Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
ArchGuy1 wrote:Monday June 6 marks the 78 year anniversary of the D Day invasion at Normandy. This led to the Allied victory in Europe a year later and was a turning point with World War 2 in Europe.
viewtopic.php?t=1310607&start=50#p18440229
Kiwirob wrote:ArchGuy1 wrote:Monday June 6 marks the 78 year anniversary of the D Day invasion at Normandy. This led to the Allied victory in Europe a year later and was a turning point with World War 2 in Europe.
viewtopic.php?t=1310607&start=50#p18440229
Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Kiwirob wrote:Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Boeing757100 wrote:Because of this, I believe DL is flying troops to Normandy this year to commemorate this anniversary.
https://news.delta.com/us-world-war-ii- ... sary-d-day
All my thanks goes to the troops who put their lives on the line everyday so that we can be safe!
GalaxyFlyer wrote:One D-Day vet near me is 101.
johns624 wrote:I was at Omaha Beach a few weeks after the 75th Anniversary. It was very moving, not just the site but how many thousands still visit it daily.
Francoflier wrote:Kiwirob wrote:ArchGuy1 wrote:Monday June 6 marks the 78 year anniversary of the D Day invasion at Normandy. This led to the Allied victory in Europe a year later and was a turning point with World War 2 in Europe.
viewtopic.php?t=1310607&start=50#p18440229
Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Given the amount of kids who came from all over the World to die in Europe to defend it against tyranny, I'd say any anniversary is an important enough one. Especially at a time when aggressive fascists regimes are once again threatening Europe and the old continent seems no closer to being able or even willing to defend freedom on its own turf than it was 80 years ago...
flyingclrs727 wrote:Francoflier wrote:Kiwirob wrote:
Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Given the amount of kids who came from all over the World to die in Europe to defend it against tyranny, I'd say any anniversary is an important enough one. Especially at a time when aggressive fascists regimes are once again threatening Europe and the old continent seems no closer to being able or even willing to defend freedom on its own turf than it was 80 years ago...
Every year the number of veterans of WWII dwindles even more. A 19 year old participating in Overlord would be 97 now. As long as there are veterans still living, there will be interest in each anniversary. I could imagine interest will still continue among the descendants too.
Kiwirob wrote:flyingclrs727 wrote:Francoflier wrote:
Given the amount of kids who came from all over the World to die in Europe to defend it against tyranny, I'd say any anniversary is an important enough one. Especially at a time when aggressive fascists regimes are once again threatening Europe and the old continent seems no closer to being able or even willing to defend freedom on its own turf than it was 80 years ago...
Every year the number of veterans of WWII dwindles even more. A 19 year old participating in Overlord would be 97 now. As long as there are veterans still living, there will be interest in each anniversary. I could imagine interest will still continue among the descendants too.
The anniversaries most people make a song and dance over are usually every 10 or 25 years.
cjg225 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Yes, for a variety of reasons. Including how few people are left alive who were there and how important that day was in world history.
Nicoeddf wrote:cjg225 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Yes, for a variety of reasons. Including how few people are left alive who were there and how important that day was in world history.
In world history D-Day is ridiculously unimportant. Actually irrelevant.
But yes, in modern history a very important day if you fancy the slaughtering of young men, sons, husbands, fathers or all nations involved.
Let’s celebrate the sacrifice, though. Shall we not? Dying for your country. What a narrative.
Nicoeddf wrote:What would be your solution to the problem of Hitler?cjg225 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:Is 78 years an important anniversary?
Yes, for a variety of reasons. Including how few people are left alive who were there and how important that day was in world history.
In world history D-Day is ridiculously unimportant. Actually irrelevant.
But yes, in modern history a very important day if you fancy the slaughtering of young men, sons, husbands, fathers or all nations involved.
Let’s celebrate the sacrifice, though. Shall we not? Dying for your country. What a narrative.
johns624 wrote:Nicoeddf wrote:What would be your solution to the problem of Hitler?cjg225 wrote:Yes, for a variety of reasons. Including how few people are left alive who were there and how important that day was in world history.
In world history D-Day is ridiculously unimportant. Actually irrelevant.
But yes, in modern history a very important day if you fancy the slaughtering of young men, sons, husbands, fathers or all nations involved.
Let’s celebrate the sacrifice, though. Shall we not? Dying for your country. What a narrative.
Nicoeddf wrote:johns624 wrote:Nicoeddf wrote:What would be your solution to the problem of Hitler?
In world history D-Day is ridiculously unimportant. Actually irrelevant.
But yes, in modern history a very important day if you fancy the slaughtering of young men, sons, husbands, fathers or all nations involved.
Let’s celebrate the sacrifice, though. Shall we not? Dying for your country. What a narrative.
Don’t change the direction of the argument, please. I don’t find the slaughtering of a 100k men of all nations in just a couple of days a reason to celebrate.
Having the Nazi regime removed is obviously worthy a great deal of celebrations. D-Day as one puzzle piece to achieve that, with brutal mowing down of men, not so much. Should be a day of quiet mourning, if anything.
Nicoeddf wrote:Nicoeddf wrote:cjg225 wrote:Yes, for a variety of reasons. Including how few people are left alive who were there and how important that day was in world history.
In world history D-Day is ridiculously unimportant. Actually irrelevant.
But yes, in modern history a very important day if you fancy the slaughtering of young men, sons, husbands, fathers or all nations involved.
Let’s celebrate the sacrifice, though. Shall we not? Dying for your country. What a narrative.
Slight disclaimer: that perspective dramatically shifts obviously if you somehow came to believe the age of the “world” is something like 2 to 4K years.
A101 wrote:That's the way that I've always looked at it. I never considered it a "celebration".Nicoeddf wrote:johns624 wrote:What would be your solution to the problem of Hitler?
Don’t change the direction of the argument, please. I don’t find the slaughtering of a 100k men of all nations in just a couple of days a reason to celebrate.
Having the Nazi regime removed is obviously worthy a great deal of celebrations. D-Day as one puzzle piece to achieve that, with brutal mowing down of men, not so much. Should be a day of quiet mourning, if anything.
Its a day of reflection for the fact that it was the start of the down fall of Nazi Germany, D-Day is immensely important to the culmination of ending tyranny on the European continent, it was a remarkable achievement against a lot of odds
cjg225 wrote:Nicoeddf wrote:Nicoeddf wrote:
In world history D-Day is ridiculously unimportant. Actually irrelevant.
But yes, in modern history a very important day if you fancy the slaughtering of young men, sons, husbands, fathers or all nations involved.
Let’s celebrate the sacrifice, though. Shall we not? Dying for your country. What a narrative.
Slight disclaimer: that perspective dramatically shifts obviously if you somehow came to believe the age of the “world” is something like 2 to 4K years.
Not quite sure I've ever seen a more amusing attempt at making a pedantic argument than this.