Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
bennett123 wrote:Perhaps someone can confirm the situation for me.
If I fly to the US, would I be able to buy a gun in Arizona or Nevada.
I am not a US citizen and would be in the US as a tourist.
phatfarmlines wrote:Tourists are welcome to rent a gun at a gun range.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:Those aren't criminals, they're good ole boys.If you want to consort with criminals selling illegal guns, go ahead, but don’t be surprised by the outcomes.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:If you want to consort with criminals selling illegal guns, go ahead, but don’t be surprised by the outcomes.
bennett123 wrote:phatfarmlines wrote:Tourists are welcome to rent a gun at a gun range.
I keep hearing about the danger from Bears and Mountain Lions in these areas.
What other options are available?.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:No, not a citizen or legal resident alien. There are some exceptions, but you unlikely to be one.
https://www.shouselaw.com/az/defense/la ... ow-to-buy/
dmg626 wrote:Repellant spray, then make sure you can outrun the slowest person.
Kiwirob wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:No, not a citizen or legal resident alien. There are some exceptions, but you unlikely to be one.
https://www.shouselaw.com/az/defense/la ... ow-to-buy/
Or you go to a gun show and buy one.
Kiwirob wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:No, not a citizen or legal resident alien. There are some exceptions, but you unlikely to be one.
https://www.shouselaw.com/az/defense/la ... ow-to-buy/
Or you go to a gun show and buy one.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:No, not a citizen or legal resident alien. There are some exceptions, but you unlikely to be one.
https://www.shouselaw.com/az/defense/la ... ow-to-buy/
GalaxyFlyer wrote:Kiwirob wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:No, not a citizen or legal resident alien. There are some exceptions, but you unlikely to be one.
https://www.shouselaw.com/az/defense/la ... ow-to-buy/
Or you go to a gun show and buy one.
Have you tried this out in reality?
Kiwirob wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:Kiwirob wrote:
Or you go to a gun show and buy one.
Have you tried this out in reality?
I haven’t but I know someone who did, it was many years ago. My flatmate in London and his friends bought a yellow school bus and toured around the country for 6 months, they bought a couple of guns at a gun show then dumped them in a river when they were ready to leave.
Kiwirob wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:Kiwirob wrote:
Or you go to a gun show and buy one.
Have you tried this out in reality?
I haven’t but I know someone who did, it was many years ago. My flatmate in London and his friends bought a yellow school bus and toured around the country for 6 months, they bought a couple of guns at a gun show then dumped them in a river when they were ready to leave.
bpatus297 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:
Have you tried this out in reality?
I haven’t but I know someone who did, it was many years ago. My flatmate in London and his friends bought a yellow school bus and toured around the country for 6 months, they bought a couple of guns at a gun show then dumped them in a river when they were ready to leave.
The idea of touring the US in an old school bus sounds pretty fun, but you realize that your flatmates blatantly violated US law, right? Just because they did it, doesn't make it legal, and passing additional laws to limit legal gun owners wont stop criminals, as your example shows. Every gun show I have attended, the dealers do all the required and correct paperwork. On top of that, the ATF and various other law enforcement agencies like to do undercover sting operations at gun shows to curtail the less than honest dealers.
Kiwirob wrote:bpatus297 wrote:Kiwirob wrote:
I haven’t but I know someone who did, it was many years ago. My flatmate in London and his friends bought a yellow school bus and toured around the country for 6 months, they bought a couple of guns at a gun show then dumped them in a river when they were ready to leave.
The idea of touring the US in an old school bus sounds pretty fun, but you realize that your flatmates blatantly violated US law, right? Just because they did it, doesn't make it legal, and passing additional laws to limit legal gun owners wont stop criminals, as your example shows. Every gun show I have attended, the dealers do all the required and correct paperwork. On top of that, the ATF and various other law enforcement agencies like to do undercover sting operations at gun shows to curtail the less than honest dealers.
This was 30 years ago.
bennett123 wrote:Visiting rather than camping, (in at Phoenix and out from Las Vegas)
Keep hearing that these animals are a problem once you leave the city limits, so thought best to check.
Promise not to cuddle Yogi.
scbriml wrote:bennett123 wrote:Perhaps someone can confirm the situation for me.
If I fly to the US, would I be able to buy a gun in Arizona or Nevada.
I am not a US citizen and would be in the US as a tourist.
By all accounts, it’s ludicrously easy to purchase guns illegally, so there’s always that.
Phosphorus wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:No, not a citizen or legal resident alien. There are some exceptions, but you unlikely to be one.
https://www.shouselaw.com/az/defense/la ... ow-to-buy/
Ownership of a hunting permit counts, according to this document. (for a foreigner, that is) (Paragraph 18.4)
In Montana, annual hunting permit for an out of state person is like 15$ (in-state10$), available over the counter at most sporting goods stores. Maybe even local supermarkets, my memory is fuzzy on that one.
(No idea if this works in Arizona; hopefully it's not radically different).
