|Quoting Philhyde (Reply 12):|
Do you see the grain on the right-hand-side engine and underwin
Thanks Phil for your comments.
I see the grain now, but I had to look at it from an inch away from the screen to see it. It's an unfortunate fact of DSLR shooting that there will be noise in the shadows. I shot this at ISO 200 (the lowest on a D70), and since Neat Image is the devil around here, I really don't know what the screeners want us to do.
As for centering, if this is a reason for rejecting, that's very upsetting. The distance from the front of the fuselage to the edge is 0.142, while the distance from the back of the fuselage to the edge is 0.138, according to CS2. If I centered on the end of the horizontal stab, there would be a lot of empty blue to the right, making the whole thing feel like it was leaning left. Honestly, I think a centering rejection is somewhat tacky here.
As for quality... that could be literally anything. Do you have any thoughts on particulars?
Would you like to take a stab at it? I can send you the RAW file if you like.
I know my tone sounds awfully critical in this thread, but want you to know I really do appreciate your help.