Posts: 4657
Joined: Thu Nov 18, 1999 12:33 am

Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Tue Sep 17, 2002 11:23 pm

Im thinking of getting checked out in either a C172 or PA28 but dont know which one to do. Does any one have any positive or negative things about either plane?
Pershoyu Spravoyu Litaki!

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Tue Sep 17, 2002 11:48 pm

If you've been flying a high-wing aircraft you might want to try a low-winged one or vice versa, just for some variety . As far a positives and negatives go - each airplane will have it's share, but it doesn't really matter. Personally, I've always felt that the Cherokee was a bit more "substancial" and the Skyhawk a bit more "kite like", but then that's just a personal opinion.

Posts: 4657
Joined: Thu Nov 18, 1999 12:33 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 1:14 am

Thanks Jetguy.
Right now I fly the 2 seat DA20-C1 Katana (low winged) which is more like a mosquito  Smile
Im kind of leaning toward the PA28, it seems like a more easier and stable plane to fly.
Pershoyu Spravoyu Litaki!
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed May 26, 1999 9:00 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 2:31 am

Ah yes, the mighty Katana! I earned my PPL in the A-1 Katana and have quite a few hours in the C-1 Katana. I then transitioned to the Piper aircraft and still instruct in Piper Warriors, Arrows and Seminoles. I also have time in Cessna's.

From the Katana, either plane will give you a very easy transistion. I don't think that you will notice much difference until you have a bunch of hours in either Piper or Cessna. If I had to choose, I'd choose Piper but that's just my own opinion.

Remember when sex was safe and flying was dangerous?
Posts: 959
Joined: Sun Jan 14, 2001 6:00 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 3:22 am

As with everything in aviation, there are tradeoffs. Neither one is better or worse than the other, and they both fly pretty much the same. The Cherokee is a little lighter than the 172 in pitch, thats really about it when it comes to flying her.

Now, other minor differances- the Skyhawk will give up about 5-7 knots to a comperable Cherokee in cruise, (no fair comparing a 172L to a Dakota 235, or even a Cherokee 180) but make up for it on the low end with about a 5-7 knot lower stall speed, and shorter takeoff and landing distances. Gross weights will be roughly the same, differances being the year; older 'hawks had a gross of 2300, when the flaps were restricted to 30 degrees the weight was increased to 2400, and another 50 lbs was added for the new R models. The only hard weights I have are for the -28 series are a Warrior 151 at 2325 and an Archer III (181) at 2500.

The flaps on a Cessna are like giant barn doors, especially older ones with 40 degrees of flap travel. Cherokees, OTOH, are much smaller. Inside, there is a little more elbow room in a Skyhawk than in the Cherokee, and the back seat is cavernous in the Skyhawk compared to a Cherokee. Entrance and exit are also easier in the Cessna, with two large doors on either side. Given that, however, passengers seem more comfortable in the low-winged airplane for some reason.

The Cherokee's also generally have longer range, due to having about 8 gallons more usable fuel, depending on the year.

In all, I liken the PA28-140/151/161 series to a small sedan, comfortable and gets the job done. The 172 is more like the SUV- it's slow, roomy, and in a pinch can get in and out of spots the Cherokee can't. The PA28-181, however is the luxury sedan. Goes fast and can carry a decent load.

Hope this helps,

Happy contrails - I support B747Skipper and Jetguy
Posts: 1409
Joined: Tue Jan 01, 2002 1:21 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 5:12 am

This depends on where you intend to go in the future regarding type/model upgrades. If the apple of your eye is to move up to a C182 or C210, stick with the Cessna airplanes. If you are going to get your multi, go with the Piper as Cessna doesn't make light twins anymore. Don't worry about any silly high wing vs. low wing nonsense; for my money, the fact that the C172 has 2 big doors would seal the deal. I found it awkward to work with only one little door and the two big openable windows in the C172 are nice in hot climates.
Posts: 980
Joined: Sat Jan 27, 2001 6:53 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 5:13 am

Got my Commercial,Instrument and CFI ratings in Cherokee's,and liked the plane very much.One negative point to mention while speaking of the PA-28 series,is the lack of a second door.The one and only door (on the 4-seaters,that is!) needs 2 locks.Not good!Flaps are manually operated.That means they can still be used if you get an electrical failure.Good!Because the Cessna 150/172/177RG's that I instructed on later,"always" developed electrical problems.
Snags were much more prevalent on the Cessna's I flew,also twins and turboprops,while the Piper's have all been very good performers in this field.Cessna workmanship always seemed very lousy to me.I'll go for a Piper anytime if I've got the choice.
Just like I'll always go for a Douglas jet before a Boeing one.
"Luck and superstition wins all the time"!
Posts: 5560
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2001 8:27 pm

