Posts: 97
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:15 pm

Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Wed Dec 22, 2004 8:21 am

Outbound Flight

City Pair: DUB-JFK (Nonstop)
Carrier: Aer Lingus
Flight Number: EI105
Date: 17 Dec
Scheduled Dep Time: 1030, Actual 1040aprox
Scheduled Arr Time: 1300, Actual 1330aprox
Equip: Airbus A330-300 (EI-DUB)


I arrived at DUB at 0725 for a 1030 departure, I felt this would allow good time to clear security and US immigration. The queues at the area for transatlantic check-in were already quite long and only 4 agents were on duty. There were lots of families with lots of luggage ahead of me. I feel that 4 agents to check in flights to New York, Los Angeles and Boston is insufficient. It took me 25 minutes aprox to reach the top of the queue, at this stage it was running (not only through the barriers) but also at least half way down the entire length of the check-in hall. Check-in staff were acceptable. Passenger processing speeds at check in, however, were slow. It took a full 5 minutes to check in some families of 4 passengers.

Having cleared security and US immigration I waited in the departure lounge for the B gates and waited for the flight to be called. Boarding was fast and efficient and ICTS security staff were present in the jetway carrying out additional checks on some passengers.

In Fight

The cabin itself was clean and bright and the 32” pitch seems comfortable for a transatlantic flight. I am 6’1 and had no difficulties with respect to comfort during the flight. This was aided by adjustable lumbar supports. Safety demo was on video and gave all the standard procedures, it is a cartoon format which hopefully makes it slightly more attractive to PAX who do not pay attention. Entertainment on this aircraft was provided by overhead screens and two movies were shown along with other programmes. There were also a number of audio channels. Crew were professional and friendly, most were young and had a positive attitude to their work. There was a drinks service early in the flight, this was followed by lunch (chicken or beef), the chicken was good as was the starter and dessert. A scone with jam was served prior to arrival. Drinks were not available at all times between services but crew were happy to oblige requests. It should be noted that this flight was 7hrs 40mins aprox due to headwinds.


Arrival in JFK was a little behind time, luggage was off quickly and uniformed staff were available to deal with queries.

Return Flight

City Pair: JFK-DUB (Nonstop)
Carrier: Aer Lingus
Flight Number: EI108
Date: 20 Dec
Scheduled Dep Time: 2120, Actual 2110aprox
Scheduled Arr Time: 0850, Actual 0745aprox
Equip: Airbus A330-200 (EI-DAA)


Arrived about 3 hrs prior to departure again. Aer Lingus operate from terminal 4 at JFK. There were 7 desks open and Aer Lingus were operating 3 flights, 1 to Shannon and 2 to Dublin. EI108 to Dublin was their last flight of the day so I was early. Check in was a breeze and the staff were very professional and friendly, and asked me if I was happy with my seat or would I like to choose a different one. After receiving a boarding card and having bags tagged I was instructed to take them to the security area where they are taken for screening and are sent to the aircraft. JFK T4 is a very pleasant place to spend a couple of hours, its spacious and airy and there is a good choice of shops and food outlets. I cleared security about 1.5 hours prior to departure, it was quick and thorough. The departure lounge is very large and comfortable and there is a good airside view. Boarding was on-time and staff were efficient.


On entering the aircraft I noticed that there were stains on seats and tables and the standard of cleaning could only be described as moderate. Legroom at some seats was slightly impeded by IFE units positioned under the seats. Cabin crew were quite friendly and professional, the older members of the crew tended to be less helpful to passengers. In-flight entertainment was good and was provided by seatback TVs. There was a good choice of movies but they were not on demand. There was also an airshow of the aircraft progress and stats. It is important to note that this flight became extremely turbulent quite quickly and at one point the crew took their stations also. This caused disruption to the in-flight service. This consisted of drinks service, dinner and breakfast. Dinner was delayed by 1.5hrs and the choice was again chicken or beef. The chicken was poor quality and fatty. Cheescake was served with the meal for dessert and this was very pleasant. No hot beverages were served for safety reasons on account of the turbulence. Crew demonstrated a lot of helpfulness with a large number of passengers who became ill during the flight and seemed sensitive towards people. The flight was quite short due to tailwinds and was rather unpleasant due to the turbulence, it was only made more pleasant due to the good attitude of the crew.

Post Flight

Disembarkation took a long time, though this was due to passengers. Luggage took 45mins to arrive and my bag arrived 60mins after arrival of flight, this represents poor service to me.

Overall ratings out of 10:
Aircraft (cabin ambience, seating, cleanness): 8/10
Ground services: 5/10 (Check in and luggage services in DUB require major improvement)
Cabin crew (professionalism, friendliness, presentation): 8/10
In-flight catering: 5/10 (Requires improvement)
In-flight entertainment: 6/10 (All aircraft should be upgraded to have PTVs)

My overall experience with Aer Lingus is consistent with my usual opinion on the carrier, they are consistent in all areas and are not outstanding in any. That said, I have had one very poor experience with the airline on a short-haul flight. For me Aer Lingus represent good value for money and provide a reasonably good service.

Posts: 421
Joined: Wed Sep 13, 2000 12:38 am

RE: Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Wed Dec 22, 2004 9:45 am


Welcome to the forum. Great report btw. Haven't flown EI T/A for a long time, overall had nice experiences though. Thanks for posting.
Posts: 310
Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2003 9:49 pm

RE: Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Wed Dec 22, 2004 8:56 pm

Ein 145

That was a good report. If you get to it, can you tell us how full the flights were?

I did not know that you can clear US immigration in Ireland. When you arrive in the US on an Air Lingus flight, are you then "processed" just as if you flew from Detroit, or is there still Customs?

And when you flew home, you had to go through immigration in Dublin, with your European passport, right?

Good reading!
I've flown thousands of miles and I can tell you it's a lot safer than crossing the street!
Contact Air
Posts: 1143
Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2001 4:13 am

RE: Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Thu Dec 23, 2004 5:11 am

Hello EIN145,

interesting report; thanks for sharing your experiences! My only experiences with EI were on European flights; my overall impression of them was good. I agree with you that they offer good value for money.
Posts: 356
Joined: Fri Oct 12, 2001 4:42 am

RE: Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Sun Dec 26, 2004 10:29 pm

Hey matthew,
Nice report...Good luck with you know what  Wink/being sarcastic

Posts: 3893
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2003 10:24 pm

RE: Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Sun Dec 26, 2004 11:04 pm

Nice report, never known so much deatil in such a short report Big thumbs up

Sam Smile
Despite the name I am a Boeing man through and through!
Posts: 943
Joined: Mon Jun 25, 2001 7:52 am

RE: Aer Lingus --- DUB-JFK-DUB

Mon Dec 27, 2004 2:39 am

OB1783P - yes, the pre-clearance for immigration in DUB is pretty useful, makes things much quicker at the other end. I've got quite a few US immigration stamps in my passport with "DUB" shown as the port of entry!

You still clear customs as normal when you fly from Dublin, just skip the immigration line. At the entrance to the immigration section passengers from DUB are usually diverted through a separate line, bypassing the usual desks and entering the baggage hall.

As for 'immigration' at DUB, that's quite a different experience... it usually takes an average of about 3 seconds, and that's if they make you stop! A friend of mine from NYC arrived in DUB a few months ago to study for a year, she presumed that there would be a lengthy immigration process - instead they just waved her through, handing her an immigration form which she was just told to 'stick in the mail whenever you get a chance'.  Smile

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google Feedfetcher, KLASM83 and 25 guests