Aircellist
Topic Author
Posts: 1300
Joined: Fri Oct 08, 2004 8:43 am

Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 1:07 pm

Cellist Paul Katz had a distressing moment on Westjet a few days ago. He thought he had purchased a ticket to fly from YYC to LAX on AA... yet, because of a codeshare, he was indeed on Westjet. He had purchased a ticket to carry his cello, a 1669 Andrea Guarneri which must be valued a small fortune, onboard.

Once in the plane, he was told, to his great distress, that he had to send his cello in the luggage compartment. He's been bumped after boarding. This is his story, written as it unfolded.

http://articles.boston.com/2012-08-2...6_1_cello-flight-attendant-westjet

Excerpt:

Quote:
Check the cello in baggage or get off the plane. That’s my choice.

“Sweet,” I say. “If I get off, how will you get me there?"

“Please understand, sir, the cello will not be allowed on any other WestJet aircraft.”

“Will you put me on another airline?”

“That will be your own responsibility.”

In the aftermath, an exchange happened between him and a Westjet customer agent.

http://cellobello.com/blog/index.php...tjets-robert-barron-and-paul-katz/

Excerpt:

Robert Barron:
One lesson perhaps to be learned from this is always to check your airline booking for codeshare and interline flights; these are becoming more and more common, and not all airlines’ policies, allowances, etc., are the same. As Mr Katz learned to his distress, what is allowable on one airline may not be on another. It’s best never to make assumptions, especially when there are any special circumstances such as a disability, special diet – or a musical instrument – are involved.

Paul Katz:
This response, implying I am the problem, infuriates me! In the bewildering world of online purchases and codeshares, does the airline itself have NO responsibility? Why was I able to buy a ticket for a cello on WestJet if you don’t allow them on board? Why should you not program your computers to reject cello tickets? Airlines have programmed their computers to close Frequent Flyer accounts opened in the name of a cello, and yet you allow us to pay for a seat , arrive at the gate, board the plane, an then, after throwing us off, lecture us that we didn’t do proper homework!



From the whole story, I get the feeling the company does not take any responsibility at all.

This brought to the forefront an online petition: Fair treatment for musicians traveling on planes with their instruments

https://www.change.org/petitions/fair-treatment-for-musicians-traveling-on-planes-with-their-instruments

Please, fellow A.netters, take the time to sign this so that my colleagues and me could travel more easily. I also find highly unpleasant to have to give an instrument to send it to the luggage compartment, even though my cello is worth a hundred times (at least) less than Paul Katz', I do feel the same way whenever it happens. Plus, it missed a connection once (in CDG...).
"When I find out I was wrong, I change my mind. What do you do?" -attributed to John Maynard Keynes
 
HPRamper
Posts: 4635
Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 4:22 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 1:35 pm

I've never even seen a booking site or engine that did not specify if the flight was a codeshare. I believe it is policy to list a flight as such. If one books through an agency or lets corporate travel do the booking, then it may be different but Katz himself seems to imply he booked online.

The story seems exaggerated as well. A bumpy takeoff? Does YYC have speed bumps on the runway? If the cello is in a proper case a little turbulence is not going to damage it especially in the manner he seems to be afraid of, as if a little jostle is going to shatter the thing.
 
phljjs
Posts: 296
Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2005 7:26 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 1:44 pm

Sorry, but I really don't have any sympathy for this person.

When purchasing an airline ticket, it's pretty easy to see which carrier is actually operating the flight and whether or not the flight is a code-share of some sort. It's up to the passenger to do his due diligence and research what, if any, policies apply to them, their luggage and any "special items" they may be traveling with. All of that information can easily be obtained on the airlines websites, but the key is to do your homework. Apparently, this person took prior experiences for granted and it bit him in the butt.

I frequently travel with a firearm in my checked luggage. I've never had an issue with any of the different airlines that I've flown. That doesn't mean that I won't have a problem in the future. Most airlines have very similar policies for firearms, but some are different. Before I book a ticket, I do my research and make sure the airline I wish to travel on does indeed accept firearms in checked luggage. I also review their policies on how they need to be packed, what type of bag is required, etc. Sitting down and reading for 5 or 10 minutes can save you a lot of time and trouble when you show up at the ticket counter to check in.
 
cheeken
Posts: 131
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:21 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 2:24 pm

Quoting HPRamper (Reply 1):
The story seems exaggerated as well. A bumpy takeoff? Does YYC have speed bumps on the runway? If the cello is in a proper case a little turbulence is not going to damage it especially in the manner he seems to be afraid of, as if a little jostle is going to shatter the thing.

It's not the turbulence that kills the instrument, (okay it can be the cause if there is) but rather the temperature and the air pressure of the cargo holds that are extremely hostile to instruments, particularly those made of wood (strings/guitars/harps)
 
kl911
Posts: 3981
Joined: Mon Jul 21, 2003 1:10 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 2:39 pm

Quoting phljjs (Reply 2):
When purchasing an airline ticket, it's pretty easy to see which carrier is actually operating the flight and whether or not the flight is a code-share of some sort. It's up to the passenger to do his due diligence and research what, if any, policies apply to them, their luggage and any "special items" they may be traveling with.

