Moderators: jsumali2, richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 2): It is interesting that two reviews by "peers" were found in favor of Skywest additionally Capt Don took the case to OSHA and lost |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 2): Writing profantities on company equipment would seem a good way to get terminated. |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 6): A very experienced pilot flew a difficult flight and then was instructed to repeat the trip 5 hours later... at 4:40am? In bad weather? Without prior notification? |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 6): I'd much rather have him as my pilot... someone who stands up for safety... than someone who bows into pressure from the company and ends up hitting the side of a mountain at 5am in a snowstorm. |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 6): Do you want to fly on an airline that fires its employees for making safety related decisions? |
Quoting Goldenshield (Reply 7): You mean like, landing a 737 at minimums on a short runway during a blizzard? |
Quoting Goldenshield (Reply 7): He was asked to try again when the weather would be expected to get better, and he was notified when he got back from his first attempt at JAC. They didn't wait until 0400 to tell him fly it. |
Quoting Goldenshield (Reply 7): Sounds to me like he was a stand-up crew. Rest wasn't an issue here (although his FO did say he was tired, but who knows whether he had just come on-line, or had been flying all day.) |
Quoting Goldenshield (Reply 7): You mean like, landing a 737 at minimums on a short runway during a blizzard? |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 6): This should flat out horrify the flying public. A very experienced pilot flew a difficult flight and then was instructed to repeat the trip 5 hours later... at 4:40am? In bad weather? Without prior notification? Everything else aside, that is just flat out asking for an NTSB Accident Report. Of course hindsight about the way he handled it is 20/20, but the situation stands simply at the fact that this is a dangerous situation no matter who the pilots are and he recognized this and tried to protect himself, his crew, and his passengers. He was then reprimanded, suspended, and ultimately fired? Do you want to fly on an airline that fires its employees for making safety related decisions? (Even if they weren't perfect when you look back on it?) I'd much rather have him as my pilot... someone who stands up for safety... than someone who bows into pressure from the company and ends up hitting the side of a mountain at 5am in a snowstorm. |
Quoting Jayspilot (Reply 12): This is a perfect example of why ALPA or another union is worth it. This pilot was left to fight on his own for his rights and was hung out to dry by his Airline. With no Union, things are great when everyone agrees, but when it is the company vs one pilot things get lop sided quickly. |
Quoting Jayspilot (Reply 12): This is a perfect example of why ALPA or another union is worth it. This pilot was left to fight on his own for his rights and was hung out to dry by his Airline. With no Union, things are great when everyone agrees, but when it is the company vs one pilot things get lop sided quickly. |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 2): Writing profantities on company equipment would seem a good way to get terminated. The pilot can declare himself unfit to fly but not both crew members.. |
Quoting Drewwright (Reply 15): I have to agree. A pilot that calls in fatigued for legitimate reasons will be backed 110% by the union and fellow pilots. There is a great deal of anti-union sentiment on this forum, but this case is a classic example of why unions are necessary in our industry. This guy called in fatigued, was framed with bogus charges, and was then left to his own devices. It never would have gone that far if this happened at a unionized company. If I call in fatigued or otherwise unfit to fly, I feel confident that the union and the FAR's will back me up. |
Quoting Highflier92660 (Reply 16): This story contains interesting interpersonal elements apart from the superficial airline safety issues of duty time and flying a turboprop into known icing conditions. Further, whether or not Captain Don Douglas should be reinstated should be determined by a judicial official that is knowledgeable in airline operations and meteorology. The article says nothing of Judge Russell Pulver's background. Reading through this and other postings on the Internet one gets the impression of a personality clash taking place between a guy in his late forties still stuck flying regional airline Brazilias all hours of the night, through wintertime cold fronts, into mountainous airports, and his slightly younger Chief Pilot who, when he isn't at SkyWest, is flying a helicopter for a Salt Lake television station and getting media face time as Mr. Super Pilot. It isn't difficult to extrapolate that Captain Douglas on the night in question probably didn't ooze aeronautical enthusiasm as he checked into dispatch. His attitude, after checking the JAC meteorological conditions, could have become infectious. His F/O came down with a sudden onset of cronic fatique syndrome and their flight attendant Brandee Black reported her arthritis becoming particularly acute. SkyWest was becoming the regional airline equivalent of the National Football League injury reserve list. But they fought through physical distress like dedicated airline employees and off they went to Jackson Hole. And what did they get for all their effort? ATC gave them a holding pattern, perhaps while they attempt to clear the snow on the JAC runway or the winds/crosswind component lowered to acceptable landing standards. Sometime between a teardrop entry into the holding pattern and the decision to return to SLC it's not a stretch to say the Brazilia cockpit became infected with a profusion of BAD WORDS. Yes profanity; about their airline's dispatch, management and his brown nosing Chief Pilot in particular and maybe life in general. As he checked for rime ice accumulation and his Brazilia's fuel supply, the thought may have crossed Captain Douglas that (well into his forties) he was flying a [email protected]# [email protected]#n 30 passenger turboprop into Jackson Hole instead of a Boeing 747-400 into Sydney or Paris. As the evening wore on toward midnight the fatigued and psychologically drained crew diverted back to Salt Lake. In the dark and silent cockpit Captain Don Douglas felt a dull ache, a painful throbbing sensation grow...and grow between his loins. The physician was wrong about the degree of discomfort his vasectomy operation would yield; his balls hurt like hell! When the crew blocked-in back at SLC and completed their paperwork what was their reward? A flight back to JAC through the same weather scheduled five hours later at 4:40 am. The odds of that crew accepting that flight were as likely as turkeys flying with eagles. |
