Yes, it is, but you previously said that 2 hours is a requirement. In any event, it doesn't change the scenario I gave you where there are creeping ATC delays that put you over the limit. Like I said, you could have been only 2:10 late, but now you'll be 3 or 4. Be careful for you ask for as you may surely receive it.
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): That would by the way be my defense in any criminal case. Interfering with a flight crew might be a crime but so is false imprisonment. |
I'm not a lawyer, but I think the prosecution would have a much easier case to make than someone making a false imprisonment claim case.
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): Maybe I'm not reading your response correctly |
You're reading it correctly alright...
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): but it seems your points are all geared to the benefit of the airline. |
...but it's not because I'm airline-employed--it's because most of the general public has no idea whatsoever what goes on behind the scenes on the operational side of an airline. As a 27-year dispatcher, I deal with his kind of stuff every day, and the realities I see are different than those outside the industry can comprehend. Do people ever misunderstand things related to whatever industry you happen to be in?
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): What about the people who are being held captive? |
You think the airline
likes to have them couped up on the aircraft? I know it's no fun, speaking from personal experience, on my own airline, and others. That said, I also know that in most cases, it's
unavoidable, and the lesser of multiple evils. What about the people who are "held captive" in a long dead-stop traffic jam caused by a wreck up miles ahead? Is it reasonable to expect the highway department to come out and bulldoze/pave new lanes so you don't have to wait for hours? The more
realistic and
pragmatic view would be that the freeway runs just fine most of the time, has traffic slowdowns or brief stops during peak
AM/PM periods, and will occasionally be a complete parking lot if something really out of the ordinary occurs. Who should the delayed motorists charge with false imprisonment? The driver(s) the accident vehicle(s)? The highway department? My position isn't an arbitrary pro-airline stance, it's basic common sense.
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): Perhaps airports that have schedules so tightly packed should be required to keep equipment on site to offload passengers when the plane is away from the gate. |
Yes, there such things as external stairs. They're also made out of metal, and when you throw in freezing precip that's falling, plus that precip on an oily ramp and toss in some glycol-based de-icing fluid here and there, it's an environment that's conducive to unexpected falls and resultant lawsuits. Covered stairs and buses? They're possible, sure, but it goes back to the
PHX/
LAS snowplow analogy--can any airport operating entity justify the expense of a fleet of stairs/buses sufficient to handle multiple extra aircraft? Try running that past City Hall.
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): Of course a passenger could fake chest pains. Wonder how fast they find a way to get people off the plane. |
It's been tried before, and once in awhile it even works, but the paramedics usually see through the ruse. They have a tendency to get rather testy about being called out on false alarms, especially when they were anything but accidental.
Quoting Indy (Reply 80): Just remember this is the airline's and airport's problem. Not the passenger's problem. You can't forcibly hold someone. I'd like to see a court ruling involving a case where a passenger has demanded to be removed after being held in a jet beyond a reasonable period of time. At some point holding a person against their will should be a crime. |
It is the passenger's problem, in the sense that it's a deregulated industry, and that expenses have to be justified. If a 100-gate airport wants to go out and spend a few zillion for enough stairs/buses to replicate 40 or 50 extra gates "just in case", that's great, but those costs will be passed on, and they'll eventually be reflected in increased ticket prices, and people will then complain about
that. (I figured 40-50 buses, since anything less at a 100-gate airport might result in a planeload of folks having to (gasp!)
wait for an available set of stairs and bus.) Once all these extra planeloads of folks are inside the terminal, I suppose we'll then hear how crowded it is...)
ALL views, opinions expressed are mine ONLY and are NOT representative of those shared by Southwest Airlines Co.