I agree 100%. Unfortunately not everybody is willing to take the time for this, and then afterwards complain.
No excuses, everybody knows how important it is to read the conditions, doesnt matter if its a new tv, microwave or plane ticket.
 
User avatar
b727fa
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 8:21 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 2:59 pm

If you're that important of an artist and have such a valuable instrument, then I think you'd have traveled enough to know how to "know" what you're in for. If you know to buy a ticket for it, then you know how to "find" the rules.

Took me about 3 minutes to find this:
Musical instruments: Although seats may not be purchased for instruments, we will accept small instruments as part of the carry-on baggage allowance. Exceptions may be made for irregular-sized instruments. All instruments must be stowed in the overhead compartment, under the seat or in other approved locations. This is left to the discretion of the cabin crew and Customer Service Agent upon checking flight and baggage loads. Instruments may also be accepted in checked baggage when they are properly packed. Applicable excess baggage fees will apply.
http://www.westjet.com/guest/en/trav...basics/baggage/special-items.shtml

http://www.westjet.com/guest/en/travel/basics/baggage/code-share.shtml
From the AA link:
Musical Instruments
Small musical instruments may be carried onboard the aircraft providing they meet existing carry-on size requirements and fit in the overhead bin or under the seat in front of you. Case dimensions may not exceed 45 dimensional inches (width + length + height), except for guitars which may be brought on board only if they can be safely stowed in an overhead bin or approved stowage location in the cabin.

The instrument is considered the passenger's one allowed carry-on bag. A personal item is allowed in addition to the instrument.
My comments/opinions are my own and are not to be construed as the opinion(s) of my employer.
 
User avatar
Aesma
Posts: 7957
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 6:14 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 3:37 pm

He says he bought a seat for the cello, what's up with that ?
New Technology is the name we give to stuff that doesn't work yet. Douglas Adams
 
phljjs
Posts: 296
Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2005 7:26 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 3:55 pm

Quoting Aesma (Reply 6):
He says he bought a seat for the cello, what's up with that ?

I've seen people do that before, however, I don't see how it could be done online since you have to input birth dates, passport numbers, etc. I don't think you can get through the booking process without filling in all the info. He would have input fake information to get it to work.

Ticket agents at the airport and perhaps the call center can complete the booking. I've seen people carrying large musical instruments on US Airways. They had a boarding pass in the name of "A. Cello."

The part of the story where he said he bought the extra seat online made me suspicious of him and his ordeal. If Westjet or AA doesn't allow large musical instruments in the cabin, why would they let you buy a ticket for one?
 
canoecarrier
Posts: 2569
Joined: Sat Feb 14, 2004 1:20 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 4:18 pm

Quoting phljjs (Reply 7):
I've seen people do that before, however, I don't see how it could be done online since you have to input birth dates, passport numbers, etc. I don't think you can get through the booking process without filling in all the info. He would have input fake information to get it to work.

Ticket agents at the airport and perhaps the call center can complete the booking. I've seen people carrying large musical instruments on US Airways. They had a boarding pass in the name of "A. Cello."

I've seen it done two ways, either purchased as an extra seat in the passengers name. As in they bought an empty seat next to them. People without instruments do that sometimes as well. Or, as you mention they'll buy a ticket for "Cello (last name)". You can make up birth dates if you're flying domestically, the TSA isn't going to look for a drivers license for an instrument.

When I worked at the airport we had a regular that flew with his cello quite often. We even had a professional violinist purchase a seat for her violin every time she flew.

I don't have any sympathy for this guy. Cellos are not small instruments and anyone that travels with them frequently should know the rules already or at least know to look them up before you fly.
The beatings will continue until morale improves
 
strfyr51
Posts: 2173
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 5:04 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 6:14 pm

Quoting HPRamper (Reply 1):

many cellos are nearly Priceless and cannot BE replaced, My take?? INSURE THE Cello to the HILT Make prior arrangements with the airline. DO NOT accept code shares and STAY off Low Rent airlines Because any Reputable airline would allow you to buy a seat so that your Cello or Double Bass might travel Neck Down inside it's case. Ive been on flights with yo yo Ma and Ron Carter and Both of them had their instrument sitting beside them. I'm not sure what airline WOULDNT understand that.
 
ScottishDavie
Posts: 177
Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2011 10:48 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 7:07 pm

Quoting Aesma (Reply 6):
He says he bought a seat for the cello, what's up with that ?

Maybe I'm missing the point but surely the rules quoted in reply 5 are directed towards carrying musical instruments as hand baggage. That's not exactly what this guy was trying to do - he was carrying his cello as an additional fare-paying passenger, so to speak. If he has bought a seat for the cello and it fits securely into that seat where exactly is the problem apart from a lack of common sense and flexibility on the part of Westjet?
 
User avatar
b727fa
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 8:21 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 7:56 pm

I would never travel with it neck down--in ANY kind of case. Still, he should know how to fly with his cello. I live in CVG. How does our world class symphony travel all around the world with their priceless instruments in cargo?
My comments/opinions are my own and are not to be construed as the opinion(s) of my employer.
 
Viscount724
Posts: 19287
Joined: Thu Oct 12, 2006 7:32 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 8:13 pm

Quoting ScottishDavie (Reply 10):
Quoting Aesma (Reply 6):
He says he bought a seat for the cello, what's up with that ?

