Moderators: jsumali2, richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
Quoting BEG2IAH (Reply 2): Lack of E+ type seating makes me avoid LH. I had to beg a guy in front of me to not recline his seat. I felt for him, but I had to work during the whole 9-hour flight. |
Quoting vhtje (Reply 7): That makes me very uneasy. Why should the person in front of you suffer discomfort because you had to work and wouldn't/couldn't fly business class? Whilst I sympathise with your position, I think asking the person in front not to recline during the entirety of a 9-hour flight is both highly presumptuous and extremely rude of you. Had I been the person in front, I would have apologised but politely declined your request. |
Quoting flybyguy (Reply 10): Don't understand why Premium Economy is marketable to business fliers who's companies won't pony up the dough for business class. Most, if not all those companies will only pay for the cheapest seat available, which is never premium economy anyway |
Quoting vhtje (Reply 7): That makes me very uneasy. Why should the person in front of you suffer discomfort because you had to work and wouldn't/couldn't fly business class? Whilst I sympathise with your position, I think asking the person in front not to recline during the entirety of a 9-hour flight is both highly presumptuous and extremely rude of you |
Quoting Ferroviarius (Reply 13): I like very much SAS Premium Economy version called "Economy Extra" |
Quoting BEG2IAH (Reply 2): Lack of E+ type seating makes me avoid LH. I had to beg a guy in front of me to not recline his seat. I felt for him, but I had to work during the whole 9-hour flight. |
Quoting BEG2IAH (Reply 2): Lack of E+ type seating makes me avoid LH. I had to beg a guy in front of me to not recline his seat. I felt for him, but I had to work during the whole 9-hour flight. |
Quoting flybyguy (Reply 10): Don't understand why Premium Economy is marketable to business fliers who's companies won't pony up the dough for business class. Most, if not all those companies will only pay for the cheapest seat available, which is never premium economy anyway. Most often than not the cheapest seat will be the middle seat at the very back of the airplane. I think premium economy might actually siphon customers away from business class if anything. |
Quoting csavel (Reply 11): So flying on a 9+ hour flight, it is worth it for me to shell out $200 bucks r/t not to feel like crap. |
Quoting photoshooter (Reply 16): Though I'm not so keen on having more than 3 cabins in one aircraft, I think this will be a (great) success for Lufthansa. |
Quoting JAAlbert (Reply 18): My experience is that premium economy is not just $200 more than coach - it is often $1,000 or more dollars per round trip ticket on an international segment. The difference on Qantas LAX to SYD for example is over $1,300 - and that's on sale. If your traveling with your partner/spouse you've just upped the cost of the trip alone by $2,600. Perhaps the premium international carriers offer greater amenities, but most of the airlines I've checked out the seats are no wider than economy seats. As a flyer who pays my own fare, would I pay an extra $200 per flight? Yeah. Would I pay $600 - $1000 more per flight? I wish I had the money, but usually I don't. |
Quoting danielkandi (Reply 15): Quoting Ferroviarius (Reply 13): I like very much SAS Premium Economy version called "Economy Extra" overpriced. I dont know what they think we want, overall. But that aint it. Its plain daylight robbing a wallet. |
Quoting raffik (Reply 12): Getting back to Y+- it does very well for BA. I do feel that their product falls behind Virgin's, which to me is like flying on some airline's business class. The worst I ever experienced was United Economy Gold which offered just a bigger seat but I still had to shell out $5 for a glass of wine with my meal.. it didn't feel very premium. |
Quoting danielkandi (Reply 14): Thank god tho, that they keep the premium on tk |
Quoting aloges (Reply 3): I think the SENs and HONs might hate it because it would probably mean that they get upgraded to premium economy instead of business, but for everyone who's willing to pay a reasonable premium for a slightly better seat, it could be a very good product. |
Quoting raffik (Reply 12): 9 hours is a long way to go in the upright position and must have been uncomfortable for the person ahead. |
Quoting vhtje (Reply 7): If the story about it being so profitable for BA is true, one wonders why other airlines have waited so long to introduce it. |
Quoting gabrielchew (Reply 26): I'm surpsied LH hasn't gone down the Y+ route before....however, we all know LH isn't exactly an innovator in this regard. When were PTVs in Y finally rolled out fully? Last year? Or are there still some 744 without? |
Quoting B777Neuss (Reply 20): Maybe they will offer their premium economy only on aircraft where there is no first anymore. A few weeks ago I read somewhere, could have been here, that they will extend their fleet with a two cabin layout. No first. So the A330 and A340 could be the aircraft for premium economy, because B748 and A380 should keep first class. But otherwise BA is successful with the four cabin layout. So we'll have to wait and see. |