Would that count as a valid hunting permit for the purposes of 18.4 above?
bluecrew wrote:scbriml wrote:bennett123 wrote:Perhaps someone can confirm the situation for me.
If I fly to the US, would I be able to buy a gun in Arizona or Nevada.
I am not a US citizen and would be in the US as a tourist.
By all accounts, it’s ludicrously easy to purchase guns illegally, so there’s always that.
And you can probably check it in your luggage going home without a problem. I doubt they check registration info.
It's super fun having regulations on par with a failed state.
(I'm not a psycho that participates in Bring Your Gun to Work Day, so I have no idea how guns and travel actually work)
bennett123 wrote:phatfarmlines wrote:Tourists are welcome to rent a gun at a gun range.
I keep hearing about the danger from Bears and Mountain Lions in these areas.
What other options are available?.
Flanker7 wrote:How about bear spray?bennett123 wrote:phatfarmlines wrote:Tourists are welcome to rent a gun at a gun range.
I keep hearing about the danger from Bears and Mountain Lions in these areas.
What other options are available?.
Crossbow
bennett123 wrote:Probably the best option.
JJJ wrote:I am European living in Europe and hunted in several states (Montana, Alaska, Washington...) I carried my own guns but the local guides told us about foreigners that preferred to buy locally and then sell the gun back to the guides or to a range.
It was essentially a cheap rental. Buying certain guns/calibers is terribly expensive in some places.
Airstud wrote:JJJ wrote:I am European living in Europe and hunted in several states (Montana, Alaska, Washington...) I carried my own guns but the local guides told us about foreigners that preferred to buy locally and then sell the gun back to the guides or to a range.
It was essentially a cheap rental. Buying certain guns/calibers is terribly expensive in some places.
There is no such thing as Montana.
johns624 wrote:While it is possible to obtain a gun with a hunting license, that's not what the law intended. It's so people from a restricted firearms ownership country can come here to hunt and buy a gun to do it with. Most gun dealers won't sell you one because it's too much of a PITA.
Phosphorus wrote:johns624 wrote:While it is possible to obtain a gun with a hunting license, that's not what the law intended. It's so people from a restricted firearms ownership country can come here to hunt and buy a gun to do it with. Most gun dealers won't sell you one because it's too much of a PITA.
Isn't this exactly the scenario we are discussing?
A foreigner comes to the USA from a country, where gun laws are more restrictive than USA (if I would guess that's pretty much the rest of the world, would I be wrong?).
A foreigner wants to hunt, goes buys a hunting permit for a nominal fee.
A foreigner uses said hunting permit as a legal avenue to acquire firearms.
Anything wrong with this?
LabQuest wrote:Phosphorus wrote:johns624 wrote:While it is possible to obtain a gun with a hunting license, that's not what the law intended. It's so people from a restricted firearms ownership country can come here to hunt and buy a gun to do it with. Most gun dealers won't sell you one because it's too much of a PITA.
Isn't this exactly the scenario we are discussing?
A foreigner comes to the USA from a country, where gun laws are more restrictive than USA (if I would guess that's pretty much the rest of the world, would I be wrong?).
A foreigner wants to hunt, goes buys a hunting permit for a nominal fee.
A foreigner uses said hunting permit as a legal avenue to acquire firearms.
Anything wrong with this?
Nothing wrong with it here in the USA. I welcome the additional tax revenue. What to do about taking the firearm home with you is the issue.
LabQuest wrote:Phosphorus wrote:johns624 wrote:While it is possible to obtain a gun with a hunting license, that's not what the law intended. It's so people from a restricted firearms ownership country can come here to hunt and buy a gun to do it with. Most gun dealers won't sell you one because it's too much of a PITA.
Isn't this exactly the scenario we are discussing?
A foreigner comes to the USA from a country, where gun laws are more restrictive than USA (if I would guess that's pretty much the rest of the world, would I be wrong?).
A foreigner wants to hunt, goes buys a hunting permit for a nominal fee.
A foreigner uses said hunting permit as a legal avenue to acquire firearms.
Anything wrong with this?
Nothing wrong with it here in the USA. I welcome the additional tax revenue. What to do about taking the firearm home with you is the issue.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:If the pawn shop sells guns; they are an FFL and have to process the 4473; do the NICS check; etc. Nothing like your idea.
Second, countries where people are wealthy enough to travel to America to hunt in nearly all cases have provisions for sporting arms ownership, certainly EU countries do. Countries with the greatest restrictions allow for those privileged residents with that kind of wealth to own hunting arms by dint of corruption. There are hunters world-wide.
seb146 wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:If the pawn shop sells guns; they are an FFL and have to process the 4473; do the NICS check; etc. Nothing like your idea.
Second, countries where people are wealthy enough to travel to America to hunt in nearly all cases have provisions for sporting arms ownership, certainly EU countries do. Countries with the greatest restrictions allow for those privileged residents with that kind of wealth to own hunting arms by dint of corruption. There are hunters world-wide.