Maybe I'm missing the point but surely the rules quoted in reply 5 are directed towards carrying musical instruments as hand baggage. That's not exactly what this guy was trying to do - he was carrying his cello as an additional fare-paying passenger, so to speak. If he has bought a seat for the cello and it fits securely into that seat where exactly is the problem apart from a lack of common sense and flexibility on the part of Westjet?

Because WestJet makes it very clear in their rules, easily found on their website, that they DO NOT sell extra seats for musical instruments. Instruments carried on have to be "small" which certainly doesn't describe a cello.

Westjet also includes the following in the baggage section of their website, followed by links to the baggage rules of all their codeshare partners. Since this passenger was travelling on an AA ticket, not a WS ticket, perhaps AA wasn't as clear in their website. He should then be complaining to AA for selling him a ticket that couldn't be used, not WS.

Code-share baggage info

Travelling with one of our airline partners? Be sure to familiarize yourself with their baggage allowances and fees as they may be different from ours.


[Edited 2012-09-02 13:18:57]

[Edited 2012-09-02 13:19:54]
 
ScottishDavie
Posts: 177
Joined: Fri Feb 25, 2011 10:48 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 10:32 pm

Quoting Viscount724 (Reply 12):
Because WestJet makes it very clear in their rules, easily found on their website, that they DO NOT sell extra seats for musical instruments.

Exactly as I said - lack of common sense and flexibility. What does it matter to Westjet whether a seat is occupied by a human being or a musical instrument? They still get paid the same and at least the musical instrument isn't likely to get drunk, become disruptive or fail to comply with cabin crew instructions.  
 
ORDJOE
Posts: 650
Joined: Wed Aug 11, 2010 2:27 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 10:59 pm

Quoting strfyr51 (Reply 9):
any cellos are nearly Priceless and cannot BE replaced, My take?? INSURE THE Cello to the HILT Make prior arrangements with the airline. DO NOT accept code shares and STAY off Low Rent airlines Because any Reputable airline would allow you to buy a seat so that your Cello or Double Bass might travel Neck Down inside it's case. Ive been on flights with yo yo Ma and Ron Carter and Both of them had their instrument sitting beside them. I'm not sure what airline WOULDNT understand that.

Agreed, I have no sympathy for this jack ass who seems to think the airline will bend to his will due to him being a professional or having a priceless instrument (as a note I do not doubt the instrument costs a ton of money, my sister plays cello and even a crappy one will be 20K and up). When you book codeshare it always says under it "operated by XYZ" he did not due his dilligence.
He seems like one of the many who think the airline will make exceptions or try to pull the "do you know who I am." He could have booked a connecting flight on AA or whomever's metal to ensure it stayed in the passenger cabin.
 
User avatar
Goodbye
Posts: 855
Joined: Mon Jan 22, 2001 1:41 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:02 pm

To be fair, most average people when they're booking a flight on an airline's website expect to be flying with that airline. 90% of people wouldn't have a clue what a "codeshare" is nor what it means for them.

One of my friends is travelling in the US at the moment, he didn't know what airline he was flying there on (from Australia!), nor what airline he was travelling around the US on ("whatever the travel agent booked for me"), so the fact that this gentleman wasn't aware his flight was operated by WestJet isn't that hard to understand.
✈︎
 
PHX787
Posts: 7881
Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2012 7:46 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:06 pm

Quoting ScottishDavie (Reply 13):
Exactly as I said - lack of common sense and flexibility. What does it matter to Westjet whether a seat is occupied by a human being or a musical instrument? They still get paid the same and at least the musical instrument isn't likely to get drunk, become disruptive or fail to comply with cabin crew instructions.

true but can you securely use a seatbelt to strap a cello in?

When I bring my guitars on board, I usually ask the F/As to put the guitar behind the last First Class seat if there's no room in the overhead. If I'm in first class, the F/As usually put it above my seat. But then again it's a guitar, not a cello  
Follow me on twitter: www.twitter.com/phx787
 
ooslc
Posts: 89
Joined: Thu Nov 20, 2008 12:51 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:41 pm

How did he make it all the way to his seat with a huge cello without a single agent at WS seeing it!?!?! It would have been less of a blow if an agent saw it during check in. Surely two boarding passes popped out of the machine. When the agent asked him for his passport, I'm surprised he/she didn't catch that there was no passport for the cello. Seems fishy to me.
 
User avatar
nitepilot79
Posts: 790
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 9:10 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:41 pm

Quoting PHX787 (Reply 16):
true but can you securely use a seatbelt to strap a cello in?

Only if you "B#" enough. If not, then one has to "C" it to "B" leave it   
 
trex8
Posts: 4662
Joined: Sat Nov 02, 2002 9:04 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Sun Sep 02, 2012 11:57 pm

Quoting PHX787 (Reply 16):
true but can you securely use a seatbelt to strap a cello in?