Quoting gabrielchew (Reply 26): I flew back from Riyadh to London last weekend in Y, and the guy in front kept his seat upright the entire 8 hour night flight....odd. |
Quoting huxrules (Reply 6): Basically there are two kinds of business travelers - those who can still travel business and those who are forced to pick the cheapest flight on orbitz. |
Quoting Ferroviarius (Reply 22): Well, it still is considerably cheaper than Business and you can select the Flex or FullFlex fare, at which the former still is not sooo expensive. Same with BA. |
Quoting danielkandi (Reply 15): overpriced. I dont know what they think we want, overall. But that aint it. Its plain daylight robbing a wallet. |
Quoting LH4116 (Reply 31): It's just a merely enhanced Economy Class seat with a legrest that serves no purpose, and a fibre optic reading light to give the faux impression of Business Class. Same food as Y, same luggage and no lounge access, except that the seats will be priced 3x times of a regular Y ticket. |
Quoting gabrielchew (Reply 26): I flew back from Riyadh to London last weekend in Y, and the guy in front kept his seat upright the entire 8 hour night flight....odd. |
Quoting vhtje (Reply 7): That makes me very uneasy. Why should the person in front of you suffer discomfort because you had to work and wouldn't/couldn't fly business class? Whilst I sympathise with your position, I think asking the person in front not to recline during the entirety of a 9-hour flight is both highly presumptuous and extremely rude of you. Had I been the person in front, I would have apologised but politely declined your request. |
Quoting OB1504 (Reply 9): If the passenger behind me had to work, that is exactly what business class is intended for. |
Quoting flybyguy (Reply 10): Don't understand why Premium Economy is marketable to business fliers who's companies won't pony up the dough for business class. Most, if not all those companies will only pay for the cheapest seat available, which is never premium economy anyway. Most often than not the cheapest seat will be the middle seat at the very back of the airplane. I think premium economy might actually siphon customers away from business class if anything. |
Quoting raffik (Reply 12): I have to agree with your comments. I would recline my seat- if you had to work that desperately then you should be in Business Class. 9 hours is a long way to go in the upright position and must have been uncomfortable for the person ahead. |
Quoting photoshooter (Reply 16): Sorry to hear that but if I had to work in an aircraft for 9 hours, I would think about flying in Business class then. I'm aware that not every company has the ability to pay for expensive business class tickets but it's kind of a win-win situation for the company. The company will gain air miles which they can use for booking another business class ticket eventually. Also, I believe that the results will differ when working in Economy class for 9 hours or in Business class for 9 hours. |
Quoting AAIL86 (Reply 17): You would really ask someone in front of you on nine hour flight not to recline their seat so you'd have more room for your laptop?? I hope you shared some of the fruits of your labor with that person... I'm 6"4 (1.93m) and I when I travel in economy I would never insist that the person in front of me not recline their seat, despite the implications for my knees.... |
Quoting LH4116 (Reply 31): Lufthansa already have a Premium Economy class product today. It's called Business Class… Honestly speaking I've never been a fan of the Y+ concept. It's just a merely enhanced Economy Class seat with a legrest that serves no purpose, and a fibre optic reading light to give the faux impression of Business Class. Same food as Y, same luggage and no lounge access, except that the seats will be priced 3x times of a regular Y ticket. If your company books you into the flex classes in Y, the Y+ might be a nice bonus. But for the leisure traveler looking to have some extra comfort on his flight (which Y+ strangely is also targeted towards) it's an absolute robbery! |
Quoting BEG2IAH (Reply 35): Sorry I'm such a monster. This was the only time I did it and this is exactly why LH will not see me again before they do something about premium seats. |
Quoting BEG2IAH (Reply 35): After reading all these comments I feel like crap. |
Quoting BEG2IAH (Reply 2): I had to beg a guy in front of me to not recline his seat. |
Quoting connector4you (Reply 24): Turkish Economy Comfort Class: pitch 46.0" width 19.5" 111 degree recline /63 seats/ Boeing 777-300 version 2 |
Quoting AAIL86 (Reply 36): Well I wouldn't go so far as to say that and didn't think it when posting. However (in my opinion), the ability to recline one's seat a bit is an implied (yes, I understand that some seats do not recline at all - but that's about 5% or less of total seats) privilege of purchasing a ticket and makes up part of the space which each person it "entitled" to ... |
Quoting aloges (Reply 37): I see it most people skipped one important little word: |