Moderators: jsumali2, richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
G500Captain wrote:I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
G500Captain wrote:There will hopefully be many lessons learned from this. But the industry and public will move on. Soon enough, Boeing will be back to full production and MAX’s will be flying the friendly skies again.
I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
BigPlaneGuy13 wrote:G500Captain wrote:I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
So do you think it would be wise for AS to purchase more MAX for their fleet strategy given the current environment?
ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
BigPlaneGuy13 wrote:G500Captain wrote:I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
So do you think it would be wise for AS to purchase more MAX for their fleet strategy given the current environment?
ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
BigPlaneGuy13 wrote:G500Captain wrote:I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
So do you think it would be wise for AS to purchase more MAX for their fleet strategy given the current environment?
nine4nine wrote:ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
Huge difference between the 787 program and the MAX. While there were those battery over heating issues and a small fire on one 787, there were no fatal crashes involved. So I think it will be a very long time before anyone forgets this issue as pertains the MAX.
ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
BoeingGuy wrote:[...]The Electra was grounded after two fatal crashes. The design issue was fixed and the airplane enjoyed a long career as an excellent airplane.
BoeingGuy wrote:G500Captain wrote:There will hopefully be many lessons learned from this. But the industry and public will move on. Soon enough, Boeing will be back to full production and MAX’s will be flying the friendly skies again.
I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
Well stated. The lives lost are distressing but lessons are being learned.
The Electra was grounded after two fatal crashes. The design issue was fixed and the airplane enjoyed a long career as an excellent airplane.
Kilopond wrote:BoeingGuy wrote:[...]The Electra was grounded after two fatal crashes. The design issue was fixed and the airplane enjoyed a long career as an excellent airplane.
Right, but you forgot to mention one important fact: after those horrofic crashes with Electras dropping off their wings mid-air, orders had been cancelled. This way the mended Electra had been a technical succsess but a total comercial disaster. Almost like the Comet. Public fear and scare killed those projects, as they also severely hurt the DC-10/MD-11.
MAH4546 wrote:ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
No comparison. The Max has a huge design flaw that literally causes the plane to crash.
nine4nine wrote:ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
Huge difference between the 787 program and the MAX. While there were those battery over heating issues and a small fire on one 787, there were no fatal crashes involved. So I think it will be a very long time before anyone forgets this issue as pertains the MAX.
nine4nine wrote:ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
Huge difference between the 787 program and the MAX. While there were those battery over heating issues and a small fire on one 787, there were no fatal crashes involved. So I think it will be a very long time before anyone forgets this issue as pertains the MAX.
BigPlaneGuy13 wrote:For a major portion of its history, Alaska's mainline fleet has been "Proudly All Boeing."
smartplane wrote:nine4nine wrote:ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
Huge difference between the 787 program and the MAX. While there were those battery over heating issues and a small fire on one 787, there were no fatal crashes involved. So I think it will be a very long time before anyone forgets this issue as pertains the MAX.
The MAX will soon feature on a Mayday episode (perhaps two), repeated for years. Standby for series ownership to change hands, and production to cease before that happens.
BigPlaneGuy13 wrote:G500Captain wrote:I said from the get go that all this was was a time to watch for dips in Boeings stock price and buy.
So do you think it would be wise for AS to purchase more MAX for their fleet strategy given the current environment?
gmcc wrote:AS also has an order for 30 A320NEO that are scheduled to start delivery in 2020. While these were originally ordered by VX and AS is expected to cancel them, if the MAX problems continue more A320s could be in AS future.
Airlinerdude wrote:gmcc wrote:AS also has an order for 30 A320NEO that are scheduled to start delivery in 2020. While these were originally ordered by VX and AS is expected to cancel them, if the MAX problems continue more A320s could be in AS future.
When does this decision have to be made? We're already through Q1 2019, I would have thought that deposits would soon be due if they intend on following through with this order.
MAH4546 wrote:ikolkyo wrote:I don’t even think their first MAX has rolled out of the FAL yet. You realize there are plenty of other airlines that are also in this situation. When the 787 was grounded 5 years ago, you didn’t see airlines go out and start buying A330s and A350s. Once is the aircraft is back in the air people are going to forget the aircraft was ever in this situation. I bet many often forget about the 787.
No comparison. The Max has a huge design flaw that literally causes the plane to crash.
smartplane wrote:The MAX will soon feature on a Mayday episode (perhaps two), repeated for years. Standby for series ownership to change hands, and production to cease before that happens.
NWADTWE16 wrote:People are not going to forget this so easily. This represents everything horrible about the state of our country. Profit over safety, Corporate greed , and Boeing now twice in the past year has been shown to be in bed with high levels of government. People who are unaware will be on the max and likely be the next casualties, sadly.
So many people have been made aware of this and how bad the entire scenario looks that companies with thousands of travelers on the road daily are banning the max from even being an option. Airlines would be insane to stay one fleet type, and make the majority of that fleet this horrible plane.
wedgetail737 wrote:NWADTWE16 wrote:People are not going to forget this so easily. This represents everything horrible about the state of our country. Profit over safety, Corporate greed , and Boeing now twice in the past year has been shown to be in bed with high levels of government. People who are unaware will be on the max and likely be the next casualties, sadly.