Yes

My daughter is a cellist, she has a $3000 air travel case for checking it in but its so heavy if she goes somewhere where she has to carry it around a lot - say she is going to a music camp as opposed to just doing a performance, she gets another seat for it and uses a lightweight case you can carry on your back. She usually flies UA and getting a E+ bulkhead seat guarantees no problems. Its not allowed in exit rows. She has managed to fit it in a regular coach seat but it seems to vary with type of plane/seat- also sometimes it will stop the person in front from reclining completely. FAs are usually very good about accommodating her. We had one issue recently with DL, she was using grandparents freq flier miles as she was going to ATL so figured there must be so many flights and they can't all be completely full. I called DL and spent over an hour twice trying to get a bulkhead seat- they won't release till day of flight and people with medical issues get first dibs at it, they ("supervisors" ) also claimed there would be zero issues with a regular seat and it fitting and they "absolutely knew it would be fine in a regular seat" and there were specified seat locations for such instruments in the cabin but no one could tell me exactly which seat on a MD80 this was! I think they didn't know the size difference between a guitar and a cello! They were wrong about it fitting but fortunately the flight wasn't full so it manged to fit at an angle for 2 seats. Maybe when they have economy comfort on all DL flights it won't be an issue as it would be like UA E+ space wise. WN has moved people from bulkhead seats to allow her cello to get in there.

You can book another seat for an instrument on line very easily on every airline we have tried. TSA doesn't ask to see the id to certify the birth date or sex when you bring it up to them, in fact they usually don't even check its got its own boarding pass, thats only important for the gate agent, FAs. She usually books it as surname, cello instrument

Some research and preparation helps but it also helps if the airline have a clue! Some don't.

She called UA Mileage Plus once to ask if she could get an account for the cello, they said that would not be appropriate!  
 
OB1504
Posts: 3030
Joined: Tue Jul 27, 2004 5:10 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 12:05 am

Quoting HPRamper (Reply 1):
I've never even seen a booking site or engine that did not specify if the flight was a codeshare. I believe it is policy to list a flight as such.

Indeed, I believe a company would be opening itself up to fines from the DOT if it did not disclose codeshare flights.

Quoting canoecarrier (Reply 8):
I've seen it done two ways, either purchased as an extra seat in the passengers name. As in they bought an empty seat next to them.

This is how I've usually seen it done, and the customer was then issued two boarding passes for himself/herself and the instrument. I can't recall if had to go on the floor (the bottom of the case) or could be in the seat, though.
 
prosa
Posts: 5389
Joined: Sat Oct 27, 2001 3:24 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 12:08 am

If the cello is worth millions of dollars, why wasn't it shipped using an armed courier service?
"Let me think about it" = the coward's way of saying "no"
 
User avatar
nitepilot79
Posts: 790
Joined: Tue May 20, 2008 9:10 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 12:17 am

Quoting OB1504 (Reply 20):
This is how I've usually seen it done, and the customer was then issued two boarding passes for himself/herself and the instrument.

I've never felt the need to name any of my musical instruments until now!
 
Mir
Posts: 19108
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 3:55 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 2:46 am

Quoting PROSA (Reply 21):
If the cello is worth millions of dollars, why wasn't it shipped using an armed courier service?

You don't realize how much (or should I say how little) musicians make, do you? That's not going to be financially possible.

-Mir
7 billion, one nation, imagination...it's a beautiful day
 
HPRamper
Posts: 4635
Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 4:22 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 3:28 am

Quoting Mir (Reply 23):
You don't realize how much (or should I say how little) musicians make, do you? That's not going to be financially possible.

Hmm, then how could said individual have acquired a multimillion dollar instrument? Charitable gesture?
 
Mir
Posts: 19108
Joined: Mon Jan 05, 2004 3:55 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 3:39 am

Quoting HPRamper (Reply 24):
Hmm, then how could said individual have acquired a multimillion dollar instrument? Charitable gesture?

Some instruments are loaned, but most are purchased. Doesn't mean they have a lot of disposable income hanging around to spend on armed escorts for it. By your logic, anyone who owns expensive camera equipment should be very well-off, but we know that's not the case. Some people need to spend money there and cut back elsewhere - this is no different.

-Mir
7 billion, one nation, imagination...it's a beautiful day
 
User avatar
jetjack74
Posts: 6606
Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2003 6:35 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 7:00 am

Honestly, are we to believe that the world should stop for this guy, because he CHOOSES to cart around some sort of "sacred relic of string instruments" because he thinks it makes him play better? If he really cared enough about this silly thing, he would insure it everywhere he goes instead of imposing it's presence upon the traveling public. If having to check your cello is "unthinkable" as he puts it, then why would you agree to travel and not take another flight where your 2nd seat for your cello(paid at a fraction of a real seat price) is honored? This rationale bewilders me. And then he writes some silly story about having a nervous breakdown inflight, where everyone is supposed to hold your hand while you sob like a 2 year-old??? I'd crap on it if I had the opportunity. We're going to be held liable as some sort of "Americans With Musical Abilities Act" to disguise it as some kind of civil right's protection. Give me a break.

Quoting Mir (Reply 25):
Quoting HPRamper (Reply 24):
Hmm, then how could said individual have acquired a multimillion dollar instrument? Charitable gesture?

Some instruments are loaned, but most are purchased. Doesn't mean they have a lot of disposable income hanging around to spend on armed escorts for it. By your logic, anyone who owns expensive camera equipment should be very well-off, but we know that's not the case. Some people need to spend money there and cut back elsewhere - this is no different.

