Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
ltbewr wrote:So he was Norwegian.The shooter was a Norwegian national originally from Iran
AirWorthy99 wrote:This is truly unfortunate. RIP to all who died.
How are the gun laws in Norway?
johns624 wrote:ltbewr wrote:So he was Norwegian.The shooter was a Norwegian national originally from Iran
SQ22 wrote:Please remember to provide a link to your source when stating facts, thanks.
Kiwirob wrote:So only "Aryans/Vikings" are 'real" Norwegians? If he has a Norwegian passport, then he's Norwegian. They should embrace their "melting pot" society, just like the US does. It doesn't matter where you come from, once you get a US passport, you're an American. Saying a person who was born somewhere else isn't the same, just sounds somewhat racist.johns624 wrote:ltbewr wrote:So he was Norwegian.The shooter was a Norwegian national originally from Iran
Not an ethnic Norwegian just a foreigner with a Norwegian passport, like I will be sometime soon.
Aesma wrote:According to Kiwirob, who lives there, it doesn't matter because even semiautos are banned.I saw of French TV they said one weapon was "automatic", was it really, or just semi-automatic (French journalists don't know the difference) ?
Aesma wrote:I saw of French TV they said one weapon was "automatic", was it really, or just semi-automatic (French journalists don't know the difference) ?
johns624 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:So only "Aryans/Vikings" are 'real" Norwegians? If he has a Norwegian passport, then he's Norwegian. They should embrace their "melting pot" society, just like the US does. It doesn't matter where you come from, once you get a US passport, you're an American. Saying a person who was born somewhere else isn't the same, just sounds somewhat racist.johns624 wrote:So he was Norwegian.
Not an ethnic Norwegian just a foreigner with a Norwegian passport, like I will be sometime soon.
Aesma wrote:The police aren't releasing that information, according to this article.I'm really asking about the weapons used, not their legality (I would be surprised if automatic weapons were legal anywhere in Europe, except Switzerland maybe ?).
johns624 wrote:[...]the man had a Norwegian passport, so he was in effect, a member of the "tribe".[...]
Kilopond wrote:Wrong. A Norwegian (or Brit, Italian, American, etc.) is someone who lives in a country and has been approved for citizenship. There is no special race called "Norwegian". If you hold a country's passport, you are no longer an alien. A person who emigrates to the US and becomes a citizen is just as much an American as I am. This is just more of that unacknowledged European racism. Not all terrorists are those "evil foreigners". You have plenty of homegrown ones...IRA, RAF, Basques, Breivik, etc. Get off your high horse.johns624 wrote:[...]the man had a Norwegian passport, so he was in effect, a member of the "tribe".[...]
Sorry to say so, I really do not want to offend you, but this is just completely weired. If I get a foreign passport I will still remain an allien. Unless I submit myself to certain masonic dogmas and suddenly consider myself some kind of [insert any sex and race and mixture of them].
On topic: that violent act was horrible. But brain-washed EVIL do-gooders will do their utmost to swamp Europe with as many potential terrosists as possible.
johns624 wrote:It was some Europeans who tried to claim that he really wasn't a Norwegian, so they could distance themselves from his act.
johns624 wrote:It was some Europeans who tried to claim that he really wasn't a Norwegian, so they could distance themselves from his act.
Kiwirob wrote:[url][/url]AirWorthy99 wrote:This is truly unfortunate. RIP to all who died.
How are the gun laws in Norway?
It’s very difficult to get a gun in Norway, that said there are a lot of guns in Norway, Norwegians are avid hunters. This gun was probably smuggled in from elsewhere.
There are two routes to gun ownership, the easiest is to belong to a gun club as a recreational shooter, you can only use it on a range, you will need to pass a test and be vetted by the police, they will also come and inspect your gun storage in your home, you can’t hunt. The next way is to belong to a hunting club, you have to hunt, they will check, same tests as the gun club route, same police inspections. You’re endorsed for a certain number of weapons, if you want more and you’re at your limit you have to sell an existing weapon, semi automatic weapons are banned.
AirWorthy99 wrote:Its seems to be close to impossible to having a gun, and obtaining an illegal one seems like a very difficult task. Nonetheless a bad guy wanted to kill others and still did it, despite the laws and the difficulty.
