Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
par13del wrote:If the Ukraine military is this good and or the Russian military so poor, would I be correct in assuming that the only reason why Crimea remained in Russians hands since 2014 is because of the Ukrainians forces who are aligned with Russia?
Klaus wrote:par13del wrote:If the Ukraine military is this good and or the Russian military so poor, would I be correct in assuming that the only reason why Crimea remained in Russians hands since 2014 is because of the Ukrainians forces who are aligned with Russia?
That there have been 8 years of drawing the right conclusions from that last invasion might have more to do with it, really.
Vintage wrote:Apparently Ukrainian artillery is hitting inside Russia in the area above Kharhiv.
The FIRMS sites reports a hot spot at 50.23892 36.62459, which is about 20 miles NNE of Karhiv and one mile inside the Russian border.
There are also several other hot spots in the area above Karhiv within Ukraine.
Klaus wrote:Vintage wrote:Apparently Ukrainian artillery is hitting inside Russia in the area above Kharhiv.
The FIRMS sites reports a hot spot at 50.23892 36.62459, which is about 20 miles NNE of Karhiv and one mile inside the Russian border.
There are also several other hot spots in the area above Karhiv within Ukraine.
Do those sensors only pick up target explosions or also missile launches, for instance?
SRQLOT wrote:It seems the high russian troop deaths are not just on the success of the Ukrainians. russian commanders finish off their injured with a bullet to the head. I can’t find the original article but here is a Newsweek article. Obviously he is a prisoner of war so “could be forced to say anything” but I don’t see the Ukrainians needing to force anything out of the russian POWs. They said plenty on their own in captured phone conversations.
“ "[The Russians] don't collect their dead even. They finish off the wounded.”
“ The alleged prisoner of war said soldiers were ordered to shoot at anything that moves, including civilians, according to a Newsweek translation.
The man in the video also said he wanted to run away but there were men ready to shoot those who tried to flee.”
We knew about the dead bodies that Putin doesn’t want home and even mobile crematoriums. We saw the horrible conditions of the russian field hospitals. But to just shoot your wounded, it’s unbelievable that more russian commanders are not killed at the hands of their troops!! Wishful thinking here I guess.
https://www.newsweek.com/captured-russi ... ed-1684092
Francoflier wrote:SRQLOT wrote:It seems the high russian troop deaths are not just on the success of the Ukrainians. russian commanders finish off their injured with a bullet to the head. I can’t find the original article but here is a Newsweek article. Obviously he is a prisoner of war so “could be forced to say anything” but I don’t see the Ukrainians needing to force anything out of the russian POWs. They said plenty on their own in captured phone conversations.
“ "[The Russians] don't collect their dead even. They finish off the wounded.”
“ The alleged prisoner of war said soldiers were ordered to shoot at anything that moves, including civilians, according to a Newsweek translation.
The man in the video also said he wanted to run away but there were men ready to shoot those who tried to flee.”
We knew about the dead bodies that Putin doesn’t want home and even mobile crematoriums. We saw the horrible conditions of the russian field hospitals. But to just shoot your wounded, it’s unbelievable that more russian commanders are not killed at the hands of their troops!! Wishful thinking here I guess.
https://www.newsweek.com/captured-russi ... ed-1684092
For a nation with an already declining population, low fertility, relatively low life expectancy and an already depressing skewed age pyramid, Putin is certainly making sure that Russia's population shrinks even faster by liberally slaughtering a good chunk of the already too scarce Russian males of reproducing age...
Not that he cares, I suppose. Deluded megalomaniacs only really care about themselves and in his case, if the increasingly loud rumours are true, he may not be long for this World anyway.
Francoflier wrote:For a nation with an already declining population, low fertility, relatively low life expectancy and an already depressing skewed age pyramid, Putin is certainly making sure that Russia's population shrinks even faster by liberally slaughtering a good chunk of the already too scarce Russian males of reproducing age...
Not that he cares, I suppose. Deluded megalomaniacs only really care about themselves and in his case, if the increasingly loud rumours are true, he may not be long for this World anyway.
