Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
bikerthai wrote:RJMAZ wrote:With rising inflation and sky rocketing fuel prices the average US citizen will not support a large war to protect an island that most of them couldn't find on a map.
Do not underestimate the ability for the average American to withstand hardship if they believe the cause is just.
It would be interesting to know how many Americans know how to find Taiwan vs Ukraine prior to this conflict. My bet is more American knows about Taiwan than they did Ukraine as we got lots more press of US ship transiting the Taiwan Straight and it is so easy now a days to look up these countries in Google Maps.
Also, to China opening up in 1972, all the "Made in China" products were from Taiwan. We still gets lots of products with Made in Taiwan labels. Not so much made in Ukraine.
bt
FGITD wrote:If only there was some way for those Russians to not be in that situation! Maybe something to the effect of not invading a sovereign nation without reason. Their homes aren’t being bombed; families not being killed. They could be home and life wouldn’t change at all for them. They may be young conscripts but…war is war…don’t go to war if you aren’t willing to accept the consequences.
You know who didn’t get to choose it? The millions of Ukrainian citizens who’s livelihoods have been permanently altered or destroyed because those Russians are there destroying their country.
kelval wrote:Wich video are the last few posts speaking of?
Also, I'm quite concerned about the last Biden's declarations, where he says that Putin cannot remain in power (https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/26/worl ... raine.html).
In a position where every single word has a meaning (head of state, most important country in NATO), I can't understand what he's trying to do, or what he's expecting. He knows first hand that NATO cannot launch a frontal attack on Russia, and that most Russians will never ever hear about that speech. So what's the point really?
As I said, I have the feeling that he's trying to obtain something or push something (some countries?) but I can't understand what or how exactly.
Phosphorus wrote:I'm rather suspicious of massive under-ratio of wounded on Russian side, vs. killed. Last I looked, it's like 1:1; it's not really possible. The math doesn't work out. Reports are coming that Russians are finishing off their own wounded.
journeyperson wrote:kelval wrote:Wich video are the last few posts speaking of?
Also, I'm quite concerned about the last Biden's declarations, where he says that Putin cannot remain in power (https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/26/worl ... raine.html).
In a position where every single word has a meaning (head of state, most important country in NATO), I can't understand what he's trying to do, or what he's expecting. He knows first hand that NATO cannot launch a frontal attack on Russia, and that most Russians will never ever hear about that speech. So what's the point really?
As I said, I have the feeling that he's trying to obtain something or push something (some countries?) but I can't understand what or how exactly.
Henry became incensed ............................ and is said to have uttered the fateful words “Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest!”
Four of Henry’s knights, probably not the brightest of men, took this as a summons to action, and left for Canterbury immediately.
bikerthai wrote:Phosphorus wrote:I'm rather suspicious of massive under-ratio of wounded on Russian side, vs. killed. Last I looked, it's like 1:1; it's not really possible. The math doesn't work out. Reports are coming that Russians are finishing off their own wounded.
The Russians would be most knowledgeable on the number of wounded. But they are not publishing reliable data.
Wounded prisoners are typically captured by attacking, not retreating armies.
Consider the weather condition of the recent fighting. Wounded soldiers left on the field will died more quickly with in the cold before captured.
I doubt the Russians are shooting their wounded. Intercepted communication noted that some units are retreaving their dead and carrying them along for days. So if there are any shooting of wounded, we would hear about it by now.
But you have a point. Ukraine is currently using hit and run tactics. Once the campaign to retake territory progress, we should see more reliable data on wounded prisoners.
bt
kelval wrote:As I said, I have the feeling that he's trying to obtain something or push something (some countries?) but I can't understand what or how exactly.
bikerthai wrote:Phosphorus wrote:I'm rather suspicious of massive under-ratio of wounded on Russian side, vs. killed. Last I looked, it's like 1:1; it's not really possible. The math doesn't work out. Reports are coming that Russians are finishing off their own wounded.