AirWorthy99 wrote:I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings. I just want to know exactly how is it possible that Norway can have them since I have been told this is an eminently an American phenomenon.
AirWorthy99 wrote:This Norwegian man who did this, was he poor? Does Norway offer good welfare system for its poor? does it offer free health care? does it offer free mental health care?
I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings.
AirWorthy99 wrote:
We can get out of the equation the idea that having a 2nd amendment allowed this to happen in Norway as they don't have one. And the laws are tough since this was an illegal gun, yet despite that he managed to obtain it. So basically laws couldn't avoid this, I am interested if other reasons would allow for this to happen.
FGITD wrote:yeah, and Norway's population is barely 1/70 of the US. Just think if they had the same population?AirWorthy99 wrote:
We can get out of the equation the idea that having a 2nd amendment allowed this to happen in Norway as they don't have one. And the laws are tough since this was an illegal gun, yet despite that he managed to obtain it. So basically laws couldn't avoid this, I am interested if other reasons would allow for this to happen.
You’re making a bad faith argument and you know it.
No one in favor of increased gun control has made the argument you claim. No one is out there claiming there are no shootings in other countries.
The reason that this is so noteworthy is due to the rarity of such shootings. And at that, only 2 people died. The US had literally 10x that many victims in one single elementary school last month.
Here’s some fun reading. There are individual mass shooting events in the US that lead to more deaths than Norway has total murders per year.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/670 ... -firearms/
ACDC8 wrote:AirWorthy99 wrote:Its seems to be close to impossible to having a gun, and obtaining an illegal one seems like a very difficult task. Nonetheless a bad guy wanted to kill others and still did it, despite the laws and the difficulty.
Which is why this doesn't happen on a near daily basis in Norway.AirWorthy99 wrote:I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings. I just want to know exactly how is it possible that Norway can have them since I have been told this is an eminently an American phenomenon.
The American phenomenon is that they have mass shootings on a daily basis. Has nothing to do with the poor, has nothing to do with this or that, has only to do with one thing - gun control, or in the US's case, lack there of.
johns624 wrote:FGITD wrote:yeah, and Norway's population is barely 1/70 of the US. Just think if they had the same population?AirWorthy99 wrote:
We can get out of the equation the idea that having a 2nd amendment allowed this to happen in Norway as they don't have one. And the laws are tough since this was an illegal gun, yet despite that he managed to obtain it. So basically laws couldn't avoid this, I am interested if other reasons would allow for this to happen.
You’re making a bad faith argument and you know it.
No one in favor of increased gun control has made the argument you claim. No one is out there claiming there are no shootings in other countries.
The reason that this is so noteworthy is due to the rarity of such shootings. And at that, only 2 people died. The US had literally 10x that many victims in one single elementary school last month.
Here’s some fun reading. There are individual mass shooting events in the US that lead to more deaths than Norway has total murders per year.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/670 ... -firearms/
scbriml wrote:johns624 wrote:It was some Europeans who tried to claim that he really wasn't a Norwegian, so they could distance themselves from his act.
I think you'll find it wasn't any Europeans, it was one New Zealander.
johns624 wrote:yeah, and Norway's population is barely 1/70 of the US. Just think if they had the same population?
AirWorthy99 wrote:I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings. I just want to know exactly how is it possible that Norway can have them since I have been told this is an eminently an American phenomenon.
AirWorthy99 wrote:ACDC8 wrote:AirWorthy99 wrote:Its seems to be close to impossible to having a gun, and obtaining an illegal one seems like a very difficult task. Nonetheless a bad guy wanted to kill others and still did it, despite the laws and the difficulty.
Which is why this doesn't happen on a near daily basis in Norway.AirWorthy99 wrote:I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings. I just want to know exactly how is it possible that Norway can have them since I have been told this is an eminently an American phenomenon.
The American phenomenon is that they have mass shootings on a daily basis. Has nothing to do with the poor, has nothing to do with this or that, has only to do with one thing - gun control, or in the US's case, lack there of.
Norway has a population of 5.5 Million, the US 330 Million.
And gun control couldnt avoid the tragedy of the mass shooting in Norway. So clearly, even with gun control and. Norway sits on the extreme, they couldnt stop the tragedy, dozens of people shot.