Klaus wrote:He does care, but mostly about the ethnically russian population. The ones sent to the meat grinder are predominantly from peripheral minority regions which is important to keep people in the big russian cities like Moscow and St. Petersburg from rising up.
flyingturtle wrote:Every video gamer knows to disperse when the fireworks hits the ground. But they are all running into the building... sheesh.
flyingturtle wrote:Yep. Young men from the Baikal Lake and other disadvantaged regions are doing the fightin' and the dyin'.
bikerthai wrote::bigthumbsup: Well it seems that at least one army in this war knows how to cross a river.
https://m.dailykos.com/stories/2022/5/1 ... not-Russia
bt
tomcat wrote:This also underlines the inability of the Russians to bomb a bridge from the air. A bridge that is so close to their border. Or maybe they don't care?
bikerthai wrote:flyingturtle wrote:Every video gamer knows to disperse when the fireworks hits the ground. But they are all running into the building... sheesh.
Wrong or right, they may have the impression that only Russian artilery hit civilian buildings.![]()
Maybe not the case here, but a good building can protect against the shock wave as well as the shrapnel.flyingturtle wrote:Yep. Young men from the Baikal Lake and other disadvantaged regions are doing the fightin' and the dyin'.
Flash back to the Vietnam War where minorities occupy a proportially higher number of front line infrantry role.
This disproportional representation still exists today in the US Army. However the motivation is different. Minorities in the US Arm Forces are not conscripted but join as a way to improve their financial prospects.
bt
MohawkWeekend wrote:Not sure that disproportional representation still exists in combat units. In 2020 here was the breakdown of US Army Infantry Unit demographics
Putin involved in war ‘at level of colonel or brigadier’, say western sources
Klaus wrote:https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/may/16/putin-involved-russia-ukraine-war-western-sourcesPutin involved in war ‘at level of colonel or brigadier’, say western sources
Translation: The situation is so bad now that only the supreme brilliance of the great dictator can surely turn it all around (at least that is apparently his own assessment).
Next phase: See Downfall.
Leading senators of both parties have struck a deal over a draft bill that would expand a 1996 war crimes law to give American courts jurisdiction
over cases involving atrocities committed abroad even if neither party is a U.S. citizen, in the latest response to Russia’s apparent targeting of civilians in Ukraine
The idea behind the draft, a copy of which was obtained by The New York Times, is that if someone who committed war crimes abroad later comes to the United States
and is discovered, that person could be prosecuted for those actions by the Justice Department. Killings of civilians and the discovery of mass graves in parts of Ukraine
that had been occupied by Russian troops have incited an international outcry..
Washington–Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) joined Senators John Cornyn (R-Texas), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), Rick Scott (R-Fla.), Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.),
Thom Tillis (R-N.C.), Angus King (I-Maine), Susan Collins (R-Maine), Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.), Gary Peters (D-Mich.), John Boozman (R-Ark.), Tim Kaine (D-Va.) and
Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.) to introduce the Ukraine Invasion War Crimes Deterrence and Accountability Act. This legislation would ensure the United States is undertaking
coordinated efforts to collect and maintain evidence of war crimes and atrocities committed during the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
“Vladimir Putin and the Russian troops under his command must be held accountable for the heinous war crimes being committed against innocent Ukrainians.
Our bill will ensure that evidence is preserved so war criminals may one day be brought to justice and these atrocities are never forgotten,” said Senator Feinstein.
Trololzilla wrote:What law is that about invading The Hague?Kind of an ironic thing to legislate when your own country literally has a law on the book that would demand an immediate invasion of The Hague (or any other court the US is not a party to) if any US official or service member were to be tried for war crimes.
ReverseFlow wrote:Trololzilla wrote:What law is that about invading The Hague?Kind of an ironic thing to legislate when your own country literally has a law on the book that would demand an immediate invasion of The Hague (or any other court the US is not a party to) if any US official or service member were to be tried for war crimes.
petertenthije wrote:Ah thanks.ReverseFlow wrote:Trololzilla wrote:What law is that about invading The Hague?Kind of an ironic thing to legislate when your own country literally has a law on the book that would demand an immediate invasion of The Hague (or any other court the US is not a party to) if any US official or service member were to be tried for war crimes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_ ... cials%20of
H.R. 4775, 116 Stat. 820, enacted August 2, 2002), known informally as The Hague Invasion Act, is a United States federal law which aims "to protect United States military personnel and other elected and appointed officials of the United States government against criminal prosecution by an international criminal court to which the United States is not party."