-Mir

By my logic, anyone who owns an expensive camera, an expensive house or expensive sports car should be able to provide for it's upkeep, storage and care. If you can't, don't buy it and let somebody who can buy it. Otherwise, it's your fault if it gets damaged.
Made from jets!
 
BN747DFWHNL
Posts: 83
Joined: Mon May 09, 2005 6:32 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 7:00 am

Few thoughts from a professional musician and plane geek:

1) WestJet's policy makes zero sense. It is common practice to allow cellists to buy a seat for their instruments when they fly. We're not talking about a floor lamp that Aunt Mathilda wants to take with her back to Poughkeepsie. We're talking about a piece of equipment, musical in nature, which is depended upon by the musician to earn a living. If that piece of equipment is damaged from being checked under the aircraft, they can't do their job. Although I don't play the cello, I would not use the special hard case that cellists can buy (at an exorbitant price) to check the instrument under the aircraft: I would always buy a seat so I knew where the instrument was at all times and how it was being treated.

2) The whole codeshare system is deceitful. "Oh, look: you can fly us all the way from Hartford, CT, to Thunderhead, BC, Canada (fictional)....well, not really, heh heh: you can fly us from Hartford to [insert connecting city of your choice] to Vancouver, BC, and then you'll fly on Flying Geese (fictional) Airlines to Thunderhead (only thing is that Flying Geese Airlines is written in small letters on your itinerary and Big Name-Recognition Airlines with a 7800 (fictional) flight number is what is listed in bigger letters, along with your other bigger-letter type for the other Big Name-Recognition AIrlines' flights)." It's just like how you go to baggage claim and see fifteen different airlines and fifteen different flight numbers listed for your one flight (Air India flies from Cleveland to Chicago....huh?). We're supposed to think, erroneously unfortunately, that everything is all streamlined and hassle-free.

3) Related to 2) above: if airlines are going to scratch each other's marketing backs and make it seem like they're one conglomerate, then they need to streamline their requisite policies into one policy so stuff like this doesn't happen. If one company decides to do something differently than the general practice of most airlines, especially airlines it codeshares with, this makes no sense and is a disservice to the customer. If the airlines are going to market their flights under the codeshare and use the bigger airline's name, then the smaller airline's policy needs to match the larger airline's policy.

4) WestJet flies the same aircraft that are flown by dozens of other airlines around the world, dozens of other airlines who understand there's a small percentage of their customers who have a very special circumstance when they fly, dozens of other airlines who understand that a purchased seat is a purchased seat, no matter whether a human butt is in it or the backside of a cello case. Heck, they should be HAPPY to have a cello "sitting" in the paid-for seat: it doesn't complain when the flight is delayed, it doesn't ask for a special meal, and, most importantly, it adds less weight to the cabin than 90% of the mass in the other seats.

[Edited 2012-09-03 00:02:56]

[Edited 2012-09-03 00:05:52]

[Edited 2012-09-03 00:12:26]
 
cheeken
Posts: 131
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:21 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 7:40 am

Quoting B727FA (Reply 11):

I would never travel with it neck down--in ANY kind of case. Still, he should know how to fly with his cello. I live in CVG. How does our world class symphony travel all around the world with their priceless instruments in cargo?

They don't. For instruments too big to be carried, they rent it at their destination, and for celli, they put them in flight cases, or most of the time they are provided with a spare seat for it. And for the rest, everything goes into the cabin!

Quoting jetjack74 (Reply 26):
By my logic, anyone who owns an expensive camera, an expensive house or expensive sports car should be able to provide for it's upkeep, storage and care. If you can't, don't buy it and let somebody who can buy it. Otherwise, it's your fault if it gets damaged.

upkeep, storage and care, in the case of a flight = bringing it into the cabin and not leaving it in cargo conditions.
 
User avatar
jetjack74
Posts: 6606
Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2003 6:35 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 7:53 am

Quoting cheeken (Reply 28):
upkeep, storage and care, in the case of a flight = bringing it into the cabin and not leaving it in cargo conditions.

How about leaving it at home and taking a less-expensive cello?

This is what I would do with it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=749iU2Zv1kw

[Edited 2012-09-03 00:58:22]
Made from jets!
 
PanHAM
Posts: 8649
Joined: Fri May 06, 2005 6:44 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 8:06 am

Quoting PROSA (Reply 21):
If the cello is worth millions of dollars, why wasn't it shipped using an armed courier service?

because you don't give it to people who might shoot holes into the Cello.

Quoting HPRamper (Reply 24):
Hmm, then how could said individual have acquired a multimillion dollar instrument? Charitable gesture?

LOL - some answers here are unbelievable


An instrument made in 1669 is priceless. Simple as that. Priceless means, you cannot buy a new one because there ain't new ones on the market. unfortunately, the manufacturer dies some time ago and the skills to make them like that are no longer available..

To make it udnerstandable for some guys here, Willie Nelson would not be Willie Nelson without Trigger. I doubt that ´Trigger ever saw the bellyhold of an aircraft.