And private sales?
https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/ ... ately.html
Read the second sentence.
When any gun proposals come up, the same chorus screams about how guns are illegal in socialist places like Europe, but you just said they have guns in Europe. We will remember this.
Phosphorus wrote:The OP never mentions going hunting. In most states, hunting for certain game by non-residents requires a guide.johns624 wrote:While it is possible to obtain a gun with a hunting license, that's not what the law intended. It's so people from a restricted firearms ownership country can come here to hunt and buy a gun to do it with. Most gun dealers won't sell you one because it's too much of a PITA.
Isn't this exactly the scenario we are discussing?
A foreigner comes to the USA from a country, where gun laws are more restrictive than USA (if I would guess that's pretty much the rest of the world, would I be wrong?).
A foreigner wants to hunt, goes buys a hunting permit for a nominal fee.
A foreigner uses said hunting permit as a legal avenue to acquire firearms.
Anything wrong with this?
bennett123 wrote:The problem with privileges is that the "privileged" normally have more of them.seb146 wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:If the pawn shop sells guns; they are an FFL and have to process the 4473; do the NICS check; etc. Nothing like your idea.
Second, countries where people are wealthy enough to travel to America to hunt in nearly all cases have provisions for sporting arms ownership, certainly EU countries do. Countries with the greatest restrictions allow for those privileged residents with that kind of wealth to own hunting arms by dint of corruption. There are hunters world-wide.
And private sales?
https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/ ... ately.html
Read the second sentence.
When any gun proposals come up, the same chorus screams about how guns are illegal in socialist places like Europe, but you just said they have guns in Europe. We will remember this.
In the UK it is a privilege you apply for, not a constitutional right.
johns624 wrote:bennett123 wrote:The problem with privileges is that the "privileged" normally have more of them.seb146 wrote:
And private sales?
https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/ ... ately.html
Read the second sentence.
When any gun proposals come up, the same chorus screams about how guns are illegal in socialist places like Europe, but you just said they have guns in Europe. We will remember this.
In the UK it is a privilege you apply for, not a constitutional right.
bennett123 wrote:I know what you meant. My point was that the rich and famous are more privileged. It's almost impossible to get a carry permit in California. Yet, many famous people in Hollywood and even antigun Diane Feinstein have them.johns624 wrote:bennett123 wrote:The problem with privileges is that the "privileged" normally have more of them.
In the UK it is a privilege you apply for, not a constitutional right.
I was explaining the difference in approach between UK and US.
In the US, the default position is that you are entitled to have a gun.
In the UK, the default is why do you need a gun.
seb146 wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:If the pawn shop sells guns; they are an FFL and have to process the 4473; do the NICS check; etc. Nothing like your idea.
Second, countries where people are wealthy enough to travel to America to hunt in nearly all cases have provisions for sporting arms ownership, certainly EU countries do. Countries with the greatest restrictions allow for those privileged residents with that kind of wealth to own hunting arms by dint of corruption. There are hunters world-wide.
And private sales?
https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/ ... ately.html
Read the second sentence.
When any gun proposals come up, the same chorus screams about how guns are illegal in socialist places like Europe, but you just said they have guns in Europe. We will remember this.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:If the pawn shop sells guns; they are an FFL and have to process the 4473; do the NICS check; etc. Nothing like your idea.
Second, countries where people are wealthy enough to travel to America to hunt in nearly all cases have provisions for sporting arms ownership, certainly EU countries do. Countries with the greatest restrictions allow for those privileged residents with that kind of wealth to own hunting arms by dint of corruption. There are hunters world-wide.
GalaxyFlyer wrote:seb146 wrote:GalaxyFlyer wrote:If the pawn shop sells guns; they are an FFL and have to process the 4473; do the NICS check; etc. Nothing like your idea.
Second, countries where people are wealthy enough to travel to America to hunt in nearly all cases have provisions for sporting arms ownership, certainly EU countries do. Countries with the greatest restrictions allow for those privileged residents with that kind of wealth to own hunting arms by dint of corruption. There are hunters world-wide.
And private sales?
https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/ ... ately.html
Read the second sentence.
When any gun proposals come up, the same chorus screams about how guns are illegal in socialist places like Europe, but you just said they have guns in Europe. We will remember this.
Did I mention private sales anywhere? Are there private sellers? Yes. Are there many at “gun shows”? No. Most shows vet their sellers, so FFLs are predominant.
Second, I’ve never screamed “guns are illegal in socialist places”; stop rewriting history. I have stated that guns are rare and subject to greater regulation in many, most, countries. Yes, much of Europe has an active hunting tradition, but it’s very divorced from the American scene. I’ve carried guns on-board planes in Europe and Africa. I have many friends who brought guns to Europe for hunting and competitions. France is quite simple; the UK looks at long guns has a revenue making charging an obscene £125 in AND out for the police inspection.