ReverseFlow wrote:petertenthije wrote:Ah thanks.ReverseFlow wrote:What law is that about invading The Hague?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_ ... cials%20of
H.R. 4775, 116 Stat. 820, enacted August 2, 2002), known informally as The Hague Invasion Act, is a United States federal law which aims "to protect United States military personnel and other elected and appointed officials of the United States government against criminal prosecution by an international criminal court to which the United States is not party."
So it's nickname is The Hague Invasion Act but I guess as "all means necessary and appropriate to bring about the release of any U.S. or allied personnel being detained or imprisoned by, on behalf of, or at the request of the International Criminal Court" you'd hope that they start small before working up!
flyingturtle wrote:Until then, the Joe Biden is only paying lip service when he says that "Might is not Right".
bikerthai wrote:flyingturtle wrote:Until then, the Joe Biden is only paying lip service when he says that "Might is not Right".
The US President may be the lips, but the Senate is the face as all treaties with the US must be approved by 2/3rd of the Senate, a difficult endeavor even under less divisive times
bt
GDB wrote:This excellent channel is back, tackling the stories about 'bare cupboards' and related issues, 25 mins well spent;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CmXz8Qd9yw
journeyperson wrote:I saw that. Which oligarchs and generals are going to take the fall for what all of them have been doing?For this to be broadcast there must be a shift in thinking at the top:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-61484222
johns624 wrote:Which oligarchs and generals are going to take the fall for what all of them have been doing?
Vintage wrote:johns624 wrote:Which oligarchs and generals are going to take the fall for what all of them have been doing?
Which politician or General took the fall for the Vietnam blunder?
none
Which politician or General took the fall for the Iraq blunder?
none
Jalap wrote:Can we even find any dictator that got overthrown because of a failed military operation?
flyingturtle wrote:The Republicans managed to pin the blame for the Korean war not going well on Harry Truman, thus he was defeated by Ike on 1952. This is ironic because it was the staunch Republican, Dugout Doug MacArthur that brought about the Chinese entry into that war. If we would have had a competent CG in Korea, that war probably would have been over by November 1952.Jalap wrote:Can we even find any dictator that got overthrown because of a failed military operation?
Leopoldo Galtieri springs to mind.
johns624 wrote:journeyperson wrote:I saw that. Which oligarchs and generals are going to take the fall for what all of them have been doing?For this to be broadcast there must be a shift in thinking at the top:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-61484222
flyingturtle wrote:Jalap wrote:Can we even find any dictator that got overthrown because of a failed military operation?
Leopoldo Galtieri springs to mind.
Vintage wrote:I follow the progress of the war via the Rondeli Russian Military Digest: https://gfsis.org.ge/russian-monitor/view/3225
They publish a map usually every day: https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewe ... 20235&z=13
I download their KML file for the front lines and view it in Google earth; it lets me see changes on a day to day basis.
After I started doing this, I've gone elsewhere to double check the accuracy of the information I'm using and so far the Rondeli Russian Military Digest has checked out; I've never found any discrepancies; they were about 12 hours late in seeing the Ukrainian breakthrough at Stari Saltiv, but that is no fatal error.
Today however, they are showing what has to be a major breakthrough across the Donets by Russian forces about 12 miles west of the now famous attempted river crossing at Bilohorivka. The location is near the town of Zakitne (48°52'37.65"N 38° 5'26.82"E). It shows that they must have gotten a bridge working or forded the Donets. The Rondeli front line for today shows about a four mile penetration toward the town of Siversk along highway TO513.
If this is true, this is a big deal. But nobody is writing about it.
Has anybody here heard anything about it?
A Russian soldier on trial for war crimes in Ukraine has pleaded guilty to killing an unarmed civilian.
Vadim Shishimarin is accused of gunning down an unarmed 62-year-old civilian in the days after the invasion began and faces life in prison.
Prosecutors say more trials could be forthcoming, after identifying thousands of potential crimes committed by Russian forces. Moscow has denied its troops have targeted civilians.
T4thH wrote:Russia has bombed one of the M777 howitzer units, minimum 3x M777, with loitering ammunition and MLRS. Amount of damage and losses is unknown, as the loitering attack missed as seems also the MLRS bombardment was likely....near but not fully covering. It missed the street, where they have hided in the forest by likely 100 m.
https://twitter.com/RALee85/status/1526878044505481218?%20ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1526878044505481218%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.redditmedia.com%2Fmediaembed%2Fusa4y2%3Fresponsive%3Dtrueis_nightmode%3Dfalse