Now, although United breaks guitars, this story show how needed legacy carriers are, who still understand particular needs of their customers. There is a mreason why some musical instruments are carried in the main cabin. has to do with culture as well.

The old culture, not the new one created by cheapos of all kinds of trades.
powered by Eierlikör
 
UALWN
Posts: 2177
Joined: Mon Jun 01, 2009 3:27 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 8:56 am

Quoting jetjack74 (Reply 26):
By my logic, anyone who owns an expensive camera, an expensive house or expensive sports car should be able to provide for it's upkeep, storage and care.
Quoting jetjack74 (Reply 29):
How about leaving it at home and taking a less-expensive cello?

Do photographers leave their top camera and lenses home and then work with worse equipment? Do they put their expensive equipment in their check-in luggage? No? Same thing here.
AT7/111/146/Avro/CRJ/CR9/EMB/ERJ/E75/F50/100/L15/DC9/D10/M8X/717/727/737/747/757/767/777/787/AB6/310/32X/330/340/380
 
keegd76
Posts: 87
Joined: Sat Aug 22, 2009 9:39 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 9:35 am

Quoting BN747DFWHNL (Reply 27):
2) The whole codeshare system is deceitful. "Oh, look: you can fly us all the way from Hartford, CT, to Thunderhead, BC, Canada (fictional)....well, not really, heh heh: you can fly us from Hartford to [insert connecting city of your choice] to Vancouver, BC, and then you'll fly on Flying Geese (fictional) Airlines to Thunderhead (only thing is that Flying Geese Airlines is written in small letters on your itinerary and Big Name-Recognition Airlines with a 7800 (fictional) flight number is what is listed in bigger letters, along with your other bigger-letter type for the other Big Name-Recognition AIrlines' flights)." It's just like how you go to baggage claim and see fifteen different airlines and fifteen different flight numbers listed for your one flight (Air India flies from Cleveland to Chicago....huh?). We're supposed to think, erroneously unfortunately, that everything is all streamlined and hassle-free.

Flying Geese Airlines - We'll get you where you need to go, provided its on our annual migration route   

Quoting PanHAM (Reply 30):

An instrument made in 1669 is priceless. Simple as that. Priceless means, you cannot buy a new one because there ain't new ones on the market. unfortunately, the manufacturer dies some time ago and the skills to make them like that are no longer available..

  

Reminds me of an incident I had a few years back on FR. We were flying to CRL and had a laptop (in a carry-all) as our carry-on item. The girl at the check-in desk wanted to put it into the hold, claiming the bag was too big. We refused. Not only was there a 50% chance the bag would be stolen (laptop carry-alls are pretty distinctive) but there was a 95% chance the laptop would end up getting smashed after having a heavier item 'deposited' on top of it.

Just out of curiosity, if the cello had been put in the hold and had been damaged or worse destroyed as a result, who would be liable for compensation, AA or WS?

[Edited 2012-09-03 03:31:39]
Nothing comes down faster than a VTOL aircraft upside down.
 
User avatar
jetjack74
Posts: 6606
Joined: Sun Jul 27, 2003 6:35 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 9:48 am

Quoting UALWN (Reply 31):
Do photographers leave their top camera and lenses home and then work with worse equipment? Do they put their expensive equipment in their check-in luggage? No? Same thing here.

Camera equipment is alot more portable than a cello or a tuba .And on that subject? Yes. I had Nat Geo videographers/photographers, journalists on my flight from SEA-NRT several years ago, and they did pack their equipment to be shipped in the belly of the plane, as it was notated in the Clearance Forms as insured cargo. So yes, some people do pack their expensive camera equipment in luggage. Nothing more than just a high-maintenence prima-madonna just begging for attention.
Made from jets!
 
PanHAM
Posts: 8649
Joined: Fri May 06, 2005 6:44 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 10:35 am

Quoting jetjack74 (Reply 33):
as it was notated in the Clearance Forms as insured cargo. So yes, some people do pack their expensive camera equipment in luggage. Nothing more than just a high-maintenence prima-madonna just begging for attention.

Camera equipment, regardless what the price is, can be replaced. If it is sinsured above the liability limit, the owner gets a full refund and can buy replacement.

The Cello is irreplacable. If someone has a similar 1669 cello he will not sell it for any price as long as he/she is performing.

What you call "a primadonna just begging for attention" is an artist whose virtuosity depends on the instrument. he would not be the same playing an off-the rack cello.

There are people who pay to listen to such artists and that is why they need to travel. It has always been common practise that artists take their instruments with them in the cabin and if it is a larger piece they buy a seat. .That has nothing to do with "attention begging" but very much withz prefssionailty.

Something certain carriers are lacking these days.
powered by Eierlikör
 
UALWN
Posts: 2177
Joined: Mon Jun 01, 2009 3:27 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 10:38 am

Quoting jetjack74 (Reply 33):
Camera equipment is alot more portable than a cello or a tuba

Hence the need for an extra seat. At the owner's expense. What's the big deal? This is how guitars, violins and such are transported. Particularly, violins or cellos from the 17th or 18th centuries! I don't understand why this is under discussion. Another issue is whether the guy should be aware of the subtleties (it's not so subtle, after all) involved in code-sharing...
AT7/111/146/Avro/CRJ/CR9/EMB/ERJ/E75/F50/100/L15/DC9/D10/M8X/717/727/737/747/757/767/777/787/AB6/310/32X/330/340/380
 
cheeken
Posts: 131
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:21 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 10:45 am

Quoting jetjack74 (Reply 33):
Nothing more than just a high-maintenence prima-madonna just begging for attention.