The Russians would be most knowledgeable on the number of wounded. But they are not publishing reliable data.
bt
petertenthije wrote:Totally unprofessional, very unwise, and totally in line with past remarks made by Joe “I’d take him behind the gym and beat the hell out of him” Biden.
keesje wrote:Agree, almost everybody thinks that you have to leave the opponent (Putin) escape routes. Not doing so isn't Bidens smartest move, US speaks people already tried to downplay it.
petertenthije wrote:Or, he just let his guard down for a second and told his private opinion instead of the carefully weighted and considered official opinion.
alberchico wrote:https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20220327-macron-warns-against-escalation-after-biden-brands-putin-butcher
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/fr ... 022-03-27/
So Macron thinks Biden went a bit too far with his rhetoric and is diplomatically saying that he should tone it down, as such rhetoric makes Putin even more unlikely to back down. I completely disagree. It was obvious since this war began that failure in Ukraine was not an option for Putin. He is going to continue to pursue this war regardless of whatever rhetoric or insults are thrown his way. It looks like the grand plan is to seize much of the coastline and take as much territory in the East as possible and create a separate autonomous region, arranged through some phony referendum.
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ro ... 022-03-27/
keesje wrote:Before you know, censorship by young motivated guys who feel they are doing the right thing takes over.
Typical for all sides. Their soldiers shouldn't think, but act, follow orders.
petertenthije wrote:kelval wrote:As I said, I have the feeling that he's trying to obtain something or push something (some countries?) but I can't understand what or how exactly.
Or, he just let his guard down for a second and told his private opinion instead of the carefully weighted and considered official opinion.
Totally unprofessional, very unwise, and totally in line with past remarks made by Joe “I’d take him behind the gym and beat the hell out of him” Biden.
Phosphorus wrote:keesje wrote:Before you know, censorship by young motivated guys who feel they are doing the right thing takes over.
Typical for all sides. Their soldiers shouldn't think, but act, follow orders.
Quote:
"Saruman:
- Do you know how the Orcs first came into being? They were elves once, taken by the dark powers, tortured and mutilated. A ruined and terrible form of life. And now... perfected. My fighting Uruk-Hai. Whom do you serve?
Lurtz:
- Saruman."
Just for reminder -- rallies against Russian involvement, under Ukrainian banner, in Donetsk were massive in early 2014. But then "russian world" arrived, with murder, torture
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Izolyatsia_prison
Almost eight years could turn almost anyone who couldn't flee into swine.
Exhibit A: Germany, 1933-1941.
bikerthai wrote:petertenthije wrote:Or, he just let his guard down for a second and told his private opinion instead of the carefully weighted and considered official opinion.
This really perplex me. Biden is old, but to me he's not senile. All those years in the Senate would school him in the deliberate use of words.
These "mis spoken" words have been happening too often to be coincidences. A disciplined staff should be able to clamp these statement down. So to me they are either purposefully leaving these "statements" in the speech or letting POTUS make them and using them for some political posturing purpose.
Probably learned that because of the prior administration, incendiary statements do not have the same impact as it would before.
Easier to "speak your mind" with or without projecting your true policy.
bt
keesje wrote:Phosphorus wrote:keesje wrote:Before you know, censorship by young motivated guys who feel they are doing the right thing takes over.
Typical for all sides. Their soldiers shouldn't think, but act, follow orders.
Quote:
"Saruman:
- Do you know how the Orcs first came into being? They were elves once, taken by the dark powers, tortured and mutilated. A ruined and terrible form of life. And now... perfected. My fighting Uruk-Hai. Whom do you serve?
Lurtz:
- Saruman."
Just for reminder -- rallies against Russian involvement, under Ukrainian banner, in Donetsk were massive in early 2014. But then "russian world" arrived, with murder, torture
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Izolyatsia_prison
Almost eight years could turn almost anyone who couldn't flee into swine.
Exhibit A: Germany, 1933-1941.
I watched the Hobit triology recently, and realized how this great movie will be looked back at 20-40 years from now, in the light of political developments, perception management and steering the masses. The basic message is to educate younger generations you really have to fight for ideals, don't ask questions and accept bloodshed because you are the right ones, saving the earth from evil, inhuman ones. Painfully not that different from the messages from the (deeply evil) Exhibit A references you mention.
I guess 40 years of reading history from many angles, watching conflicts, wars, media, politicians, talking to many people from many places is not what our warfighters did or need. POTUS Biden sure had his share/ experiences, 60 years full of drama. That's encouraging, hopefully there are enough 60+ yrs olds that looked around a bit further in Moscow too.
bikerthai wrote:Could they be part of the Chechen private army or Wagner Group? If so, I don't believe they are awarded any rights as POWs.OK, I finally saw a video of supposedly Ukrainians abusing prisoners and shooting them in the legs?
The one thing that struck me was the age of the prisoners. They have long beards and shaved heads. Doesn't look like any the typical Russian conscripts nor a professional soldiers that we saw on the "Russian soldier confession" video.
bt
keesje wrote:De-humanizing your opponents is an important preparation for war.