Quoting Checksixx (Reply 17): Yes, the PIC can declare himself and others unfit to fly (at least in the US anyways). Just because the PIC may not be right, doesn't mean they don't have the power to do it. |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 14): t is clear the issue was NOT that he chose not to fly. The issue was the profanities and graffiti on company property. I would find it interesting to see the actual evidence. Three groups including OSHA found he did write profanities on company property. Only this judge differred. It will be interesting to follow. But, It is clear at NO POINT was he terminated for refusing the trip. He was repremanded for calling in the full crew. Each crew member should call themselves in not the captain making a call for all of them. He responded to the reprimand with profanities and graffiti on company owned property. |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 14): Oh Please.... He was NOT terminated for refusing the flight. If ALPA is going to defend pilots writing profanities on company property, then..... ALPA is not and was not a part of this and it would not have made a difference. How many pilots were terminated in the last 10 years per 1000 at Skywest, at ASA, at Comair... Sorry, the fact is more pilots were terminated at ALPA unionized COMAIR then SKYWEST. The argument is moot. |
Quoting BlueSkys (Reply 21): They Canned him b/c they are pissed off he lost money for the company by not flying.... Skywest does not want "Safe" pilots, they want pilots that will make them money... |
Quoting CWAFlyer (Reply 22): Quoting BlueSkys (Reply 21): They Canned him b/c they are pissed off he lost money for the company by not flying.... Skywest does not want "Safe" pilots, they want pilots that will make them money... Do you work for SkyWest? Have you read the court document? Do you know Don or anyone else involved with the case? I didn't think so. |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 23): I'm going to have to back up BlueSkys on this one. My company makes decisions DAILY in the name of costs that decrease safety. Its kind of the running joke around this place that we always fly safe, unless it costs extra. |
Quoting Highflier92660 (Reply 16): It isn't difficult to extrapolate that Captain Douglas on the night in question probably didn't ooze aeronautical enthusiasm as he checked into dispatch. His attitude, after checking the JAC meteorological conditions, could have become infectious. His F/O came down with a sudden onset of cronic fatique syndrome and their flight attendant Brandee Black reported her arthritis becoming particularly acute. SkyWest was becoming the regional airline equivalent of the National Football League injury reserve list. But they fought through physical distress like dedicated airline employees and off they went to Jackson Hole. |
Quoting CWAFlyer (Reply 24): Then I suggest you read the court document and educate yourself as to what happened. I really don't know what you or BlueSkys are basing your comments on since you obviously do not work for SkyWest (and therefore do not know any of the parties involved) and do not know all the facts. |
Quoting BlueSkys (Reply 21): Please PROVE to me that he wrote the profanities........ They Canned him b/c they are pissed off he lost money for the company by not flying.... Skywest does not want "Safe" pilots, they want pilots that will make them money... If he flew, and the plane crashed, insurance would pay back more then the loss, including lawsuits, and the plane crash would have been blamed on "Fatigue", Skywest would have walked away with ZERO loss and no bad publicity... These corporate jack asses care more about money then lives, and it is very clear to me that the reason they fired him was b/c of the self-grounding. Besides, there is no evidence to link him to the profanities aside from here-say... |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 20): There is no way the profanities are the reason why he was fired. Maybe they were the "official" reason that management was looking for to fire him, but they were not what he was actually terminated over. |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 20): My workplace is covered in profanities... our crewroom walls, posted memos from the company, bathroom walls, inside of the cargo holds, etc... they've all been scribbled on. No, I don't like it and I'm not defending it, but if management was firing people over it... you'd see people being escorted out the front door every single day. |
Quoting Flyf15 (Reply 20): He made a difficult and unpopular decision, but it was the right one. I personally commend him... this is what being a successful captain (and leader in general) is all about. |
Quoting MPDPilot (Reply 26): Do you work for Skywest? Have you read the court document? If so then please educate us. I may not work for skywest but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to know how a company works and to an extent yes companies worry about the bottomline and thats about it. Now you can say that all they do is speculate, but give me something to say that you aren't speculating. I will also add that probably 90% of the stuff on this forum is speculation so it is kind of the territory your in so I would have to say deal with it. |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 27):
Quoting BlueSkys (Reply 21): Please PROVE to me that he wrote the profanities........ They Canned him b/c they are pissed off he lost money for the company by not flying.... Skywest does not want "Safe" pilots, they want pilots that will make them money... If he flew, and the plane crashed, insurance would pay back more then the loss, including lawsuits, and the plane crash would have been blamed on "Fatigue", Skywest would have walked away with ZERO loss and no bad publicity... These corporate jack asses care more about money then lives, and it is very clear to me that the reason they fired him was b/c of the self-grounding. Besides, there is no evidence to link him to the profanities aside from here-say... Now you have crossed the line |
Quoting CWAFlyer (Reply 22):
Do you work for SkyWest? Have you read the court document? Do you know Don or anyone else involved with the case? I didn't think so. |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 27): The original handwriting anaylsis tied him to the profanities |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 27): You must work in a miserable enviroment to feel the way you do |
Quoting ACVitale (Reply 14): Oh Please.... He was NOT terminated for refusing the flight. If ALPA is going to defend pilots writing profanities on company property, then..... ALPA is not and was not a part of this and it would not have made a difference. How many pilots were terminated in the last 10 years per 1000 at Skywest, at ASA, at Comair... Sorry, the fact is more pilots were terminated at ALPA unionized COMAIR then SKYWEST. The argument is moot. |
Quoting CWAFlyer (Reply 28): Yes I work for SkyWest and yes, I have read the court document. I suggest you do the same and find out why Don was terminated (unfairly) instead of telling me what happened based on what goes on at your company or because of a newspaper article headline/thread title. |