999 4:18 pm

My favorite airline liverys: (in no particular order)

--Royal Jordanian--their new livery looks great! The crown...wow!
--Air Tanzania--the giraffe on the 767-200 tail...now that is a great looking plane!
--Air Seychelles--professional, classy, GREAT to photograph, and easy and fun to look at!
--Saudi Arabian-- their new livery speaks for itself. Just look at their new 747-400's...wow!

How's that for the 'out of the ordinary'...?

FLY777UAL
 
dash8tech
Posts: 708
Joined: Mon Jul 05, 1999 8:40 pm

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 6:39 pm

Southwest have the worst in my opinion, great airline, but terrible livery! Except for the special liveries, ie the Whales and the Lonestar. The Orange, red...yuck! Gotta go.

The best? Just something about those shiney silver AA planes! Alaska and Horizon have the good looking swoosh logos going-but that's a biased opinion. Air Canada and the new maple leaf is really nice as well.
 
User avatar
F-WWKH
Posts: 309
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 1999 8:23 pm

RE: Here Are Some For Ya, F-WWKH!

Sun Aug 15, 1999 6:57 pm

That's it!

But as you say, beyond the ordinary.
Just like the 'tropic' colors of ATA, I like it!
Agree that this wouldnt be the perfect livery for an airline targeting business people or a global carrier though!

Or what about the new Sterling color? Just like Braniff...
 
Guest

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Sun Aug 15, 1999 6:58 pm

I always did love the bright colours and the clever style of both the name and logo of one American airline nobody seemsto think of: Hawaiian!
 
Air_Chick_757
Posts: 175
Joined: Wed May 19, 1999 2:23 am

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Mon Aug 16, 1999 1:34 am

I will make my list by continents...
South America
* Best: Varig, Aerolineas Argentinas (quite nice), Transbrasil and Lan Chile (new livery, but the old is also nice)
* Worst: Ecuatoriana, VASP, TAM and Aero Peru

North America
* Best: United, AA (the commemorative scheme), Air Canada, Pan Am (it´s nice, don´t ask me why!), the Boeing livery and Northwest
* Worst: Southwest (that "flying mustard" is really obnoxious), AmeriJet, Air Florida and PSA

Europe
* Best: BA, Iberia (not that nice, but...), Corsair, Sterling (I think they are the new Braniff) and KLM
* Worst: Air France, Lufthansa, Alitalia, SAS, Air Croatia, Finnair and CSA

Australasiasia, Middle East and Africa
* Best: ANA, JAL, South African Airways, Singapore Airlines, Cathay Pacific (very classy), Royal Jordanian, Qantas and Ansett
* Worst: KAL, PIA, Garuda Indonesia and Air New Zealand

 
Concorde SST
Posts: 68
Joined: Mon Jul 26, 1999 3:51 am

RE: Best & Worst Liveries

Mon Aug 16, 1999 5:15 am

There’s too many airlines to pick just one so….
**I liked Air_Chick_757’s layout, so I’ll do something similar:

NORTH AMERICA:
>Best:
TWA (new c/s much better)
United (classy)
Northwest (love the red)
America West (new c/s original)
Canadi>n (new c/s original)
*honorable mention - Delta (new c/s, better)
>Worst:
Southwest (just awful, "flying mustard" yes!)
Kiwi
Continental (liked the old c/s better)

SOUTH AMERICA:
>Best:
Varig (classy)
LAN Chile (very nice)
Aerolineas Argentinas (A340’s look great)
>Worst:
TAM Brasil
VASP

EUROPE:
>Best:
BA (world images)
KLM (love the blues)
Condor (just like it)
*honorable mention - Aeroflot (new c/s)
>Worst:
Air France (please change, think artistic)
Iberia (getting old)
Alitalia (needs something new)
easyJet

MIDDLE EAST, AFRICA:
>Best:
Saudi Arabian (captures the impression of the homeland quite nicely)
Royal Jordanian (very elegant)
South African (nice change)
Gulf Air (simple elegance)
Arkia (nice change)
>Worst:
MEA
Royal Air Maroc (needs a change)
Emirates

ASIA:
>Best:
China Airlines (beautiful)
Thai Airways (love the cheat line)
Singapore
Cathay Pacific
Japan Air System (dare to be different - love the B777)
>Worst:
Air China
All Nippon
Asiana

OCEANIA:
>Best:
Air Tahiti Nui (cool design)
Ansett Australia
Air New Zealand
>Worst:
Air Pacific

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: AsiaTravel, Baidu [Spider], BlueF9A320, kraz911, lcycs300, Navion, Planesmart, Polot, qf789, RobertNL070, SamYeager2016, VirginFlyer and 255 guests