AirWorthy99 wrote:Norway sits on the extreme
AirWorthy99 wrote:they couldnt stop the tragedy, dozens of people shot..
johns624 wrote:FGITD wrote:yeah, and Norway's population is barely 1/70 of the US. Just think if they had the same population?AirWorthy99 wrote:
We can get out of the equation the idea that having a 2nd amendment allowed this to happen in Norway as they don't have one. And the laws are tough since this was an illegal gun, yet despite that he managed to obtain it. So basically laws couldn't avoid this, I am interested if other reasons would allow for this to happen.
You’re making a bad faith argument and you know it.
No one in favor of increased gun control has made the argument you claim. No one is out there claiming there are no shootings in other countries.
The reason that this is so noteworthy is due to the rarity of such shootings. And at that, only 2 people died. The US had literally 10x that many victims in one single elementary school last month.
Here’s some fun reading. There are individual mass shooting events in the US that lead to more deaths than Norway has total murders per year.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/670 ... -firearms/
Kiwirob wrote:johns624 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:So only "Aryans/Vikings" are 'real" Norwegians? If he has a Norwegian passport, then he's Norwegian. They should embrace their "melting pot" society, just like the US does. It doesn't matter where you come from, once you get a US passport, you're an American. Saying a person who was born somewhere else isn't the same, just sounds somewhat racist.
Not an ethnic Norwegian just a foreigner with a Norwegian passport, like I will be sometime soon.
Nope if you’re born in Norway you’re Norwegian, that can be anyone of any colour, but I will never consider myself a Norwegian even when I get citizenship, it’s just a passport it not who I am.
Kiwirob wrote:johns624 wrote:FGITD wrote:yeah, and Norway's population is barely 1/70 of the US. Just think if they had the same population?
You’re making a bad faith argument and you know it.
No one in favor of increased gun control has made the argument you claim. No one is out there claiming there are no shootings in other countries.
The reason that this is so noteworthy is due to the rarity of such shootings. And at that, only 2 people died. The US had literally 10x that many victims in one single elementary school last month.
Here’s some fun reading. There are individual mass shooting events in the US that lead to more deaths than Norway has total murders per year.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/670 ... -firearms/
John you’re an intelligent man, I know you understand the term per capita, even if you scaled up Norways population to the same size as the US murders per 100k would most likely remain the same.
Even when you look at countries with larger populations there are no US peer nations with anywhere near the same numbers of murders per capita as the US. The rate of murder in China is .53 which isn’t a lot higher than Norway at .47 per 100k
https://www.indexmundi.com/facts/indica ... 5/rankings
AirWorthy99 wrote:I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings. I just want to know exactly how is it possible that Norway can have them since I have been told this is an eminently an American phenomenon.
bennett123 wrote:There aren't many Irani-Americans in my area, Living in Detroit and having used to work in a gun store, the great majority of Middle Easterners buying guns in this area are of Lebanese, Iraqi Chaldean and Yemeni descent. Detroit has by far the largest ME population in the US. I don't see many accused of crimes in the local papers. Many are small business owners.Do US citizens of Iranian origin have the same right under 2A. I assume they do.
Would be interesting to see if they commit more or less acts of violence than in Norway.
Also do they have more guns per capita than other US citizens.
Last question, if I visited the US would I be allowed to Carry?.
AirWorthy99 wrote:ACDC8 wrote:AirWorthy99 wrote:Its seems to be close to impossible to having a gun, and obtaining an illegal one seems like a very difficult task. Nonetheless a bad guy wanted to kill others and still did it, despite the laws and the difficulty.
Which is why this doesn't happen on a near daily basis in Norway.AirWorthy99 wrote:I ask because that's also one of the reasons people say in the US we have mass shootings. I just want to know exactly how is it possible that Norway can have them since I have been told this is an eminently an American phenomenon.
The American phenomenon is that they have mass shootings on a daily basis. Has nothing to do with the poor, has nothing to do with this or that, has only to do with one thing - gun control, or in the US's case, lack there of.
Norway has a population of 5.5 Million, the US 330 Million.