The difference between journalists given the privilege of having proper protection provided by the company. Musicians have these things called flight cases when travelling in groups and their group provides, but when travelling alone, it's way more convenient AND practical to just carry it on board. Who's gonna carry a flight case around?!?! Even so flight cases are not recommended for wooden instruments because they are no built to withstand cargo hold compartment environments (extremely low temperature, pressure)

However I do agree that Katz didn't do his homework by checking the airline policies. At least now he knows which airline NOT to fly, and honestly, it isn't his loss, but theirs!

Another point to note is whether he checked in at the AA counter or the Westjet counter? If he checked in at the Westjet counter, wouldn't the check in staff notified him earlier? They would have seen the cello, it's too big to be missed!
 
Fabo
Posts: 1150
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2005 1:30 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 1:25 pm

Can we now agree that it is equal part:
-WestJet fault for not telling him sooner (at checkin?) and/or for not making one time exception
-AA fault for not telling him there might be a problem flyíng the cello on WestJet
-his fault for not looking into WestJet?
The light at the end of tunnel turn out to be a lighted sing saying NO EXIT
 
FI642
Posts: 992
Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2005 9:48 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 3:36 pm

Quoting UALWN (Reply 31):

Last month I let UA take my roll aboard (which they really banged up, BTW) rather than give ip my camera.

When I worked for NW we had a musician that always purchased a seat for his cello. Same deal, it was his livelihood, and losing or damaging it would be disastrous. He also had a FQTV account for it!
737MAX, Cool Planes for the Worlds Coolest Airline.
 
User avatar
b727fa
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 8:21 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:10 pm

That's my point, they DO check items and they are just fine.
My comments/opinions are my own and are not to be construed as the opinion(s) of my employer.
 
trex8
Posts: 4662
Joined: Sat Nov 02, 2002 9:04 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:15 pm

The million $ instruments are rarely owned by the performer, unless you literally are YoYo Ma. Often large institutions own it but lend it to top performers to use.

You don't have to be making 6 figures salaries to own an expensive cello if you have been around for some years. Most cello makers/sellers will always credit you with the value of the instrument you purchased from them before if you buy another from them as it never drops in price (unless damaged). So you pay off a eg 50K instrument over x years, you trade up to a 100K but you are only paying 50K. Keep this going for a decade or two and you could have a very pricey instrument and not be making any more than you did when you started or be able to afford a mortgage for a similarly valued house.
 
AM744
Posts: 1439
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2001 11:05 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:18 pm

Quoting B727FA (Reply 5):
Took me about 3 minutes to find this:
Musical instruments: Although seats may not be purchased for instruments

Why? Is it unsafe to carry a cello in the passenger cabin?

Quoting ScottishDavie (Reply 10):
he was carrying his cello as an additional fare-paying passenger, so to speak. If he has bought a seat for the cello and it fits securely into that seat where exactly is the problem apart from a lack of common sense and flexibility on the part of Westjet?

Exactly. I'm puzzled by this.

Quoting Goodbye (Reply 15):
To be fair, most average people when they're booking a flight on an airline's website expect to be flying with that airline. 90% of people wouldn't have a clue what a "codeshare" is nor what it means for them.

         Isn't the whole point of code shares to sort of deceive the passenger into thinking he'll be flying his favorite airline all the way?
 
User avatar
b727fa
Posts: 1058
Joined: Sun Jun 12, 2011 8:21 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:29 pm

Quoting AM744 (Reply 41):
Why? Is it unsafe to carry a cello in the passenger cabin?

Don't ask me. I was quoting WestJet's rule. I see them in the cabin all the time.
My comments/opinions are my own and are not to be construed as the opinion(s) of my employer.
 
AS739BSI
Posts: 146
Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2012 11:35 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:42 pm

Quoting AM744 (Reply 41):
Why? Is it unsafe to carry a cello in the passenger cabin?

If it couldn't be secured to the seat and the aircraft hits a good chunk of turbulence and the instrument is heavy. That could be enough to injure a person would be my concern and then is the airline liable in that case for permitting the instrument in the cabin that was not secured? I am sure musicians out there could help on this one because I do not know how you would secure a cello unless the travel case has enough weight to overcome the turbulence.
 
canoecarrier
Posts: 2569
Joined: Sat Feb 14, 2004 1:20 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 5:43 pm

Quoting AM744 (Reply 41):

Why? Is it unsafe to carry a cello in the passenger cabin?

Just making an educated guess that the policy may have started with the airline asking themselves "what is the largest instrument that can be brought on and safely strapped down and stowed in an empty seat?"

As a former customer service supervisor I thought carrying musical instruments on board was one of the most abused rules. We make everyone else check a bag that isn't small enough to fit in a carry on sizer. It's not really fair to everyone else that pays a bag fee. I'd think there should be a middle ground though where you can charge a baggage fee for the guitar or other relatively large instrument like a banjo and have them put it in the overhead instead of the hold below.

