Moderators: jsumali2, richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
Quoting IrishAyes (Reply 3): What about Asia, Oceania and Latin America flights? |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 1): Creating meals that can be successfully reconstituted in an airplane oven hours after they were cooked is a tough assignment. Things like pasta, stews, fish and some chicken entrees do the best. Steaks are a non-starter--they are tough and either raw or way over cooked. |
Quoting gonnagetbumpy (Reply 2): I think this is an interesting selection. The comments by Maneet Chauhan in the below article aren't very poised and don't inspire confidence in the selection or make me excited to try it. Also I think it is interesting to have a UK based chef; usually the UK isn't known for their 'good' food. |
Quoting gen2stew (Reply 8): Hoping for the best! Unless the "do it on the cheap/ America Worst" mindset is changed, this will be nothing more than chef branded slop or better known as lipstick on a pig. |
Quoting gonnagetbumpy (Reply 2): Also I think it is interesting to have a UK based chef; usually the UK isn't known for their 'good' food. |
Quoting gonnagetbumpy (Reply 2): The comments by Maneet Chauhan in the below article aren't very poised and don't inspire confidence in the selection or make me excited to try it. |
Quoting ckfred (Reply 6): I was on a cruise ship that week, and there were no lobster meat in my lobster bisque. |
Quoting Seat1F (Reply 9): Bingo. AA can bring on 20 new chefs to design new menus but unless they are willing to spend a lot more (think triple what the spend now) on premium cabin food and bevs, not much will change. The core problem isn't the chefs designing the menus, rather it is the amount of money AA is willing to spend on the actual food/bevs. |
Quoting TWA1985 (Reply 13): 09/01/2014 |
Quoting Seat1F (Reply 9): Bingo. AA can bring on 20 new chefs to design new menus but unless they are willing to spend a lot more (think triple what the spend now) on premium cabin food and bevs, not much will change. The core problem isn't the chefs designing the menus, rather it is the amount of money AA is willing to spend on the actual food/bevs. |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 1): But a lot depends on the flight attendant running the oven. You can always tell the ones that do not cook at home because they won't take the time to tweak the temperature or timing to get the best results. |
Quoting Seat1F (Reply 9): The core problem isn't the chefs designing the menus, rather it is the amount of money AA is willing to spend on the actual food/bevs. |
Quoting jsnww81 (Reply 17): It's a minor gripe and a total first-world problem, but the attention to detail from the caterers and flight crew usually just isn't there the way it is on other carriers. |
Quoting 9w748capt (Reply 5): Oh wow - LCC Dougie and Hector finally got the clue that their onboard product sucks? Only took two years. |
Quoting TVNWZ (Reply 16): I like your expert observation. And it is a belief I have had for some time. It's all in the end preparation and if you are not wise to the nuances that produce good tasting food you will not get it. This is particularly important when you consider the obstacles that get in the way just because it is being served at 40K feet in a tube. And this is totally overlooked by just about everyone commenting about food quality on airplanes. |
Quoting 9w748capt (Reply 18): Starts at the top IMO. The AA crews know that the suits couldn't give two shits about the onboard product and have seen how badly degraded it is from the legacy AA days, so there's minimal incentive for them to even try. |
Quoting ckfred (Reply 15): If you look at Cruise Critic, people complain that with the advent of specialty restaurants on cruise ships, food in the main dining room has suffered. |
Quoting jsnww81 (Reply 20): remember the fiasco about eliminating the second olive in the salads? If memory serves that was all the way back in the 1990s. |
Quoting coolian2 (Reply 21): This forum can sustain 20+ posts about premium food but dare mention Y food and the attitude is "ha, lucky you get anything". I love this place. |
Quoting jsnww81 (Reply 20): In fairness to the current AA leadership, the catering quality on legacy AA for the last 10-15 years was nothing to write home about, either. As far back as 2004-2005, I can remember getting food in F and J that was embarrassingly bad, served by crews who clearly didn't care about presentation or quality. |