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 5:27 am

Sounds like this could easily turn into a Boeing vs. Airbus war...
Last year 1,944 New Yorkers saw something and said something.
Posts: 959
Joined: Sun Jan 14, 2001 6:00 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 6:07 am


Trust me, this one has been around a LOT longer. The high-wing vs. low-wing has been debated around hangers ever since piper screwed it up and put the wing on the wrong way  Wink/being sarcastic

Happy contrails - I support B747Skipper and Jetguy
Posts: 532
Joined: Fri Oct 26, 2001 7:09 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 7:36 am

I too fly both the Katana and the Cessna 172. They are both great and fun airplanes, and both are very different. You'll find the 172 (or Piper, for that matter) to be a lot slower and a lot easier to get down on the ground. This means that your first few approaches might be a bit low. Also, I flare the Cessna much lower than I do the Katana, which seems to work. If you do the same, expect some rough arrivals the first few times until you get used to it and anticipate it. I don't know too much about the Piper, never flown one, so I won't even try to comment on it. Have fun.

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 11:02 am

Let's be highly technical here... with all my years of experience...
A C-172 high wing aircraft is most convenient in case of rain...
With a PA-28, you need to carry an umbrella as per your MEL...
... and a little humour does not hurt or kills anyone...
(s) Skipper
Posts: 3961
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2000 1:18 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 11:03 am

I teach in both the Cessna and the Archer (II and III)... I personally prefer the Archers, landings are consistently smoother, and its a more stable airplane. Also the load carry capabilities are better and the climb performance is quite better with the 180 hp engine in the Archer as compared to the 150 hp in teh 172. As far as stuffing stuff in the airplane.... the Cessna makes it easier with two doors and its defintely cooler on hot days, although there is a nice pilot side window scoop mod for the Archers that really cools off the cockpit. Regardless in a light airplane, you WILL bake on a hot day. The Archer III's come with a great air conditioning system and Garmin 430's with the STEC 55 autopilot, which is great- and also if you are going a long ways they typically will true out upwards of 115-120 knots with the wheel pants at 2500-2550 RPM. Really, though, its preference. I fly the Archers more and know them inside and out, upside and down.... so ive defintiely got some bias. Also if you ever get a chance to fly one of the new Saratoga II TC's.... they are a magic carpet ride. It takes a bit of finesse to get the landings down nice and smooth in the 'toga, but when you get it down, it is nothing but grease jobs. Plus 170 knots at 10,000 feet is nice.

Chicks dig winglets.
Posts: 5625
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2000 12:16 pm

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 3:53 pm

I learned in the 172, just got checked out in the Archer. I agree that the Piper seems more substantial, I like that it seems more comfortable and is definitely quieter. The landing experience is the big change since a proper flare in thr Archer removes the runway from your sight... disconcerting, but once you learn the technique and trust it, the landings are smoother.
...three miles from BRONS, clear for the ILS one five approach...
Posts: 223
Joined: Mon May 13, 2002 3:07 pm

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 6:22 pm

After you get your licence..........which aircraft is the most available for hire at the best rate.

No point getting the Piper 28 licence and none avaiable to rent on your airfield and visa versa, assuming ot coarse you will be renting for a while and not going out with a big cheque book.
Posts: 29881
Joined: Wed Jul 07, 1999 11:27 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Wed Sep 18, 2002 7:43 pm

Well either platform is going to be a step up from the Katana, AKA "The Flying Sperm"

Posts: 4657
Joined: Thu Nov 18, 1999 12:33 am

RE: Cessna 172 Or Piper 28?

Thu Sep 19, 2002 12:54 am

Ok im going to be checked out in the PA28 Arrow. There is an abundance of those at my airport and my college flys them.
Thanks for all the help!  Big thumbs up
Pershoyu Spravoyu Litaki!

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: flight152 and 1 guest

Popular Searches On

Top Photos of Last:   24 Hours  •  48 Hours  •  7 Days  •  30 Days  •  180 Days  •  365 Days  •  All Time

Military Aircraft Every type from fighters to helicopters from air forces around the globe

Classic Airliners Props and jets from the good old days

Flight Decks Views from inside the cockpit

Aircraft Cabins Passenger cabin shots showing seat arrangements as well as cargo aircraft interior

Cargo Aircraft Pictures of great freighter aircraft

Government Aircraft Aircraft flying government officials

Helicopters Our large helicopter section. Both military and civil versions

Blimps / Airships Everything from the Goodyear blimp to the Zeppelin

Night Photos Beautiful shots taken while the sun is below the horizon

Accidents Accident, incident and crash related photos

Air to Air Photos taken by airborne photographers of airborne aircraft

Special Paint Schemes Aircraft painted in beautiful and original liveries

Airport Overviews Airport overviews from the air or ground

Tails and Winglets Tail and Winglet closeups with beautiful airline logos