So many people have been made aware of this and how bad the entire scenario looks that companies with thousands of travelers on the road daily are banning the max from even being an option. Airlines would be insane to stay one fleet type, and make the majority of that fleet this horrible plane.
MAX will continue on. What exactly makes the 737 MAX so bad in your opinion?
NWADTWE16 wrote:People are not going to forget this so easily. This represents everything horrible about the state of our country. Profit over safety, Corporate greed , and Boeing now twice in the past year has been shown to be in bed with high levels of government. People who are unaware will be on the max and likely be the next casualties, sadly.
So many people have been made aware of this and how bad the entire scenario looks that companies with thousands of travelers on the road daily are banning the max from even being an option. Airlines would be insane to stay one fleet type, and make the majority of that fleet this horrible plane.
zkojq wrote:wedgetail737 wrote:NWADTWE16 wrote:People are not going to forget this so easily. This represents everything horrible about the state of our country. Profit over safety, Corporate greed , and Boeing now twice in the past year has been shown to be in bed with high levels of government. People who are unaware will be on the max and likely be the next casualties, sadly.
So many people have been made aware of this and how bad the entire scenario looks that companies with thousands of travelers on the road daily are banning the max from even being an option. Airlines would be insane to stay one fleet type, and make the majority of that fleet this horrible plane.
MAX will continue on. What exactly makes the 737 MAX so bad in your opinion?
Oh I don't know, the 350 dead bodies that Boeing's incompetence has resulted in?
People can wish this will go away quickly, but the reality is that investigations into the FAA, the MAX's certification, Boeing's engineering of MCAS as well as the crashes themselves are going to drag on for years.
wedgetail737 wrote:zkojq wrote:wedgetail737 wrote:
MAX will continue on. What exactly makes the 737 MAX so bad in your opinion?
Oh I don't know, the 350 dead bodies that Boeing's incompetence has resulted in?
People can wish this will go away quickly, but the reality is that investigations into the FAA, the MAX's certification, Boeing's engineering of MCAS as well as the crashes themselves are going to drag on for years.
You don't think there probably other factors that lead up to the crashes. The Indonesians didn't ground the airplane when Lion Air MAX behaved the same way in previous flights before that airplane went down. Or when the Ethiopian investigators found that the AOA sensor was damaged on takeoff before that MAX crashed? Boeing will fix the problem and I agree it will sting Boeing for a long time.
But I think it's more like you all Boeing haters that want Boeing to die here. If you don't like the MAX then don't fly on it...pretty simple. But the MAX will continue whether you like it or not.
PlanesNTrains wrote:wedgetail737 wrote:zkojq wrote:
Oh I don't know, the 350 dead bodies that Boeing's incompetence has resulted in?
People can wish this will go away quickly, but the reality is that investigations into the FAA, the MAX's certification, Boeing's engineering of MCAS as well as the crashes themselves are going to drag on for years.
You don't think there probably other factors that lead up to the crashes. The Indonesians didn't ground the airplane when Lion Air MAX behaved the same way in previous flights before that airplane went down. Or when the Ethiopian investigators found that the AOA sensor was damaged on takeoff before that MAX crashed? Boeing will fix the problem and I agree it will sting Boeing for a long time.
But I think it's more like you all Boeing haters that want Boeing to die here. If you don't like the MAX then don't fly on it...pretty simple. But the MAX will continue whether you like it or not.
I do think there’s a middle ground here. The MAX itself will go on to have a successful, if tragically tarnished, career. That doesn’t absolve some of the things that Boeing may have done both during certification as well as after the Lion Air crash which created and perpetuated a bad system implementation and communication. I look forward to a full investigation into the decisions that were made and how they were communicated, but that is separate from the MAX issues being fixed and the aircraft being an exceptional performer for the carriers that have and will order it.
zkojq wrote:
People can wish this will go away quickly, but the reality is that investigations into the FAA, the MAX's certification, Boeing's engineering of MCAS as well as the crashes themselves are going to drag on for years.
Channex757 wrote:zkojq wrote:
The media will be salivating at doing hatchet pieces asking if the MAX is being rushed back into service on the backs of those dead people.
Gr8Circle wrote:Channex757 wrote:zkojq wrote:
The media will be salivating at doing hatchet pieces asking if the MAX is being rushed back into service on the backs of those dead people.
….until the next big story comes along.....then the media will also move on......and how long will it take for the next story to come along....?
trnswrld wrote:I disagree with you guys that say people won’t forget the Max and the crashes and how it will have a significant impact for a long time. Honestly, the ONLY place I even see anything about the Max anymore still is here on a.net. The plane is still grounded and based on my everyday life that news event has already come and gone. That is not to take away anything from the people that lost their lives and the families involved as it is so terrible, but I feel like it will have little to no impact on things once the plane is fixed and back flying.
NWADTWE16 wrote:People are not going to forget this so easily. This represents everything horrible about the state of our country. Profit over safety, Corporate greed , and Boeing now twice in the past year has been shown to be in bed with high levels of government. People who are unaware will be on the max and likely be the next casualties, sadly.
So many people have been made aware of this and how bad the entire scenario looks that companies with thousands of travelers on the road daily are banning the max from even being an option. Airlines would be insane to stay one fleet type, and make the majority of that fleet this horrible plane.