....
keesje wrote:IMO Merkel fully inderstood Putin & could talk sense into him, because of their shared past. Now there is distance.
Russian solider allegedly surrenders tank for $10K, Ukrainian citizenship
bikerthai wrote:How about encouraging Ukrainians in occupied areas to allow Russian soldiers to borrow phones to text home and say they are alive.
It may even kick start grass root human relationships that is key to lasting peace.
bt
LCDFlight wrote:The time will come to rout the Russians out of Donbass and Crimea, which are Ukrainian territory. Anyone who resists is a valid military target.
art wrote:LCDFlight wrote:The time will come to rout the Russians out of Donbass and Crimea, which are Ukrainian territory. Anyone who resists is a valid military target.
Am I not right in thinking that the majority in Crimea approves Russian occupation? If true, how do you want the majority to be treated?
keesje wrote:IMO Merkel fully inderstood Putin & could talk sense into him, because of their shared past. Now there is distance.
Alfons wrote:Oh, so you want to say by that, that Putin is a lion
Virtual737 wrote:art wrote:LCDFlight wrote:The time will come to rout the Russians out of Donbass and Crimea, which are Ukrainian territory. Anyone who resists is a valid military target.
Am I not right in thinking that the majority in Crimea approves Russian occupation? If true, how do you want the majority to be treated?
If they wanted to live in Russia, move to Russia. Simples.
Alfons wrote:keesje wrote:IMO Merkel fully inderstood Putin & could talk sense into him, because of their shared past. Now there is distance.
Oh, so you want to say by that, that Putin is a lion and we have to be nice with this beast of its own nature, otherwise we have to accept him to attack other sovereign countries in their own rights to exist?
By your standards, do you know how many countries on this planet would have started a war with its neighbour, just because it was not able to get what it wants on political grounds? We would have a hundred wars per year, every year.
There is nothing, absolutely nothing, which justifies a country to deny another sovereign country's right to exist, and kill its citizens. If you think otherwise, then I'm sorry for you.
bikerthai wrote:How about encouraging Ukrainians in occupied areas to allow Russian soldiers to borrow phones to text home and say they are alive.
It may even kick start grass root human relationships that is key to lasting peace.
bt
scbriml wrote:Virtual737 wrote:art wrote:
Am I not right in thinking that the majority in Crimea approves Russian occupation? If true, how do you want the majority to be treated?
If they wanted to live in Russia, move to Russia. Simples.
Sometimes, the simplest solution....
keesje wrote:IMO Merkel fully inderstood Putin & could talk sense into him, because of their shared past. Now there is distance.
art wrote:LCDFlight wrote:The time will come to rout the Russians out of Donbass and Crimea, which are Ukrainian territory. Anyone who resists is a valid military target.
Am I not right in thinking that the majority in Crimea approves Russian occupation? If true, how do you want the majority to be treated?
Dahlgardo wrote:keesje wrote:IMO Merkel fully inderstood Putin & could talk sense into him, because of their shared past. Now there is distance.
It's the other way around. Putin understood/read Merkel perfectly, and lured Germany to become dependent on Russian gas and remain naively pacifistic.
Remember how hard Germany fought for that Nord Stream 2 pipeline despite all the resistance from the US and others?
Merkel was played like a fool by Putin all along, and now we see Putins long planned endgame unfold.
Fortunately Putin is heading a corrupt military which in the end will let him down, but the war in Ukraine is a big part of Merkels legacy.
LCDFlight wrote:Dahlgardo wrote:keesje wrote:IMO Merkel fully inderstood Putin & could talk sense into him, because of their shared past. Now there is distance.
It's the other way around. Putin understood/read Merkel perfectly, and lured Germany to become dependent on Russian gas and remain naively pacifistic.
Remember how hard Germany fought for that Nord Stream 2 pipeline despite all the resistance from the US and others?
Merkel was played like a fool by Putin all along, and now we see Putins long planned endgame unfold.
Fortunately Putin is heading a corrupt military which in the end will let him down, but the war in Ukraine is a big part of Merkels legacy.
Merkel will go down in history as one of the dullest and worst major political leaders of the century.
scbriml wrote:Yes. They have to decide whether they are Ukrainians of Russian ancestry or Russians. If the latter, BYE!Virtual737 wrote:art wrote:
Am I not right in thinking that the majority in Crimea approves Russian occupation? If true, how do you want the majority to be treated?
If they wanted to live in Russia, move to Russia. Simples.
Sometimes, the simplest solution....