And gun control couldnt avoid the tragedy of the mass shooting in Norway. So clearly, even with gun control and. Norway sits on the extreme, they couldnt stop the tragedy, dozens of people shot.
bennett123 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:johns624 wrote:So only "Aryans/Vikings" are 'real" Norwegians? If he has a Norwegian passport, then he's Norwegian. They should embrace their "melting pot" society, just like the US does. It doesn't matter where you come from, once you get a US passport, you're an American. Saying a person who was born somewhere else isn't the same, just sounds somewhat racist.
Nope if you’re born in Norway you’re Norwegian, that can be anyone of any colour, but I will never consider myself a Norwegian even when I get citizenship, it’s just a passport it not who I am.
So if you do not feel Norwegian why get a Norwegian passport.
Personally I am eligible for an Irish passport.
Only thing is when I visit relatives over there, I become aware that I would still be English regardless.
ltbewr wrote:Please stop with the comparisons of which country is better or worse as to gun regulations and violence and be more concerned with the motivation and effects of this apparently lone gunman attacking persons outside a well known GLTBQ bar/club.
Judging from the birth place (Iran) of the alleged shooter, he is almost certain to be of a faith that totally abhors GLTBQs so motivated to do this act and others who violently attack GLTBQ's out of their 'faith'. Now what was a place where GLTBQ's could hang out with others in relative safety found out reality it wasn't, indeed it became a target..It caused an annual Pride Parade in the city to be suspended out of fear of others motivated with hate of GLTBQ's attack during it. More police were directed to carry guns for their and the public's safety. In cities around the globe, being openly GLTBQ may mean a death sentence, a reversal of over 50 years of hard work and many fights over their human rights.GLTBQ events and likely parades this weekend will have to have a massive police presence, something due to police abuses to GLTBQ's and racist policies by police creates a conflicting situation.
AirWorthy99 wrote:Ok so, its been more than 40 posts and no one has actually asked or said, what does Norway need to do to stop or to end mass shootings such as the one that happened last Friday.
No one has suggested any changes or anything to avoid this in the future.
Based on what we know from the suspect thus far;
Does Norway need to ban religion to avoid this?
Does Norway need to ban legal immigration?
Does Norway need to send immigrants to re education centers so that they can assimilate the Norwegian culture?
Does Norway need to make tougher laws that would help avoiding illegal guns from entering their borders?
Does Norway need more funding of their police to increase surveillance of people such as the suspect?
Does Norway need to change its laws in order to incarcerate people with suspected ties to Islamic terrorists?
These are the questions we need to ask if they would help reduce or stop another mass shooting in Norway.
bennett123 wrote:Do US citizens of Iranian origin have the same right under 2A. I assume they do.
Would be interesting to see if they commit more or less acts of violence than in Norway.
Also do they have more guns per capita than other US citizens.
Last question, if I visited the US would I be allowed to Carry?.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:Except for one small exception that I won't go into here, you can't even buy a gun, let alone carry it. Like Galaxy said, you have to be either a citizen or a resident alien. It's not like Hollywood movies.bennett123 wrote:
Last question, if I visited the US would I be allowed to Carry?.
Last question, probably not in most states.
Aaron747 wrote:You forgot the "Mad Archer"
Considering globally newsworthy mass shootings in Norway have consisted of a homegrown anti-minority maniac and a possibly fundamentalist immigrant, it would seem intel is obviously the answer. No need for all the deflection.
Aaron747 wrote:AirWorthy99 wrote:Ok so, its been more than 40 posts and no one has actually asked or said, what does Norway need to do to stop or to end mass shootings such as the one that happened last Friday.
No one has suggested any changes or anything to avoid this in the future.
Based on what we know from the suspect thus far;
Does Norway need to ban religion to avoid this?
Does Norway need to ban legal immigration?
Does Norway need to send immigrants to re education centers so that they can assimilate the Norwegian culture?
Does Norway need to make tougher laws that would help avoiding illegal guns from entering their borders?
Does Norway need more funding of their police to increase surveillance of people such as the suspect?
Does Norway need to change its laws in order to incarcerate people with suspected ties to Islamic terrorists?
These are the questions we need to ask if they would help reduce or stop another mass shooting in Norway.
Considering globally newsworthy mass shootings in Norway have consisted of a homegrown anti-minority maniac and a possibly fundamentalist immigrant, it would seem intel is obviously the answer. No need for all the deflection.