Quoting ckfred (Reply 6): I had steak with lobster mac and cheese in late March on ORD-MIA. Have I had better steaks? Yes. But, the steak was better than many restaurants who tout their beef entrees |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 23): Main cabin food internationally admittedly is not a high priority. Quality and quantity has deteriorated over the years and domestically hot meals in YC are history. Over nearly 40 years I have served and picked up literally thousands of meal trays in coach and I cannot count how many times I heard "that was the WORST meal I have ever had on an airplane. I would rather eat nothing." Mind you his plate was clean but I just smile and say--be careful what you wish for. Now you do get nothing. |
Quoting 9w748capt (Reply 11): Still stuck in the 1980s? So much has changed since then. |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 1): Steaks are a non-starter--they are tough and either raw or way over cooked. |
Quoting AAplat4life (Reply 24): For some reason, the food on ORD-MIA is usually very good. I once had sea bass that was outstanding. I had the steak with lobster mac recently from DFW-ORD, and it was dreadful. One of the Chicago business publications recently compared premium meals on United vs. AA. I don't recall if there was a clear winner, but the bad steak offered by AA was noted. |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 19): I shudder to think what we would find if we ever stuck our food with a thermometer--we are probably serving botulism around the world. |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 19): I worked closely with Hector Adler at NW--he is probably the finest Inflight VP today in the industry. We would kill to have him back. Unfortunately, his decisions are generally based on budget constraints placed by people higher in the food chain. |
Quoting n7371f (Reply 31): AA has a group of people on Amon Carter that are Six Sigma trained who do nothing by crunch numbers on catering. |
Quoting gen2stew (Reply 27): Speaking of Y food, one bright spot for AA is the LAX- SYD catering, both crews and pax are complimenting if not actually enjoying the new menu, portions, and style of service. |
Quoting AAplat4life (Reply 32): When my omelette on LAX-ORD was tough and swimming in oil, the F/A said they had nothing else to give me and told me that I should write in and complain. I logged on to gogo, sent an email, and got back a response from someone in Phoenix about food portions in corporate-speak. Obviously, they did not want to hear about the issue or admit it, but I do think that there has been enough complaints that management is finally listening. |
Quoting gen2stew (Reply 27): Speaking of Y food, one bright spot for AA is the LAX- SYD catering, both crews and pax are complimenting if not actually enjoying the new menu, portions, and style of service. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Quoting AAplat4life (Reply 32): Apparently, Qantas told AA that it needed to improve the food service. I don't know if it was a condition to agreeing to code-share. However, if you listen to Doug Parker's interview on CAPA, he comes right out and states that oneworld partners told him that the AA product and service needed improving (his words were blunter than mine). |
Quoting TWA1985 (Reply 13): Does anyone here have data on what AA spent per passenger on premium cabin meals pre-09/01/2014 and after? |
Quoting DTWPurserBoy (Reply 19): For example, Hector and I had a discussion about wine that is served aboard the plane. He said that he frequently gets a name or a label or sometime a whole bottle of a wine that someone feels would be a good fit. Sometimes even the price point is right. But the trouble develops when they ask the vineyard to supply 60,000 CASES of that wine--every three months. Yup--we use a lot of wine. Very few vineyards can accommodate the quantities needed. |
Quoting jsnww81 (Reply 20): AA was cutting catering budgets (and quality) long before the merger was a twinkle in anyone's eye - remember the fiasco about eliminating the second olive in the salads? If memory serves that was all the way back in the 1990s. |
Quoting jsnww81 (Reply 17): but the attention to detail from the caterers and flight crew usually just isn't there the way it is on other carriers. |
Quoting superjeff (Reply 33): I fly AA regularly and find their domestic F meals are at least adequate. |
Quoting AirDFW (Reply 36): I hope AA's other partners make the same demand |
Quoting N62NA (Reply 40): I don't believe that statement is correct. |
Quoting 9w748capt (Reply 41): Any proof to the contrary? |
Quoting 9w748capt (Reply 41): Wow - you must like terrible food. I'm sure the AA bean counters love FFs like you! |