But, cellos are large, people also would travel with harps and large drums. At what point is the instrument too large for the passenger cabin? We're also not talking about flimsy cases when they're checked, for the most part the ones I dealt with were sturdy hard cases with wheels.
The beatings will continue until morale improves
 
Fabo
Posts: 1150
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2005 1:30 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 6:18 pm

canoecarrier, this guy paid for the seat. Its not like he is trying to bypass bag charge. FWIW if you bought a seat for your oversized bag, I guess you could take it in cabin, if you can secure it.
The light at the end of tunnel turn out to be a lighted sing saying NO EXIT
 
fly2yyz
Posts: 648
Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2006 3:45 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 6:24 pm

Hmm, just thinking about this topic.

A cello is fairly wide, add to that its travel case and its fairly a tight squeeze into a row's window seat where it must go since I doubt it would fit into the overheard compartments. Also if I know my WS aircraft, there's no bulkhead or a separate business class where you can stow it behind a row of seats, even in the last row of economy, I believe.

Due to the priceless nature of the cello, if there was an emergency landing and god forbid an evacuation, would this not become an obstacle and maybe since the musician would not be willing to leave it behind?

WS makes it very clear on their website their rules for not allowing a seat to be purchased for musical instruments. I don't see WS making an exception for this and I don't see why Mr. Katz can't see this either. He bought a codeshare ticket. Mr Katz's comment "I hope he felt badly, that should be his natural human response." shows how spiteful he can be.

As a musician myself, yes I am aware of the consequences and which is why I travel with a padded hard carry case for my instrument, with insurance and with the sizing dimensions I'm luck. Sure its not a Tuba or a Cello, but I take the concern for it since it cost me a pretty penny -- yeah I could travel in an SQ Suite twice but I chose music. There's also an agreement between the TSA and American Federation of Musicians, the union that represents musicians that allows instruments to be passed through security screening, but this agreement does not require the airline though to let you carry your instrument onto the plane itself.

If the Captain personally took the cello, or any other friggen instrument or bag, he's taking his quite a bit of responsibility in putting it on the aircraft and making sure its taken care of when being placed in the hold. I don't know this whole story seems off to me.
 
canoecarrier
Posts: 2569
Joined: Sat Feb 14, 2004 1:20 pm

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 6:29 pm

Quoting Fabo (Reply 45):
canoecarrier, this guy paid for the seat. Its not like he is trying to bypass bag charge. FWIW if you bought a seat for your oversized bag, I guess you could take it in cabin, if you can secure it.

I think you missed my point. Whether or not you pay for an extra seat for any item, and an item can be an instrument, boat or car part, or whatever, the airline may be making a policy decision that it's too large or bulky (even though you bought a seat for it) to safely strap down in a passenger cabin. Seat belts aren't cargo straps. And, as I said, I'm just making a guess as to the policy. FWIW.

And, in 4 years working at an airport I never saw anyone pay for a bag and bring it in the cabin. Other than musical instruments.
The beatings will continue until morale improves
 
seven3seven
Posts: 272
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:55 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 6:32 pm

Funny, I linked a website last year to protest rising airline taxes but that thread was killed. The moderators said they don't allow such threads.

Apparently, the mods must be big music fans.
My views are mine alone and are not that of any of my fellow employees, officers, or directors at my company
 
User avatar
Aesma
Posts: 7957
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 6:14 am

RE: Petition To Carry Musical Instruments On Board

Mon Sep 03, 2012 8:33 pm

I still don't understand how he could buy a seat for the cello.

As an aside when I was younger and less savvy, I came back from a vacation at an aunt and she gave me a big lamp made of glass packed in a box for my mom. She didn't think it would maybe need to be checked and that I already had a checked bag and a carry-on or stuff like that, and me neither. I had chosen a flight in the middle of the day on purpose because I wanted to try a CRJ100 instead of the usual A32S. Nobody cared about the situation until I was in the plane, and when it clearly couldn't fit in the overhead bin an FA found a big empty bin of some sort at the front of the plane for it, without making a fuss. It was on Britair.
New Technology is the name we give to stuff that doesn't work yet. Douglas Adams

Popular Searches On Airliners.net

Top Photos of Last:   24 Hours  •  48 Hours  •  7 Days  •  30 Days  •  180 Days  •  365 Days  •  All Time

Military Aircraft Every type from fighters to helicopters from air forces around the globe

Classic Airliners Props and jets from the good old days

Flight Decks Views from inside the cockpit

Aircraft Cabins Passenger cabin shots showing seat arrangements as well as cargo aircraft interior

Cargo Aircraft Pictures of great freighter aircraft

Government Aircraft Aircraft flying government officials

Helicopters Our large helicopter section. Both military and civil versions

Blimps / Airships Everything from the Goodyear blimp to the Zeppelin

Night Photos Beautiful shots taken while the sun is below the horizon

Accidents Accident, incident and crash related photos

Air to Air Photos taken by airborne photographers of airborne aircraft

Special Paint Schemes Aircraft painted in beautiful and original liveries

Airport Overviews Airport overviews from the air or ground

Tails and Winglets Tail and Winglet closeups with beautiful airline logos